Loading...

Please wait ...

Reviews (684)

Leave a review
K

Kianadon ..

14 September 2019

The food and atmosphere is absolutely perfect! Had the spaghetti carbonara and it was delicious! They lit it on fire and mixed it with a cheese wheel tableside! The pre-meal bread was delightful and they did a wonderful job keeping my water glass full (soft drinks are bottles poured on ice). The only downside was our server who seemed like we were putting her out and our carbonara mixer who apologized for his nose running over our food. Other than the odd vibes from the servers, we can't wait to come back. More...

A

Allison Cruz Rud

14 September 2019

fantastic service, very polite management, delicious food. if you want the basics go to olive garden. if you want traditional, authentic, sicilian cuisine, go to Sicilia Mia.

D

Dede D.

13 September 2019

We stopped by for lunch without a reservation, 30 minutes before closing and were warmly welcomed. We ordered the rice balls appetizer, parmesan wheel carbonara and spaghetti Bolognese. They also included bread with 1 tiny teaspoon of red sauce for dipping. The bread was disappointing as it seemed like day-old sourdough, but that didn't stop us. We ate every crumb. The carbonara in the cheese wheel is impressive to watch and delicious. The pancetta in it was undercooked and just flappy bacon fat. I worked around it and other than that the dish was delicious, very rich and cheesy. The Bolognese was my favorite, simple, classic perfection. The servings were generous and the service was excellent. I wish they had fountain drinks. The Diet Coke was served from plastic bottles like you pick up at 7-11, except they charged triple what they cost at 7-11. It's a special occasion place for our budget and we will be back! More...

Z

Zak Curtis

10 September 2019

was really happy with the service and it was really good food

S

Sarah V.

8 September 2019

I went there last night with a friend and we had an amazing experience. All of the staff (not just our waiter) were incredibly welcoming and nice. I had brought my 8 month old daughter with us and several members of the staff stopped and talked with her! They made her just as welcome and comfortable as they made me and my friend which is a huge deal in my book. Plus the food was hands down amazing! I had some seafood pasta in a white wine sauce that was absolutely heavenly. Thanks for making it such an enjoyable night! More...

D

Drew R.

7 September 2019

I've been to their other locations, and I loved it. My coworker was leaving so we wanted to celebrated and go somewhere nice. We decide to go to the downtown location cause it was nicer looking. I do recommend getting a reservation if you have a big group. We didn't, but luckily there wasn't many people eating lunch there. The place was decorated very nice. The waiter was nice. They were Very helpful if you have any question with the menu or anything. I think it's perfect for a date too.The menu here is smaller than the menu of their older location. But I understand why they did it this way. Even though the menu is smaller it isn't lacking. I got their squid ink pasta. It was amazing. The squid ink coated each noodle. They had some calamari cooked into the sauce. The squid ink itself doesn't have much of a taste, but it does inherit the taste of the base sauce very well. It tasted like a seafood tomato garlic sauce. I love the finishing touch of a giant shrimp. Totally worth coming here to eat. More...

B

Brian B.

7 September 2019

We drove by this place on a Saturday night and decided to try it out.  We didn't have a reservation.  The place was very lively and full.  The host was very accommodating and said he will do his best to get use a table.  While we waited they brought samples of appetizers around to the people waiting and made sure everyone was taken care of.  We actually got seated very quickly.   I ordered the pasta carbonara.   It was very good.  The presentation of the food with the food wheel was great.  The waiters even sang a bit and you could tell that they really enjoyed what they were doing.  Overall it was a great experience and the food was excellent.  One warning - parking is limited.  I was told you could park next door in the car wash parking lot, which I did without any hassles or issues. More...

K

Kiran B.

3 September 2019

Good Italian fare, vegetarian and family friendly. Avoid busy time, just plan. Quality of food very good. Will visit again. Ambiance moderate.

E

Erik M.

2 September 2019

Ordered the tagliere del padrino and split it with a coworker. Our platter came out timely and was much larger than I anticipated. I really enjoyed the mozzarella and our server Claudio. He was kind and entertaining. This place needs more servers like Claudio. More...

J

Jennie T.

1 September 2019

Wonderful food and great customer service. They are great to accommodate large groups also.

B

Bud S.

29 August 2019

I happened on this restaurant along time ago and was extremely pleased in taking people to this restaurant and sharing I'd love it excellent service

J

Joe G.

28 August 2019

What a great find. I travel to Utah every 3 months or so and always find gems. This is the latest. Great atmosphere, all the wait staff was very friendly, and the food was delicious. Traveling alone is sometimes difficult to get seated at busy restaurants when they don't have a bar. That is thr only negative. But they literally pulled out a new table, dressed it, and sat me promptly. I couldn't have been more impressed. Order the carbonara and prepare to be delighted. More...

K

Kate M.

24 August 2019

One of the best meals I've ever had. The entire staff is phenomenal. They were so kind and attentive, really treating us like family- joking and taking pictures for us. The food was excellent. We started with the Aubergine rolls and Bruschetta, followed by the table-side Spaghetti Carbonara and the Filet Mignon is Funghi and finished by taking profiteroles and cannoli to go.  We closed the place down and it was an amazing way to spend a girls evening out. More...

R

Raquel C.

21 August 2019

I have been to this location several times and the experience there is always great and their food is incredible. Among my visits we have tried Frito misto (loved the arancine) ravioli ai funghi, sage and butter ravioli, of course the famous carbonara and others. The atmosphere is incredible, service is great, definitely an authentic Italian restaurante. Highly recommend this place:) More...

L

Lendle H.

13 August 2019

I had never been to Sicilia Mia until recently, and I am so happy that I had the chance to go. It was a Monday evening so it was empty and we practically had the place to ourselves. I ordered the Spaghetti Carbonara and it was the coolest thing to watch prepare it for you on a giant block of cheese. Every single bite was delicious and it was so creamy, that I couldn't take any more bites. We ended the night with some strawberry cheesecake after looking at a great dessert cart. But truly the highlight of my evening was being served and taken care of by Claudio! He was an absolute delight and was so friendly and attentive to our table. If you enjoy conversing and laughing with your server, Claudio is the person you want. He took such good care of us that I would be thrilled to visit again, and the delicious food is a great bonus. More...

V

Vincent G.

12 August 2019

This has been an amazing experience not just with the food but with the customer service. They treated us like we were Family. Our server did a fantastic job making sure we were always happy and then not only that the manager Francesco was super upbeat and friendly and was always making sure everything was perfect and it was. We had tons of questions about the menu and he was so excited to explain everything to us, this is very hard to find nowadays. thank you so much for the awesome experience. More...

S

Sheila Erickson

11 August 2019

We went here for the first time for our 29th Anniversary. The food was off the chart delicious and the service was amazing! I would highly recommend this for a magnificent dining experience! More...

S

Sheila Erickson

11 August 2019

We went here for the first time for our 29th Anniversary. The food was off the chart delicious and the service was amazing! I would highly recommend this for a magnificent dining experience! More...

C

Carrie Sitzmann

9 August 2019

I’m a foodie... and this was probably the best meal I’ve ever had. My husband had the steak and mushrooms, and I had the carbonara. Everything was perfect, (minus the artichokes as a side). They were canned and disappointing. Vincenzo was amazing. It’s my new favorite place. More...

C

Carrie Sitzmann

9 August 2019

I’m a foodie... and this was probably the best meal I’ve ever had. My husband had the steak and mushrooms, and I had the carbonara. Everything was perfect, (minus the artichokes as a side). They were canned and disappointing. Vincenzo was amazing. It’s my new favorite place. More...

C

Catherine Cope

8 August 2019

Came here for my sister's birthday and pleasantly surprised. Amazing service, delicious food!

S

Sabrina F.

8 August 2019

Wow! Amazing food and amazing service. They gave us a warm welcoming vegitable soup when we arrived and fresh homemade bread. We had the gnocchi gorgonzola and ravioli sage and butter with the tartufo Nero (truffle), they were both divine! We finished with a strawberry and chocolate desert which were to die for! Claudio, our server, was delightful and so kind. He really cares and loves his job. He loves the food and the people. Definitely bringing my friends and family here! More...

T

Tara M.

8 August 2019

This review is going to be very short- pasta carbonara twirled in a wheel of Parmesan. That's all you need to know.

C

Catherine Cope

8 August 2019

Came here for my sister's birthday and pleasantly surprised. Amazing service, delicious food!

S

Shana W.

7 August 2019

Amazing food, amazing service, great wine list! Will definitely come back to try more dishes. The Italian atmosphere was tip top! Thanks crew!

J

Justin Sparacino

5 August 2019

Awesome place to drink wine and eat the most authentic food ever

K

Kevin B.

3 August 2019

The servers were incredibly polite and knowledgable of the menu. Having never been to Italy or Sicily, food seems authentic! Especially compared to Olive Garden or Pasta Roni. The filet mignon appetizer was good, but odd because we weren't expecting it to be served raw. The arugula and parmesan on it helped compliment the dish with the saltiness, the filet with the savory flavor, and the oil for the fatty flavor.The spaghetti truffle and the spaghetti carbonara dishes were partially prepared tableside in a melted cheese wheel. The cheese and pasta was tasty, the black truffles were aight. The prestige of eating the was enough. My partners spaghetti carbonara was served with generous portions of pancetta. Overall, our experience with Sicillia Mia was bougie and great! More...

K

Kirstin H.

3 August 2019

The food is amazing and our waiter Claudio was attentive, cheery, delightful, amazing, and hilarious.

M

Max Hernandez Ruiz

2 August 2019

so delicious go there and try it✌

M

Max Hernandez Ruiz

2 August 2019

so delicious go there and try it✌

J

Joe G.

1 August 2019

The food is outstanding. Each time we eat here it reminds us of the amazing flavors and food we experienced as we traveled in Italy. Our server Claudio really pushed the experience over the top with his passion for every detail on the menu and engaging Italian style. He was the best. More...

T

Tamatha Molyneux

1 August 2019

Excellent food. Felt like I was back in Sicily. ❤️

D

Dhara J.

1 August 2019

The hubs decided to surprise me on a random Thursday and I was super excited when I saw where we were pulling in. To his surprise the place had a long wait and we did not have reservations. We put our name down and they said that they'd let us know and to come back in about an hour. We drove away to grab a drink and in about 30 minutes we were called to come back. I'm so glad we went back. We decided to go all out with a three course meal. We started with the bruschetta. This was one of the best versions of one I've had. They also gave us some table bread with a couple of spreads. We ordered one pizza as well as the gnocchi in Gorgonzola sauce. The pizza was amazing! We could see them pulling them piping hot of the oven and straight over to our table. They do the traditional thin crust with the perfect char. The gnocchi was delicious as well. I did feel like it was slightly over sauced and the sauce was a bit on the salty side. They were kind enough to fix it. I did notice that things are a bit on the salty side even for us. (My husband and I typically like our food salty.) The tiramisu was the cherry on top to this meal. The down side is that this place is a little on the pricy side however for an occasional meal for a splurge it's totally okay. We had plenty of leftovers since they give large portion sizes and the service is great. I'm definitely going to go again to try other things on their menu. More...

D

Denise Hamblen

31 July 2019

Gracious service and delicious food made for a wonderful birthday dinner! Thank you!

M

Milo P.

30 July 2019

The food here is phenomenal, and the service was mostly excellent. I had the Spaghetti Carbonara, which is their signature dish. Ordering this dish in particular makes your experience feel extra fancy because they bring out a large wheel of cheese, light it on fire, and role your Spaghetti in the cheese wheel right in front of you. The only minor complaint I had were the portion sizes. It wasn't that they were too small, it was that 3 people at my table ordered the same dish and we all had completely different portion sizes. However, it is still a must try for delicious pasta, especially if you're looking for a high end feeling experience while paying a relatively small amount (~$25/plate), all while wearing jeans and a t-shirt. More...

C

Cynthia Steinkirchner McComber

28 July 2019

Fun fun night with the family. Loved the hospitality, the singing and the food!

C

Cynthia Steinkirchner McComber

28 July 2019

Fun fun night with the family. Loved the hospitality, the singing and the food!

E

Eduardo M.

27 July 2019

This is by far one of the coolest and best restaurants I have been to in Salt Lake City. Hands down the greatest. Service was awesome our waiter was awesome this place almost brought me to tears how awesome they are and the food. OMG the food was incredible. I would recommend any Italian food lovers to come check them out. We will be back Claudio was our waiter best one hands down. Thanks so much Claudio More...

J

Jordan W.

27 July 2019

Best Italian in SLC! Our server was even better! Absolutely loved Claudio and how he treated us like family! Would come again and request him as our waiter hands down!

J

Jennifer Arismendi

27 July 2019

Excellent Food, amazing service!

L

Lisa Baer Kimes

26 July 2019

Highly recommend!! Very fun place to go!!

M

Matthew L.

23 July 2019

We really love this place.  I love the Carbonara and all their specialties are out of this world.  Service is incredible and they really know how to present what you order.  The only reason that I didn't give this location 5 stars is they don't have a pizza oven.  The experience isn't the same without it, because their pizza is out of this world. More...

A

Aaron W.

23 July 2019

This was our second visit to Sicilia Mia. Our server was friendly and attentive, and the manager who checked on us during our meal was helpful and personable. We got the bruschetta again, which was amazing. Probably my favorite in the valley. We also got the lasagne, which my wife really liked (as did my three-year-old, and he's very picky). The carbonara was good, and the tableside presentation adds a nice flair to the dish. It was rich and creamy, but I felt it lacked a certain depth of flavor I've had in other carbonaras elsewhere. Overall, a bit pricey for what you get in my opinion, but a great dining experience. More...

R

Randall Scott

22 July 2019

very very very good Carbonara

R

Randall Scott

22 July 2019

very very very good Carbonara

J

Jesse T.

20 July 2019

We had a great dinning experience. I really wasn't keeping expectations to high but they delivered. Waiter was great and friendly. The food was delicious and food was perfectly cooked (minus the "turned" prawns) I'll be back! More...

L

Lulu C.

10 July 2019

An artistic display of food only paralleled by the magnifico taste. The wait staff was amazing particularly Vincenzo's, the outstanding maitre'd and carbonara chef extraordinaire! The food was delightfully fresh with subtle hints of the tender touch they have with herbs and spices. Make it a point to go to any of the Sicilia Mia restaurants - it is a taste of Italy at its finest More...

W

Wayne P.

3 July 2019

Hands down one of the best sit down restaurants we have been at in Utah.  The service and food was amazing and we have added this to our list of go to restaurants every time we are at Snowbird.  Make sure to get the Carbonara as it is out of this world.  So glad my nieces husband told us of this place otherwise we would have had no idea. More...

J

Jessica V.

27 June 2019

So good! The service is always great and everything I've tried has been fantastic! The carbonara is absolutely delicious!

B

Blake S.

25 June 2019

Real authentic Italian.  The olive oil dips for your bread are awesome.   Carbonara is the best.

T

Tony J. Washington

15 June 2019

Love this place! Delicious food. Great serving size... Great service. I wish there was a little more Cabernet in that glass for $15.00 but it was tasty! Highly recommend More...

T

Tony R.

15 June 2019

I've been waiting to try this place for a while now, finally made it. We had a reservation at 6 but had to wait about 15 minutes for a table. The host was very apologetic though and offered us some complimentary bruschetta. For our starter we had the tagliere burrata with prosciutto, the flavors complimented each other nicely. My wife ordered the filet mignon, she said it was cooked to perfection, very tender and flavorful, it was smothered in a creamy mushroom sauce that was delicious, also came with fresh grilled vegetables, her only disappointment was that it did not come with potatoes, apparently they changed the menu and no longer offer potatoes of any preparation. My daughter and I ordered the special which was a fettuccine dish in a creamy Rosa sauce with shrimp, scallops, and lobster tail, it was good but it was more hands on than I expected for a pasta dish, I had to dehead and devein the shrimp, and scrape the meat out of the lobster tail, not a big deal at a seafood shack, but when covered with a cream Rosa sauce it was a little messier than I wanted to get. All in all though, it was a good meal. The staff was very friendly and attentive. We will be back. More...

C

Chuck H.

14 June 2019

We were visiting from California and our party of 8 decided to take my daughter here for her 27th birthday. When our waiter Claudio, came to our table, we were immediately excited to find this would be an authentic experience. Claudio was what made this whole evening worth the visit. He was patient to explain the specials and to answer any question we had. From the moment we met him, it seemed like he wanted us to remember this evening. The food was great. The carbonara prepared at the table was the best I've had. The servers were quick to refill our drinks, and the atmosphere was inviting. We would come back again on our next visit, and would most definitely request to sit in Claudio's section. More...

S

Shane B.

11 June 2019

Truly as much an experience as a wonderful meal! The table side pastas are as wonderfully balanced and tasty as they are huge! The Arancini is a do not miss dish with an old world flavor that requires great ingredients, skill and time. Can't wait to return! More...

S

Shannon Y.

11 June 2019

This place is amazing! Have been here a few times. The prosciutto and rice balls are my favorite appetizers. I highly recommend the Flaming Wheel of Cheese.   Slow roasted pancetta tossed with an egg cream sauce and spaghetti noodles. Then tossed in the cheese wheel by the Italian guy The fungi raviolis are to die for!!!! More...

S

Susan R.

10 June 2019

Excellent service, food and wine during my business trip to SLC. I found Sicilia Mia via Yelp, of course! I ordered the filet mignonette with fungus (mushroom sauce) and a side of potatoes. I didn't realize the steak comes with mixed veggies, which include mashed potatoes. YUM!!! All around a great experience with excellent food and wine. Lucky me to have Roberto at the bar, who served me an excellent red wine!! Great food service from Patrick, I'll be back! More...

J

Jodi Lewis Jensen

9 June 2019

Wonderful service, delicious food, fun atmosphere. Very friendly

S

Sam Neumeier

8 June 2019

Food was fantastic and staff was very welcoming, friendly and knowledgeable. Be prepared to pay over $20 a plate though.

J

Jared K.

7 June 2019

I recommend the Holladay location unless you live close. This restaurant feels like you are eating in a hallway. Holladay has a true restaurant ambience.The Bisteca ai Funghi is amazing.For appetizers the Bruschetta is quite good. More...

L

Lauren H.

6 June 2019

I don't know where to start. I came home and told my husband that my girl friends and I were treated like queens at Sicilia Mia downtown. The staff was absolutely wonderful, the service was genuine and authentic. The food speaks for itself, absolutely AMAZING! I wish I could give this restaurant 10 stars. Great price for the most authentic Italian food. My friend and I shared the carbonara, so that picture is a 1/2 portion! More...

J

Joshlyne C.

5 June 2019

New favorite place for sure. They where pretty busy but really fast! No long wait. I was very impressed. You get a total family vibe but it is a upscale place. U can totally wear jeans n a shirt but get a nice experience. The bread & dips as s snack was sooo good! I got the cheese wheel pasta. Omg  it was so tasty! My daughter got the ravioli & it was also soooo good! (I had to steal a few bites) BUT, the fresh mozzarella that came with her ravioli omg, it was seriously the best mozzarella iv ever had. I could have ate 20lbs of it lol. The chefs where so sweet as well and OBVIOUSLY love what they do! I will most definitely be back! VERY soon! More...

A

Anita Hencke

4 June 2019

Great food. Nice place/atmosphere.

D

Deb D.

3 June 2019

Finding great Authentic Italian is difficult in Utah. Add homemade to the mix snd your chances are even less. I ordered gnocchi with pistachio cream sauce - yum. Ample serving size, and superbly light. More...

M

Marci F.

1 June 2019

We just found our new favorite Italian restaurant!!!  Everything was spot on, from the service to the food.  The hostess was very friendly and personable.  Our server was excellent and made excellent suggestions. More...

M

Manuella Martin

28 May 2019

Food is great, They help feed me homeless in Salt Lake City, UT... Thank you... spend your money there.

M

Manuella Martin

28 May 2019

Food is great, They help feed me homeless in Salt Lake City, UT... Thank you... spend your money there.

B

Brad C.

28 May 2019

We really wanted to go there on Memorial Day, but they were closed, I had to drive there to find out, the voice mail did not say anything, and was full.  It's a wonderful place to eat, I will be back! More...

D

D. W.

25 May 2019

This place reminds me a lot of what the place on Highland used to be, before the renovation. While that location has taken a slight downturn, this one is hitting on all cylinders and is probably instantly in the running for the best Italian place in Utah. The appetizers and the bread, all very, very nice, the serenading waiter, the ambiance, all magnifico. The gnocchi I went with was a touch on the soft side, enough so that it bordered on mush. Didn't enjoy that a whole great deal. Sauce was rich, borderline too rich and I could have used a lot more of the seafood in it, but it didn't diminish from the experience a touch...just instead will serve as a reminder to order something else next time and there will be a next time. That I promise you. Oh yes, there will be. More...

K

Kyle I.

22 May 2019

Have enjoyed the holiday location. This new location downtown is even more elegant. Food has always been 5 stars in 4 previous visits.

S

Shawn Alfonsi

18 May 2019

Great food and service! Love Katie! ❤️

M

Maureen M.

17 May 2019

Was in town for 2 weeks. Started and ended with dinner here. First time with a large group, lots of food and wine. Last night dinner for two. Highlights were wine and carbonara. Dessert and espresso too! Dont miss the best Italian in SLC. More...

S

Stephanie L.

16 May 2019

Cena Fantastica!! This dinner was probably one of the best Italian dinners I might have had in my life - and that includes Italy. It follows the traditional serving sequence. The pasta was fresh, the sauces creamy and meaty. So specifics... have you ever had your spaghetti made table side? Well that's how they do it-- hot pasta put in the Parmesan roll and then light a flame to melt it all together- amazing. This is not to take away from the chicken and tagliatelle which were served right with the spaghetti in perfect timing. Georgio provided personal service- actually the entire service staff was attentive. More...

M

Mylan D.

15 May 2019

It's a little overrated if you ask me. It's more like 3.5 stars, but I rounded up. The star of this place is the pasta is spun inside this enormous melted cheese wheel! The only downside is that there there are only 2 dishes that you can get to witness the cheese wheel entertainment. Carbonara or spaghetti. I ordered the carbonara at the Holladay location and it was just ok. I wanted to check out something different on the menu and ordered the gnocchi al pistacchio. It was a nice surprise to see that each gnocchi was stuffed with bits of porcini mushrooms. Delicious. My friend ordered the squid ink pasta and his lips were "stained" from the ink. It wipes off easily with a napkin, but may not be best for first date nights! Of course the squid ink has a bit of the salty sea water taste and I felt like I was eating the ocean. Wasn't a fan of this dish, but he loved it. Not sure if this is a place I can come back to for pasta, unless it's requested for a celebration. More...

A

Alexa P.

15 May 2019

Sicilia Mia is without a doubt one of the best Italian restaurants you can visit in the Salt Lake area. I have tried many items from their menu, all being delicious with unique flavors. Not only that, but the food is consistently good every single time I have been. The service is great, and the food is seriously heavenly... This is a favorite of my families and we always leave very full and happy.  Thank you, Sicilia Mia family! More...

B

Brent C.

12 May 2019

Saw this place on yelp and went here for dinner about 10 days ago and it is wonderful! Great food, friendly service, a bit noisy but fun. The only downside is the parking, otherwise a great place.  Will be back soon and wish I could have known about this place years ago. More...

A

Anna Alfonsi

12 May 2019

Great food! Great Staff! Taylor was fantastic!

J

Jan Schuurman

2 May 2019

Ok we have been to the store on 3300 south in Salt Lake. Great experience. We went to the Farmington Station store tonight. I can’t tell you our servers name because I couldn’t hear what she said. Not because she mumbled, but the annoying singing was WAY to loud. Don’t even get me started about the tambourine. We should have asked to be moved, we were literally 3 feet away from the singer. Live music is awesome but this was over the top annoying. His voice was pleasant enough but not when it is blaring and you can’t even hear the people you are with talking. The couple we were with are some of our closest friends and we usually sit for quite awhile after completing our meal, but we couldn’t get out of there fast enough. I understand the singer is renowned singer in Italy, and great for him, but he should take a break during his routine. The break in between songs was heaven. I said I would recommend this place because of my first experience. Also our server tonight was fantastic. She was attentive and sweet. It would have been nice to hear what she was saying when describing the desserts, but again the music! At several points during our meal we all just laughed because it was almost comical how miserable we were. We were practically yelling to communicate with each other. Again we should have asked to be moved, but it was right at 7:30 and most tables were full. By the time a table was available we were already through our appetizer. We thought about asking our server to turn the volume down, but we didn’t. There should not be a table where ours was when there is live music. I still have ringing in my ears. Ok I have rambled on long enough, but felt like I needed to to make my point. Thanks for your time. More...

J

James H.

2 May 2019

Don't let the strip mall location or neighboring Macey's grocery store keep you from trying Sicilia Mia.  Their cheese wheel enhanced Carbonara plate  is a bit heavy but that isn't likely a concern if you ordered it.

C

Chris S.

30 April 2019

After another trip to Sicilia Mia, an update.We went again last night, and it was perfect, again. I've never visited any of the other locations, so can't compare to those, but we prefer Sicilia Mia to any other Italian place we've found in the area.Our server, Francesco, was fantastic. Very warm and friendly, there at all of the right times, never too much. He made great suggestions, he knows the menu, he brought and placed and removed everything perfectly, he was funny and easy to talk with... just a great job. He even sang to us while he prepared the Carbonara.The food was all excellent, and all presented beautifully. We had a Caprese appetizer and a warm spinach salad. It's a little early for really great tomatoes, but the Caprese was still very good. The spinach salad was better, and looked so good that it seemed a shame to ruin it by eating it, but it was perfect and delicious.We shared a Spaghetti Carbonara that you just have to try. The preparation is a presentation, and the dish is wonderful. Sicilia Mia still serves very generous portions, and both of us were really comfortably finished at this point, but then Francesco brought out the dessert options. We went with his recommendation, the Panna Cotta. It was creamy and very tasty. Finally, he brought us out glasses of a tasty lemon icy treat whose name I didn't catch. It was a perfect meal and evening, and I'd definitely recommend Sicilia Mia to anyone who wants a nice evening and an excellent meal. More...

P

Patrick Kelly

27 April 2019

Really some amazing food!

G

Glen Mckean

27 April 2019

Great food and good service.

P

Patrick Kelly

27 April 2019

Really some amazing food!

D

Dan G.

27 April 2019

Love the Alfredo dish where they bring out the cheese wheel on a cart and toss hot pasta in it to coat with melted cheese. One of my favorite pasta dishes ever! This small  restaurant has multiple locations in the valley but be sure to get a reservation. More...

A

Adriana Paola Q.

24 April 2019

The best menu the best service by Jerry. You will love it! I order the Ravioli Osso Buco and was above my expectations. Taggliatele della Nonna AMAZING. Jerry is the best server.

J

Johnny L.

22 April 2019

This review is going to be edited as understanding consumers and business owners mingle. =)

S

Stacey C.

19 April 2019

Consistently delicious food and lovely service. Our server Jerry was a lot of fun tonight and sang while making the Carbonara. This is authentic Italian food and should not be confused with your experience at a cheesy chain restaurant. It's a small space and promotes an intimate atmosphere between you, the staff and other guests. We are officially regulars after tonight's dinner. Thank you! More...

C

Ciro Giorgio

16 April 2019

da Italiano di Napoli vi dico che e il miglior ristorante che ho trovato qui negli Stati Uniti. Complimenti a tutti.

C

Ciro Giorgio

16 April 2019

da Italiano di Napoli vi dico che e il miglior ristorante che ho trovato qui negli Stati Uniti. Complimenti a tutti.

B

Blake C.

13 April 2019

This restaurant feels like you're in Italy. If you're looking for an authentic experience, then you have to come here... The carbonara is unreal. The lasagna is to die for. This is a must if you are in Salt Lake City. It's hard to find proper Italian restaurants. The staff is friendly and the chef always comes to greet you. Restaurant is more of an experience than anything. More...

B

Bailey B.

11 April 2019

Such an amazing restaurant, and Vincenzo was a great and fun server! The food is very delicious and comes out in great presentation.

L

Libby A.

11 April 2019

This is definitely one of our favorite restaurants in all of SLC. We always feel like family when we're there.  Vincenzo takes amazing care of us!  The ambiance, the delicious food and great wine list is the best!   Never had a dinner that wasn't amazing.  Can't wait until we go back. More...

T

Tiffany H.

11 April 2019

I'm going to have to strongly disagree with any negative review about the spaghetti alla carbonara. Yes it's a little rich- what else would you expect from cheese, bacon, and pasta. But, oh my god is it delicious. I'm going to dream about this dish and the creamy deliciousness that covers the pasta when it's drowned in a wheel of cheese. Definitely would recommend More...

L

Lizzie W.

11 April 2019

There must be some sort of city wide ordinance that ensures all restaurants on Highland Drive uphold a certain level of quality. You really have to go out of your way to be disappointed, food wise, on this street.We came here on a whim. But be forewarned this doesn't seem like a place you generally just show up at. It's in your best interest to get a reservation. My luck at getting seated immediately has probably everything to do with the fact that we came here at 5:00 p.m. sharp on a Thursday. Mind you, by the time we left, the place was already filling up.When I heard patrons of the restaurant start speaking Italian, I knew we were in for something good, and we were not disappointed. Appearance wise, Sicilia Mia does the best it can with the hand its been dealt. Despite it being comfortable and welcoming, you can only go so far when you're located right next to IHOP and a crossfit gym. Sister restaurant Anticia Sicilia gives you a bit more of a refined experience. Sicilia Mia is JV, while Anticia Sicilia is straight varsity. Both great in their own ways, but you truly appreciate them for different reasons. As a first timer I was not sure what to order, so we went with a Caprese appetizer because mozzarella cheese needs no explanation. Outstanding flavor, and the consistency was just right. For dinner, I had the spaghetti bolognese, which was very good, but just on the verge of being delicious. It just wasn't quite there. Maybe I goofed in my ordering, but I just really love a classic spaghetti. It wasn't bad by any stretch of the imagination, but it really lacked that richness I've come to love about a knockout spaghetti dish. Didn't get around to dessert, but that's definitely on the docket for next time.Prices are par for the course as far as I'm concerned, and the staff are friendly. As a holistic experience, it's really hard to go wrong here at Sicilia Mia. We're definitely going to be back. More...

V

Vincent E Bath Jr

10 April 2019

Giuseppe is arrogant and very demeaning to employeess and guests. I was an employee and he stole tips from us then never showed us a daily report that made any sense about how little we were paid on payday. There was constant yelling and the chefs would drink in the kitchen before closing and get made at every little detail. The Mirendas are very sketchy and I would caution you to stay away from eating as well as working at any of there restaurants. More...

C

Chad Carter

8 April 2019

pasta was good. i had carbonara and they nailed it. a little over priced for sure. pizza was terrible.

L

Levi A.

8 April 2019

We've been here several times and really enjoyed all our experiences.  The carbonara is outstanding, as are all their other dishes.  Fantastic desserts too!  This is a place we like to bring our friends and family.  Be sure you're reservations are for the proper restaurant, their online reservation system is a little confusing! More...

V

Val S.

7 April 2019

This place !!! WOW. The service is excellent above par for sure. The food is delicious . The atmosphere is fabulous. Small party intimate place ...would highly recommend .

A

Ashley M.

7 April 2019

Amazing food and great staff! We had the bruschetta, carbonara, and cacio e pepe. All of it was amazing. The staff was very welcoming and fun. It seems like they enjoy working there. More...

E

Elle C.

6 April 2019

We came here for Valentine's Day. Deft a cute little authentic Italian place. The servers are on top of everything and the food is really good. I personally preferred the food in their cottonwood Heights location but the downtown one is fun too. Combination of their wines with their meals is out of this world. Make sure you ask your server. Stick to traditional italian meals. My husband tried the steak and I personally don't think it's their forte. More...

S

Sweet D.

5 April 2019

Loved it. Our waiter, Jerry, offered fantastic recommendations.  We had the seafood tagliaterre, mediterranean steak, grilled veggies. Fantastic wine. All awesome. Tiramisu for dessert, must try. More...

B

Brittany M.

5 April 2019

This place was SO good! We got the carbonara and the made it in front of us in a wheel of cheese while singing songs in Italian. Highly recommend!!

N

No-l E.

5 April 2019

What an amazing dinner!  The food was impeccable!  The service was excellent!  The wine list amazing!  Spendie as everything is separate; salad and entree.  But it is worth it because the food is delicious!!!  The restaurant is darling but small.  You MUST have reservations!  We lucked out because there was a no show. More...

A

Aisha Gunn Sanders

3 April 2019

Best food and staff I have EVER experienced before. I don’t get to Utah often but I can assure that when I do this will be in the plans to enjoy again. Don’t think twice about this one check them out and enjoy every bite. More...

B

Brenda T.

3 April 2019

Delicious !!! Beautiful table setup , nice atmosphere ! My husband brought me for my birthday ! Our server jerry was amazing !!! He treated us like royalty . Super attentive !!! Awesome for special I assign or just a friend meet up ! Can be both formal and casual ! Loved it ! More...

A

Aisha Gunn Sanders

3 April 2019

Best food and staff I have EVER experienced before. I don’t get to Utah often but I can assure that when I do this will be in the plans to enjoy again. Don’t think twice about this one check them out and enjoy every bite. More...

L

Lisa V.

1 April 2019

We showed up here as a party of 8 on a busy Saturday night. They were so gracious to try and accommodate us and even gave us a free bruschetta appetizer while we waited. Two ordered the lasagne, both felt it was the best lasagne they had ever eaten. Two of us ordered the carbonara. It was excellent!!   Fun presentation!  Two ordered the sage ravioli, very tasty, one had the gnocchi, great flavor and texture and I can't remember what the last person in our party had but I know he was happy with it. The wine was also very good. The service was amazing from the hostess to the wait staff. They were fun to interact with and made sure we were well taken care of. We had a very fun evening with great friends, food and wine. I would highly recommend Sicilia Mia! More...

D

David Kay

31 March 2019

Great food and outstanding service!

D

David Kay

31 March 2019

Great food and outstanding service!

H

Heather M.

27 March 2019

Absolutely fabulous!  Our server was Arlex.  The attention to detail was impressive.  He figured out we were a fun group and had some fun with us. The food was exceptional.  Carlo was amazing too. In fact every employee we interacted with was dedicated to making sure we had a fabulous evening. Will be returning for certain! More...

K

Kim A.

23 March 2019

Seems to be the thing for us to try a new Italian restaurant for my birthday dinner. This year Sicilia Mia was on the menu because I had tempted my mom with pasta mixed in a wheel of cheese. She didn't need to be convinced much We were brought a carrot and pea soup for tasting while we ordered. First we shared the fritto misto which was amazing. Everything was fresh and rich in flavor. Next they began the flaming wheel of cheese and mom got excited. Then they delivered our other entrees. My dad got the paccheri and I the pistachio gnocchi. Everything had a very different flavor so it was nice to have a bit of everything. We even had them put a little of each dish into everyone's to go box. Because it was my birthday we had to order a slice of cake for dessert. That came with a nice plating and some singing. Afterward you're treated with a light drink of sorbet and sprite. More...

R

Randall Smith

17 March 2019

we ate downtown, First time there, it was a Great experience! Service provided by Francesco was fun and engaging, Sono stato in grado di parlare Italiano con lui. I ordered their signature dish which is the Carbonara and my wife had Lasagna di Nonna! Can I just say Fantastico! It was all so delicious and the table side presentation of the Carbonara was Superb! Will definitely eat here again. More...

J

Jefferey Hogg

17 March 2019

Nico was fantastic! Table side carbonara..!! Love!!

L

Lindsey Bagby

17 March 2019

We had so much fun, Matteo was amazing and the food was even better!!!

M

Matt H.

17 March 2019

So freaking good and I love the authentic environment. All the servers worked as a team and they were so friendly and competent.

R

Randall Smith

17 March 2019

we ate downtown, First time there, it was a Great experience! Service provided by Francesco was fun and engaging, Sono stato in grado di parlare Italiano con lui. I ordered their signature dish which is the Carbonara and my wife had Lasagna di Nonna! Can I just say Fantastico! It was all so delicious and the table side presentation of the Carbonara was Superb! Will definitely eat here again. More...

H

Helen R.

16 March 2019

Enjoyed dinner tonight, excellent all around, my husband & I shared the special of prawns, beef, sausage, mushrooms, polenta, 2 potato halves served on large platter.  Plenty for us. We finished off with profiteroles that were the BEST we've had outside Italy!!!!!  I will be celebrating my soon-coming birthday there.  So glad to have a GREAT Italian restaurant so close to home More...

A

Anna W.

15 March 2019

We had a fantastic meal and experience here. You must get the pasta in the cheese wheel for the full experience. Ask for Francesco!

S

Sonia V.

13 March 2019

The gnocchi with tomato sauce and mozzarella was SOOOO GOOD!! I love pink sauce cuz I'm hesitant on marinara etc but this one is absolutely perfecttt! It's almost like a pink sauce.. but a little chunky some creaminess but not too rich.. just absolutely PERFECT! I tried the peach cosmo drink and that was good too, not too sweet! Hands down will be back :) More...

K

Kristjan M.

12 March 2019

What a fantastic meal and experience. The four of us has never eaten there before. Vincenzo was a wonderful host,  personable, and prompt. I got the very first thing I saw on the menu- the Gnocchi filled with Gorgonzola. It was honestly the best gnocchi I have ever eaten. My wife got the spaghetti carbonara and she loved it. Vincenzo brought out a dessert that I don't recall the name Of- some sort of eclair, piled high with cream and chocolate mousse. It too, was so so good. I'll definitely return. More...

M

Michelle R.

12 March 2019

This is by far my favorite Italian Resterant in Utah.  Jerry was our waiter and so professional and informative.  Incredible food and service.  Will definitely recommend.

S

Samantha A.

12 March 2019

This place was delicious, but a bit pricey. The Spaghetti Carbonara was awesome and it was really fun to have them prepare it in a giant wheel of cheese next to your table. The bruschetta was absolutely delicious, warm crispy and heaped with tomatoes. Only dislike was that the lasagna was so soupy it felt more like tomato cheese soup that had occasional chunks of pasta. More...

J

Jenn P.

11 March 2019

It's been a very hot minute since I last wrote a review. But I'm back with a great one! I love Italian food, and Sicilia Mia (cottonwood location) did not disappoint. I recommend making reservations because it's a small place, but the service is beyond amazing! We were seated and greeted. Our waiter even brought out soup of the day to try. Creamy tomato basil... I can't even describe how delicious it was, it's like like tomato soup 2.0.. so good! We also got the carpaccio di carne for appetizers, if you're a fan of a raw meat then you'll like it. It's just thin slices of meat with arugula salad in the middle. I give it a 3.5/5.For dinner I got the special.. let's just say I ate the whole entire thing. It was homemade flat pasta with seafood in white wine sauce. I loveee seafood so I wasn't surprised I ate the whole entire plate. But fear not! I had room for dessert, and I beg you guys to try their tiramisu.Omg.. like it's so so so good, better than gourmandise (the bakery) so that's saying a lot. I want to go back and just get that right now! But overall, my experience was a 10/10 here! More...

D

DerekandBarbara Dunaj

11 March 2019

great service. staff was very pleasant. table side cooking was fabulous.

K

Kim Northrup

10 March 2019

Great atmosphere, amazing food!

K

Kim Northrup

10 March 2019

Great atmosphere, amazing food!

C

Codey Peterson

9 March 2019

This is what Italian food should taste like Utahans. The Carbonara is outstanding and the gnocchi is amazing. Stop going to Olive Garden you crazy people!

A

Anna S.

7 March 2019

The location is perfect, downtown and within walking distance to the theater. So glad they have a downtown location now. You come here for the spaghetti carbonara. It's served table side on fire in a cheese wheel. It's the small things that delight. I'm not a big pasta fan, because it usually is really heavy but the pasta here doesn't disappoint. Also, try the Arancine rice balls, great option for an app and lasagna is a classic. They have speciality drinks and a nice selection of wine. Great place for a large group or date. More...

S

Sandra S.

4 March 2019

We came here to celebrate a late valentines dinner. The downer is that we made a reservation, but we were not able to be seated until like 20 min after the original reservation time.I had the three course pasta sampler. The gnocchi in the sampler was okay. It was almost like biting into a mash potato ball. Everything else on my plate was good, I was looking forward more to the black truffles because I never had them. More...

M

Mary Ann Nicks Flinders

3 March 2019

We really enjoy this restaurant. So glad to see them in Farmington. Great food!

C

Chris G.

2 March 2019

By far the best Carbonara we've tried. Prepared table side, it makes for a great experience. Our server Francesco, could not have been a better host for our party of four. Made us feel at home and was very attentive and personable. He even sang us a song in Italian while preparing the table side dish. Everybody's food was fresh and absolutely delicious, and served as decent portions. More...

J

Jessica G.

2 March 2019

I am super picky when it comes to food and usually only yelp when I want to recommend something or warn people to stay away. This place is AMAZING!!! Everything we had was great from the appetizers to dessert. Service is exceptional and everyone was very personable and we really enjoyed our food and service. The Tris Tartara, Strozzapretti Al Gambero, Spaghetti Carbonara, Big Panna Cotta and my Peach Cosmo were the best I've ever had. You must try this place out! More...

M

Mike Smith

1 March 2019

Very tasty food and adult beverages!! Awesome staff!!

C

Cherie Oliver

1 March 2019

We went for lunch today and had a great experience! Their carbonara made table-side is absolutely amazing. It was hands down the best carbonara we had ever had. The pizza and salads were wonderful as well. The owner/cook even came out to talk to us when he found out my husband spoke Italian. Most of the staff is Italian and it makes for a fun, authentic atmosphere. More...

N

Nellie C.

1 March 2019

Have you ever been to a restaurant and think......oh, I could live here and just feast all day! Welp, Sicilia Mia is that place for me! I've lived in Italy, so I really felt at home here. You are immediately greeted by a kind welcome, along with their enticing dessert display, you can't help but want to sit down and taste all of the happenings here. Their show stopper is the carbonara, tossed in this massive parmigiano-reggiano  cheesewheel , along with pancetta. My hubs ordered the bolognese, which was also a delicious flavor explosion, but wished he ordered what I got. (He's lucky I gave him a bite or two of mine. Lol)Sorry I forgot to take a pic of our super flavorful caesar salad. We inhaled that too, after a long day at the office. To round off the evening, you must MUST try a dessert or all! Since everything else is made from scratch, so are these! We had the ricotta baked cheesecake profiteroles (aka the chocolate mountain) and a regular cheesecake, with fruit toppings, to take home As a pretty legit home baker, I have a true appreciation for those who take special care, of their sweet treats ~ in taste and presentation. You will not be disappointed at your experience here. They take pride in taking care of you and making sure you eat and leave happy! ¡Grazie Mille! xx More...

S

Shelby M.

1 March 2019

One of the best Italian places in the Salt Lake Valley. It's definitely not the most fancy setting, but it's authentic Sicilian food with wonderful service and quality ingredients. If you get the carbonara in the cheese wheel, I suggest sharing it as it is the most indulgently rich meal I've had at an Italian restaurant. But if not, enjoy! I also suggest the mushroom ravioli, gnocchi and the steak. More...

K

Kris H.

28 February 2019

So good! Service is fantastic and the food is better. Love the tableside preperation. I haven't had a cioppino that good since cali.

D

Debbie M.

27 February 2019

Great menu, wonderful service, always consistently delicious! Reservations recommended however.

N

Nicole S.

26 February 2019

Vincenzo... thank you for a fabulous evening!!! We very much enjoyed you and our meal was incredible!!! Until we meet again!!! Grazie!!!

J

Jade McGowan Wilson

24 February 2019

We ordered four different meals with our friends and shared them all and every single one was just perfect. The service was also very friendly. Highly recommend making a reservation in advance. Although in a strange location This restaurant is super busy. More...

J

Jade McGowan Wilson

24 February 2019

We ordered four different meals with our friends and shared them all and every single one was just perfect. The service was also very friendly. Highly recommend making a reservation in advance. Although in a strange location This restaurant is super busy. More...

C

Catie P.

23 February 2019

This place is divine. We had the best Italian food of our lives tonight. We started with a sample of tomato basil soup, it was wonderful. The bread and pesto was great as well, and our entree's were incredible. I got the pesto shrimp pasta dish, everything was perfectly cooked and flavorful. My husband got a meat sauce(that had been cooked for 8 hours) with pasta and loved his as well. We will definitely be back and will be recommending this place to all our friends! More...

G

Gon L.

23 February 2019

Interesting old-fashioned Decour but has a great ambience. I ordered their carbonara which was delicious. Not to mention that they marinate it in this big cheese wheel, that they light on fire! Right by your table. My mother in-law's lobster was a bit overcooked but over all the seafood dish was delicious. Reasonably price just not cheap. Overall my husband and I had a great romantic Valentines dinner and they give us free dessert. More...

N

Neil G.

22 February 2019

Delicious! Just sayin! Super cute spot in the Downtown area and was really surprised on how good the food was!  Started off with 2 great salads which were dressed perfectly and the greens were really tasty. Had the bruschetta which rocked as well. Some really great wines by the glass. And our entrees were awesome. I had a pasta with vegetables which was so fresh and our kids had the spaghetti marinara which they devoured. A pasta carbonara made tableside in a round of Parmesan reggiano, was also devoured. a lasagna and a ravioli were also super. There were many other Dishes that looked amazing as well. A short drive from the airport was well worth the trip! Service was super too! More...

B

Beej C.

21 February 2019

Pasta is the star here.  I had an excellent rich mushroom gnocchi and my partner had a mixed seafood pasta.  Both were generous servings and I was amazed that my partner managed to clean his plate of everything but scattered bivalve shells..a testament to its compelling taste.  The green salad we shared  was fine, the cream puff was unremarkable.Proficient service, prosaic decor.  A welcome addition of finer dining on this block of Broadway more usually associated with fast lunches for office workers. More...

M

Martha M.

21 February 2019

Went for sons birthday.  First time for All 6 of us.  Food was so delicious.   Ordered 3 appitizers. Just fantastic.     Service was fabulous.   As for the desserts, no words to describe the deliciousness. More...

A

Angela I.

19 February 2019

From the outside this place doesn't look like much, however don't let that stop you! My friends and I celebrated Galentines here, they let us decorate the table and the staff was top of the line. Our server Mesha was amazing! She was genuine and made us feel important and relaxed. I was recommended the gnocchi by a friend and it's the best I've ever tasted! The creamy cheese sauce is beautiful and so flavorful. It's a little place which can feel crowded but it was no big deal. Our food did take a little longer than I'd like but we were having such a wonderful time that it was forgiven. More...

M

MichelleBelle Cohen

17 February 2019

Love Sicilia Mia! We've been going to the ones in SLC and am so glad that it’s closer to me now! The food is so good!

A

Amber Garrison

17 February 2019

authentic sicilian food for sure!

K

Kathi Sjoberg

15 February 2019

Great food and you always feel like a part of the family!

T

Thomas D.

15 February 2019

I moved to SLC from Italy in June of 2018 and was delighted to discover this restaurant.  The Italian food served here is the best I've had outside of Italy.  The food is superb.  The staff is friendly and professional and the owner makes you feel right at home.  It is no wonder Sicilia Mia is always crowded.  I cannot recommend them highly enough.Grazie More...

J

Jann M.

15 February 2019

Ohhhhh how I love you!     This cute place looks like a dark restaurant in a strip mall.  My son has raved about it for years so we finally went for our Anniversary.Our Waitress was beyond fabulous and we knew we had to have Bruschetta and Pasta Carbanaro.  They come to your table and in this giant cheese wheel they spin the pasta until it's coated but it's still so light and you feel like you are in a cafe in Italy.   The Bruschetta is so fresh and their olive oil is like a whisper of taste on your food.I asked where do you get all of your ingredients and they import them from Italy.   Of course they do because I have never been able to find all of this in the USSave room for dessert and get the cream puffs.  They are stacked like a small volcano but I wanted to lick the plate after they are soo delicious The people who work there are beautiful and for  most of them Italian is their first languageYou feel as though you've eaten holy food from Italy.  It's prepared so elegantly and so gooood.   Dress up because you are about to have a very special dining experience More...

C

Chris Liberatore Lewis

14 February 2019

Excellent food, atmosphere, and service!

S

Sumana Sukcharoen Hepler

14 February 2019

We had a great time here, food is delicious. Awesome people.

M

Michael Stevens

14 February 2019

Fantastic food. Love the atmosphere here.

K

Kathi Sjoberg

13 February 2019

Always delicious, fresh and homemade!

L

Lynda M.

13 February 2019

Jessica was our server and she was awesome! She had great food and wine recommendations and the food was definitely the best we've had in SLC since we moved here from NYC 3 years ago. Finally we have a great Italian place to eat! We talked to the chef afterwards to compliment him and he was very nice. Also, the cannoli reminded us of our favorite cannoli place in NYC. I already have a reservation for lunch there tomorrow and I am telling everyone I know about this place! More...

V

Vincenzo Mandurino

13 February 2019

Great place to experience Italy!

J

Jeffrey Smith

13 February 2019

Got the great opportunity to attend their soft opening. Carbonara is a must! So many other amazing dishes to enjoy on future visits.

K

Kathi Sjoberg

13 February 2019

Always delicious, fresh and homemade!

C

Catherine Duncan

12 February 2019

Absolutely amazing food. Authentic cuisine run by Italians straight from Italy. This is definitely a diamond in the rough.

C

Catherine Duncan

12 February 2019

Absolutely amazing food. Authentic cuisine run by Italians straight from Italy. This is definitely a diamond in the rough.

G

Gabi O.

12 February 2019

Sicilia Mia is always a treat. Carbonara, as everyone says, is incredible. Most recently tried the bolognese and enjoyed it.

S

Stephen H.

12 February 2019

Great spot that will surprise you with great signature dishes.  Try the Spinach Salad!

M

Michaela C.

11 February 2019

I had heard incredible things about the carbonara here so booked a table for my husband and I. We brought our two month old son and all the staff were so kind and accommodating (normally when we bring babies to dinner they are treated as a nuisance, and here our baby was doted on). Truly some of the best service we've had at a restaurant. And then there was the food--we had the carbonara and the marsala ribeye special and my husband and I were both giddy through our entire meal because it was so incredibly delicious. I can honestly say their steak is one of the best I've had and the carbonara was divine. I am recommending Sicilia Mia to all of my friends and will definitely be returning frequently. Thanks to Vincenzo and all the Sicilia Mia staff for a wonderful experience! More...

E

Emily-Anne W.

9 February 2019

This place never disappoints me. Sicilia Mia is a solid brand in my books. This was our first visit to this location. We had the arancini to start. Amazing. Then the carbonara!  Oh my heart. I love this dish. As delicious as ever. My only complaint is there is little to no parking. More...

M

Michelle C.

9 February 2019

Hubby and I loved this place- excellent food, thank you for still being a small-town restaurant with excellent service

D

Diamond K.

9 February 2019

My girlfriends and I had a galentines dinner last night and our server Misha was incredible! The best service we could have asked for. I collect wine corks and she was able to give me some they no longer needed. We had such a great time, the staff was so attentive to us and the food was incredible. I got the carbonara with shrimp and it was a fun experience to watch them make it right before your eyes! We got the moscato wine, we wanted another bottle but it was so good it sold out! I would recommend the calamari for an appetizer. We were also celebrating a promotion I got, but the servers came out singing happy birthday to me lol! Loved the place so much, we'll be back! More...

W

Whydothey T.

8 February 2019

This is true italian dining. The staff is extremely friendly. The decor is nice and provides a relaxed and elegant environment. The food is always amazing. I always recommend friends and family to eat here More...

M

Melle M.

6 February 2019

Ultimately my favorite comfort food place.  The Carbonara is definitely the best in the Salt Lake City area!  I'm a raving fan of their pasta and steak.  Every friend of mine who visited also agrees with me that it is indeed delicious! More...

R

Randall M.

4 February 2019

Took my wife for our Anniversary and what a great place, the service was exceptional and the food... Fabulous

C

Camille T.

31 January 2019

Perfection. Great service, amazing food. Particularly recommend the gnocchi Gorgonzola.

M

Massimiliano Giuseppe De Simone

30 January 2019

the best , i love them ♡♡

S

Sarah N.

27 January 2019

I came here for lunch with some coworkers and it was the best decision. The food was delectable. Of course we all had to share to know how each other's foods tasted. It's pricey but typical for an authentic Italian. The owner is Italian, and he even gave us a show with the cheese wheel and carbonara, singing for us and everything. The ambiance is truly remarkable and service is impeccable. Absolutely recommend. More...

K

Kainoa C.

26 January 2019

Talk about feeling like family! What a find! The food is amazing! The service is spot on! I can't say enough about what a great experience we had here. Highly recommend!!!

H

Heather M.

25 January 2019

The dining experience at Sicilia Mia Cottonwood is exceptional. The service is outstanding and the food is even better. We will definitely be back and couldn't be happier a restaurant of this caliber has come to Cottonwood Heights.

K

Katie F.

25 January 2019

Great service and amazing food. Make reservations,  they are busy!  I'll be back for sure.

D

Dirk P.

22 January 2019

Fat Guy Review:They serve pasta dishes with lots of proteins/veggies so you never leave hungry? YES. LET'S GO ALREADY.THEY LIGHT A WHEEL OF CHEESE ON FIRE FOR THE CARBONARA? OMG! YES. LET'S GO ALREADY.Seafood that tastes fresh in UTAH?! - YES. LET'S GO ALREADY.Aaaand the guy next to us made moaning sounds while drinking his wine (tried not to make eye contact...) so...Good alcohol in UTAH?! - YES. LET'S GO ALREADY.Why are you still reading reviews? - Let this be the last one you read...At least of this restaurant... maybe read the reviews of other restaurants so you don't get sick or go to a crappy place... ;) More...

M

Mike O.

21 January 2019

The best, so glad to have a great restaurant in this location.  I have been at the location on highland and this is the same. The manger is good, just ask for the recommendations and they will take great care if you. More...

J

Jeanne Evans

20 January 2019

I can’t say enough of how great the food, service and atmosphere was. I’m craving some more!

J

Jeanne Evans

20 January 2019

I can’t say enough of how great the food, service and atmosphere was. I’m craving some more!

J

Jodie O.

20 January 2019

The carbonara is worthy of my dreams. Absolutely delicious. The ravioli was unbelievable. I would never order ravioli normally, but their mushroom ravioli is heavenly. Did I mention ravioli?

R

Ruby Cortez Romero

18 January 2019

We love to come here for a nice meal and relaxing environment.

R

Ruby Cortez Romero

18 January 2019

We love to come here for a nice meal and relaxing environment.

L

Laurie V.

18 January 2019

This place is amazing! We went with some friends who highly recommended it and we were so glad we did. From the outside in the evening there is no curb appeal but once you get inside, it's got the charm of an authentic Italian restaurant. And the taste and service were off the charts!We had the lasagne and spaghetti carbonara, which were both epic. We hoped to try the desserts but sadly had no room, but they looked delicious. Hopefully next time.This restaurant was a wonderful find!! More...

R

Ruxandra L.

14 January 2019

The best stake I've ever had!! It is so flavorful and cooked to perfection. I paired it with L'AMURI red wine- absolutely divine!  Sicilian best. I would fly 8 hours again just to eat here. More...

S

Stephanie B.

11 January 2019

Absolutely fantastic!! The food and the service was the best ever. Thank you for such an perfect experience.

N

Neal B.

11 January 2019

Best place I have eaten at for a long time. Great food,  perfect service.  I'm going back!  Kum and Vincenzo treated us just right!

D

Doug P.

10 January 2019

Enjoyed dinner at Sicila Mia Downtown on January 5.  We had enjoyed these restaurants in Holladay and the 33rd South location.  We were not disappointed.  The service was top notch, the manager was very attentive, the atmosphere was pleasant and the dinners were excellent.  We also enjoyed complimentary bowls of soup.  This location was just as good as the other two locations.  Perfect location for after dinner events downtown.  We will definitely be regulars at this restaurant when downtown events arise.  Five big stars. More...

D

Dean Y.

9 January 2019

This is an authentic Sicilian restaurant hidden in the Cottonwood area.  The Carbonara and Sicilian Seafood pasta were the winners for our main course.  They prepare the Carbonara the traditional way in a large Grand Padano Cheese wheel in front of the table.  For dessert you can't go past the Pannacotta and Tiramisu. Both were delicious.  What have the place 5 stars was the wonderful staff who made us feel welcome and provided us with the right recommendations.  I will definitely be back.  My kids loved it too. More...

H

Heidi W.

8 January 2019

Parking was not fun...there isn't a lot.  Ordered Caprese and Bruschetta appetizers, the bruschetta was pretty good.  The tomato with the Caprese kind of killed the dish for me...it wasn't super good (obviously not in season).  Ordered the salmon and Primavera Strozzapreti, the same was good and the sauce was perfect.  Didn't love the Primavera as much as I had hoped.  I had high expectations for this place so, not sure if they were too high but, it fell short.  They are opening at Station Park in Farmington & I am hoping to give it another shot then.  :). More...

P

Patrice P.

8 January 2019

The spaghetti carbonara was indeed awesome. They were generous with everything that brought flavor to the party (Parmesan, pancetta), and the table-side show made it extra fun. Even the aesthetics with the balsamic reduction was fun to watch. We will *definitely* be back for more carbonara. At the same time, the lasagne was disappointing. It was quite bland, and served in basically a bowl of goop. I really hate to say this, but the sauce reminded me of canned "Chef Boyardee" from my childhood, only without the tangy zip. We ordered it as a benchmark and because I tend to favor tomato-based sauces, but will avoid it when we go back for more carbonara. More...

T

Thany C.

7 January 2019

What an amazing experience I had with my fellow guests. The service was absolutely amazing not only from just our waitress but from other waiters to the manager coming to make sure we were ok. The food was nothing short of amazing! I recommend this place to all!! More...

R

Raili J.

4 January 2019

Within walking distance to our home, we found one of the gems in Salt Lake City. Sicilia Mia is a collage of warm, friendly, Italian service mixed with the most amazing food imaginable. My husband, Johann, had the special of the day, rack of lamb with a rosemary demi glaze and I ordered off the menu getting the delectable ravioli osso bucco. Vincenzo was attentive to every need. I loved how each of the wait staff stopped by to chat about our meal or wine selection. When Johann dropped his knife, no less than 20 seconds later, another one appeared. The staff teamwork is obvious and feels like family. We were here when the restaurant opened in the fall and we will be back many times over for the tasty cuisine and impeccable staff. Grazie, Sicilia Mia Cottonwood! More...

J

Johnny M.

1 January 2019

This is the best authentic Italian food in Utah. The place is a slice of Scicily. Great food, great service, great atmosphere. Recommend getting the caborna table side, they bring the pasta out and finish cooking it in a cheese wheel, while its cooking the server decorates your plate. This is the place to go if you want homemade Italian food. More...

B

Benjamin F.

30 December 2018

I ate there the other night and got the Carbonara, totally amazing. My server Francesco also recommended the Cioppino which my wife ordered and loved. The food was a 4.5 but the server was a 5.5. Ask for Francesco if you want to have a great night. More...

J

Jeff D.

29 December 2018

Don't be fooled by being in Utah and in a strip mall.  This place has amazing Italian food!!!  My wife got a seafood pasta dish that was incredible.  I got the Bolognese which was the best I've ever had, including in Italy.  It wasn't marinated hamburger meat, rather had chunks of lamb and sausage.  Prices very reasonable as well. More...

T

Tiago S.

29 December 2018

One of the few examples of authentic Italian food in this state. I love this place! Great options and diverse menu. Not too fond of the sea food items though. Still gets five stars because this place is awesome! More...

M

Marcus W.

29 December 2018

We lived in Sicily for three years and our friends there know one of the cooks at Sicilia Mia and recommended it. It is so hard to find authentic Sicilian food in the states, but this place has it. The food was amazing!  The spaghetti carbonara is their signature dish and it did not disappoint. You would never think this little place next to a grocery store and salon would be so good, but if you want authentic I highly recommend it. More...

C

Carly R.

27 December 2018

I would have given this restaurant 5 stars had we had better service.  I'm not sure if our waiter was having an off day or what.  Our appetizer was delivered twice and even though I repeated my pizza order twice and he said it back to me, I received the wrong pizza.  We will try it again and hope that our orders are right this time.  Make sure to make a reservation. More...

C

Cris M.

22 December 2018

Amazing food, friendly service. This restaurant is now on my top 5 in Utah! Try the cheesy pasta and Prosciutto appetizer!

L

Lisa V.

22 December 2018

Fresh pasta,  great ingredients,  nice atmosphere,  quiet, smells fantastic,  and friendly staff.  Even though it's in a shopping mall by a grocery store,  don't let that fool you.  The parmesan carbonara is rich. And the gnocchi were soft puffs of heaven. We will definitely be back. More...

H

Harriet W.

20 December 2018

I had the chicken parm for lunch and was highly impressed by the flavor and tenderness of the chicken. It was perfectly cooked and thankful for the kind service. It was served quickly and when it was time to pay, it was even quicker. Great for lunches if you're in the area. More...

J

John C.

19 December 2018

Found this place on accident, my sister and her husband were downtown and we didn't realize that most places close at 2pm for lunch and re-open at 5pm'ish.Don't recall what occupied this place before, and it is driving me batty. Anyway we were warmly greeted upon entering and service was on the ball non stop. Someone was always checking up on us and it was great that they weren't even open a week yet and seem to have their act together.The only thing they didn't have was Pizza which was fine as we weren't in the mood for it anyway.The winning dish of the night was the carbonara and wow! Probably the best I have ever tasted in Utah. Appetizers were all delicious, also the desserts were all good except for one. It was the lemon cake one that tasted like it was over cooked and a bit dry. We brought that to their attention and they took it off our bill. The chocolate mousse was just right and tasted like a baked and chilled version and really loved it. That was my favorite. Please see pictures of the other items ordered.For sure will come back and order family style so we can all try each others dishes. More...

E

Eileen C.

18 December 2018

Excellence once again. Delicious appetizer assortment, burrata a highlight as was the seafood salad.  Grand opening entree was delicious dumplings with mushrooms and a truffled pasta.  I don't know the specific names but would order both again.  Dessert was a nice duo of a cream puff and one profiterole.  Loved this location. More...

M

Maggie O.

18 December 2018

If you love Italian cuisine but don't have the means to fly to Italy, come here for the most authentic experience from the heart of Salt Lake. They've taken all the best parts of Italian culture except you don't have to pay for the water! Incredible staff that were super friendly and conversational. Order the calamari if you get the chance, the red sauce is delicious. Also if you can stop by for dinner, they have an incredible carbonara seasoned in a GIANT flaming block of cheese. Wonderful meals for a very reasonable cost. More...

B

Brenna S.

16 December 2018

This was such a perfect birthday dinner! The Carbonara was outstanding. So flavorful and fresh-- I highly recommend it! If you're a mushroom fan, the ravioli ai funghi was outstanding as well. Friendly staff, great service. I highly recommended Sicillia Mia! More...

J

Josie Brumfield

15 December 2018

Best Italian food in the state!

B

BriAnna M.

15 December 2018

Yum. We love their Holladay location and are so excited to have them downtown. We had the Caccio e Pepe and the Peccheri Alla Contadina and both were wonderful.

F

Francesco M.

15 December 2018

The best in Salt Lake City! And going for #4 strong. Try the paccheri Al ragu! Or their famous carbonara!!Home made tagliatelle, 5 star prosciutto and delicious tiramisu!!!

J

Josie Brumfield

15 December 2018

Best Italian food in the state!

K

Ken V.

14 December 2018

A review of their opening night...which showcased why the family's restaurant business continues to thrive in the area. This is their fourth active setting, and a welcome addition to the downtown dining scene. Their trademarks are on hand...an excellent, rich carbonara finished table side... beautiful gnocchi...excellent appetizers and antipasto, all extremely well-sourced. From prior experience, their pizza and numerous entrees offer a range of dining options. Even in the chaotic environment of opening a new restaurant, their strongest attribute shines through--and that is their warm welcome and family atmosphere. The new restaurant is set in the former space of the old, long-running Judge Cafe. Many still miss the Judge since it's closing...but Sicilia is a welcome option for lunch and dinner in the downtown area. As with all of their locations, reservations are a great idea for dinner. And allow time for parking in an area that has relatively few street spaces.Last...but not least...save room for their desserts. Excellent! More...

F

Forrest R.

14 December 2018

First time here and it was not a disappointment. We will definitely come back again. The food was top notch and the staff was great and helpful. This may be my favorite Italian restaurant in Utah. More...

T

Tiff S.

13 December 2018

The food here is phenomenal. Whether you're looking for a good steak or in the mood for Italian, you won't be disappointed.  Walking up to the restaurant its in a strip mall--so you get a hole in the wall feel.  Walking in it felt like we were at a old italian, family run restaurant somewhere not in Utah. Service was great, the waiter was very attentive and personable. Now for the food-- the carbonara is something they are famous for.  They make it right in front of you! In a cheese wheel!! What?! And it was soooo good.  It wasn't overwhelmingly cheesy or creamy it was spot on.  I got the gnocchi with chicken and it was also amazing.  The portion sizes are huge so that compensates for cost, which isn't too bad anyway.  My husband got the prime rib, it was delicious and cooked  perfectly medium.  It came with potatoes and veggies. Oh and don't forget the delicious desserts displayed as you are entering or leaving.  It's hard not to get something.I'll definitely be back! More...

M

Mike O.

13 December 2018

Awesome, atmosphere and food is great. I had a recommendation from the chief which was very good. The Carbonari is also the best, they serve with a cheese bowl.

L

Lawrence Ted Trujillo

11 December 2018

Great service and food and the waiter and waitress are very good I recommend you try the food

L

Lawrence Ted Trujillo

11 December 2018

Great service and food and the waiter and waitress are very good I recommend you try the food

J

Jordan H.

9 December 2018

I've never seen such a professional staff in my life. My drink was never empty,my food came out in a timely manner and we weren't constantly bothered.The food was so good when Memo came to see how we liked our food I raised my hand with a smile and a single tear went down my face! Literally speechless.  I'd recommend making reservations in advance! More...

M

Minh T.

9 December 2018

Family owned and very friendly ppl that works here. My wife and kid loves pasta , so this place is perfect! Price is good and the portions are really really really big and when I say big I mean really big lol. I'm not a huge fan of pasta but I'll eat it. Don't get me wrong, it's just that it's a really heavy type of food. I do admit their pasta is really awesome and tasty tho. I usually always get their calimari and ribeye. Their calimari is AMAZING!!!!! It's so tender, I never had a calimari like theirs before. Calimari is cut into thick pieces not like the other places that gives you tiny pieces. It always comes with a huge prawns which I'm wondering if they have a dish that I can order that is just pawns lol. Their ribeye is really tender and great. They also will make carbonara right in front of you! That's prob ppl most favorite dish to get since you also get a show. Someone's they will have special of the day fishr. When we went they had two tomahawk steaks for sale for the day. Also they would cook those tomahawk steaks next to your table. The parking is small so you may have to walk 20 yards or so to the entrance. I recommend also that you make reservations since they are usually booked out and most of the time will not take walk-ins . Over all me and my little family lives this place. More...

K

Ken V.

6 December 2018

Welcome back to the Heights! After watching the family thrive in several locations, it is wonderful to have them launch another venture in the spot they first started.Many of their Sicilia favorites are on the menu, with some excellent new additions. A wonderful caprese antipasto with eggplant. The tagalliatelle prepared table side with fresh truffles was excellent. And the eye-popping desserts are a must.I love this family...their spirit...and, of course, their f More...

C

Carol B.

6 December 2018

This has been my second time here both the food atmosphere and service has been excellent!! I feel like I am back on the Amalfi coast in Italy

M

Mike K.

5 December 2018

We found this restaurant on Yelp and instantly fell in love.  The gnocchi was amazing and the carbonara was great as well.  Even though it was busy, the service was fast and friendly.  Next time we'll try the desserts (which were tempting) but we were way too full because of the heaping portions. More...

E

Emilee P.

5 December 2018

Small and cozy atmosphere. The food was incredible! Had the pasta on the cheese will and WOW not only was it fun to watch but it tasted amazing. There was also a major portion so I was able to take some home for lunch the next day and I was thrilled! More...

J

John L.

4 December 2018

Genuine Siciliana Ristorante. Excellent food and service. Spaghetti and clams excelled. Try the Chinese Restaurant next door. Hidden gems in Cottonwood. In a shopping Center. More...

C

Cindy Parkin Stanley

25 November 2018

The food and energy of this fine establishment are simply amazing! Our family has never been disappointed with anything we have ever ordered. I must say the seafood is our favorite. It is always so fresh and cooked to perfection. It simply melts in your mouth. The beautiful sauces and seasonings are a perfect compliment to the delicacies of the fish. The flavor of the fish is always the shining star in their dishes, not the sauces and seasonings. We love this place and have been driving from Farmington to the Highland Drive location for a few years now. We were thrilled to learn a new restaurant will be opening in a few weeks in our home town. Patrons will not be disappointed with their visits. Immediately upon walking in you will be heartily greeted. Table side presentations of food is a common occurrence, along with song, and laughter. By the time you have finished your delicious meal, your family has become apart of their family. Utah is very fortunate to have this fine Sicilian family of resturants gracing our Wasatch mountains. More...

C

Cindy Parkin Stanley

25 November 2018

The food and energy of this fine establishment are simply amazing! Our family has never been disappointed with anything we have ever ordered. I must say the seafood is our favorite. It is always so fresh and cooked to perfection. It simply melts in your mouth. The beautiful sauces and seasonings are a perfect compliment to the delicacies of the fish. The flavor of the fish is always the shining star in their dishes, not the sauces and seasonings. We love this place and have been driving from Farmington to the Highland Drive location for a few years now. We were thrilled to learn a new restaurant will be opening in a few weeks in our home town. Patrons will not be disappointed with their visits. Immediately upon walking in you will be heartily greeted. Table side presentations of food is a common occurrence, along with song, and laughter. By the time you have finished your delicious meal, your family has become apart of their family. Utah is very fortunate to have this fine Sicilian family of resturants gracing our Wasatch mountains. More...

N

Nicole G.

21 November 2018

Family Italian restaurant.  Call ahead, get a table, and enjoy.  The food is amazing and the service is tailored.  We enjoyed the burrata, carpaccio, truffle tagliatelle, carbonara, and seafood special.  They will make sure the wine pairs well too.  It's nice to have a place like this in Cottonwood Heights. More...

D

Drew R.

18 November 2018

Finally came back and gave this place a second chance. Totally worth it all. They did some renovating since I last came. It way bigger inside now. We got a seat inside. The cheese wheel was very good and rich. Very heavy though. So be careful not to over do it. We also got the tiramisu...it's delicious! Worth it! More...

D

Denise L.

17 November 2018

There's a reason they got best in state. We fit the Ravioli ai Funghi and it was absolutely delucioso. I'm not a real fan of mushrooms but the way they cooked them with the creamy cheese sauce with a hint of truffle oil was fantastic. They bring you out bread with three different kinds of pesto that are all lovely and flavorful. For dessert we split a cream puff covered in chocolate and took home a cannoli, the cannoli is out of this world delicious. All of the wait staff were very personable and I loved their accents to boot.We WILL absolutely be going back, hubby says at least once a month. :) Try them, you won't be sorry. More...

K

Kelie H.

17 November 2018

Maybe it's just a novelty to some, but I really loved the carbonara. Pasta is good and all but when it's prepped in a flaming wheel of cheese? Excellent. I'm not used to carbonara not having peas in it. And I have no idea if peas in carbonara is even authentic whatsoever, it just usually has it. I missed them. The pancetta and creamy sauce was perfect, though. This place doesn't look like much from the outside, but inside was cozy and we had great service. Perfect date night spot in the 'burbs. More...

J

John P.

15 November 2018

This restaurant serves authentic Sicilian cuisine. The food is beautifully prepared in a modest atmosphere. Service was friendly and superior to many other restaurants I've been to. My primary issue is the unusually high prices listed for most of the menu items. You'll eat very well here but it will come at a price that makes eating here regularly untenable for most families. Reservations I suggested except for off-hours. More...

P

Paul H.

15 November 2018

The food is great!  Atmosphere is fine. The burning wheel of cheese is impressive to say the least.

A

Andrew J.

13 November 2018

Now I have graced the doorways of many an Italian restaurant in my day, and in my opinion this place is something special. I came to Sicilia Mia for a family celebration and the service was exceptional. It seems like the majority of the people working at the restaurant are family and the sound of people speaking to each other in Italian made the experience all the more authentic. They have a large wood fired pizza oven that cranks out one kick butt pizza. While their pizza is really good, the crown jewel of Sicilia Mia is their Spaghetti alla Carbonara. I can honestly say this is the best pasta dish I have had in my entire life. I heard that this dish was one of the best on the menu and family members told me that it was their favorite but I didn't know it would become my favorite as well. When you order this dish you also get a show. One of the cooks comes out to the table with a huge wheel of cheese and they light it on fire and dump your pasta in the wheel to add even more delicious cheese. The dish also has  pancetta which tastes like fancy bacon. I would highly recommend Sicilia Mia and if you decide to go, GET THE SPAGHETTI ALLA CARBONARA! More...

P

PierGiorgio S.

12 November 2018

amazing food amaizing people!!!!i love this place, the mirenda family, and the whole crew , they will welcome you with an outstanding costumer service....

A

Alyssa S.

12 November 2018

Great service. Unexpectedly exceptional food. Loved the lasagna and the complementary soup before dinner. It was very busy though so make a reservation.

E

Elle C.

8 November 2018

Stop looking any further. This restaurant is an excellent place for date night. Parking is easy and conveniente. Make a reservation. The place is small and cozy with limited sitting. I have managed a Italian restaurant before and my family is from Italy and this place exceeded my expectations. Food was fresh and presentation was outstanding. They serve a complimentary soup that it's deft a Italian tradition and it tasted just Like my grammas. The atmosphere is nice and relaxing. It can be a date night or a getting out of work don't want to cook kinda a day. Vincenzo was our server and it made us feel like part of the family. Everybody else stopped by the table to make sure we were having a good dinner and made us feel special. The owner Marguerita is such a sweetie and stopped by to chat with us. I'm seriously in awe because it's been a while since we had this level of fine dining service in Utah. Prices are moderate and husband and I had a three meal course with wine and it was only $100.We can't wait to come back next week with our friends! GRATZY More...

M

Melanie E.

8 November 2018

The service, food and presentation were exceptional.  Vincenzo is personable and authentic as he is Italian and is so knowledgable.

B

Bryn J.

6 November 2018

So glad I found this place for lunch! The ravioli was delicious and beautifully presented! The cannoli was everything a cannoli should be! And, everyone was friendly! Definitely a great spot for authentic Italian food! More...

N

Nella B.

5 November 2018

Their lasagna was one of-if not thee best I've ever had. Great service. I like how cozy and warm of a feeling it gives you.

R

Robin O.

2 November 2018

Excellent!! Service and food both!! Try the Carbonara for sure. They toss the pasta in a huge Parmesan wheel! Yumm-o! And the gnocchi are like pillows of deliciousness!!

M

Marysabel Diacon

31 October 2018

Is the best Italian restaurant

M

Marysabel Diacon

31 October 2018

Is the best Italian restaurant

D

Donna Dallman

30 October 2018

Family owned with a true family feel. Food was delightful, fresh, authentic. The service was spot on. Enjoyable, tasty dinnet.

D

Donna Dallman

30 October 2018

Family owned with a true family feel. Food was delightful, fresh, authentic. The service was spot on. Enjoyable, tasty dinnet.

E

Eliza N.

30 October 2018

Authentic Italian food. My parents met in Italy and we've had authentic Italian food since. The kindest wait staff too. Everything on the menu is to die for. Call ahead to make a reservation though! It's worth the wait and the price. More...

D

Danielle LaRe

28 October 2018

A wonderful dinner with family! We just returned from Rome and have to say the food at Sicilia Mia is like we never left. Amazing!

D

Danielle LaRe

28 October 2018

A wonderful dinner with family! We just returned from Rome and have to say the food at Sicilia Mia is like we never left. Amazing!

E

Eileen C.

25 October 2018

Fantastic! Everything is so delicious. We are big Sicilia Mia fans and welcome this location to our neighborhood. The mountain view is stunning. Looking forward to coming here often. More...

T

Tina A.

25 October 2018

Absolutely wonderful! My very favorite Italian restaurant. Everything is so delicious and staff is always so warm and friendly. So happy to have this location right in my neighborhood! Looking forward to coming back very soon. More...

C

Cheryl H.

23 October 2018

I have no words to explain how excited I was to stumble upon Sicilia Mia! I am assuming it was the manager who greeted us at the door and asked if we had reservations, but was extremely kind and welcoming and said they would get a table ready for us even though we did not have reservations. The service was exceptional, but the food.... no words. Oh so good. We started with the bruschetta and this may have been the best bruschetta I have eaten in the state of Utah. Then we ordered the signature dish spaghetti carbonara. The food came out in a giant flaming dish, and served in style. I was super amazed with the spectacle of it all. I could tell the spaghetti was fresh. The meal was not dense or heavy feeling, like a lot of italian places I have been.I also have found my new (tied with first) very favorite dessert. Panna cotta. I cannot even explain the goodness of this angelic dessert. It has a thicker than gelatin flavor, but smooth and creamy like butter. Combined with the raspberry sauce on top made it exceptional. I have dreamt of eating this every day since. Obviously you can tell how stoked I am about our entire experience, and will be back for many, many more visits and am so glad a place like this exists. More...

B

Bay M.

22 October 2018

This is by far the best Italian food I've EVER had! The moment we arrived, we were promptly greeted by the manager, Eduardo who seated us right away and introduced us to our server, Francesco. Between the two of them, we felt so well taken care of. Francesco was so attentive and informative about the menu and wine pairings. I ordered the Pollo d' Annunzio, and it was amazing! The flavors were incredible. My friend ordered the Carbonara, which was also delicious. It was so rich! Both of us were so happy with our meal choices. Lastly, we shared the Tiramisu. I am somewhat of Tiramisu connoisseur, and this was by far the best I've had.I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone. It was a perfect evening. The food and the service were up there with the best I've had. More...

A

Amanda Afemata

19 October 2018

This place was spectacular! The dinner was amazing, I’ve never been treated more like royalty, the dessert was divine! Thank you for showing me what Italian food is actually like! More...

A

Amanda Afemata

19 October 2018

This place was spectacular! The dinner was amazing, I’ve never been treated more like royalty, the dessert was divine! Thank you for showing me what Italian food is actually like! More...

N

Nikki Crayk

18 October 2018

Best Italian food you will ever have! Served by the most incredible, kind, loving family around!

N

Nikki Crayk

18 October 2018

Best Italian food you will ever have! Served by the most incredible, kind, loving family around!

T

Taylor B.

13 October 2018

Go here!! Get the carbonara and thank me after! Our waiter was amazing too. I truly believe they should rename the Carbonara to Carbomazing!

E

Eva Olsen

12 October 2018

My family is from Sicily, and so I can say this is authentic! I love the atmosphere and the live music. It’s a great place for the whole family ❤️

E

Eva Olsen

12 October 2018

My family is from Sicily, and so I can say this is authentic! I love the atmosphere and the live music. It’s a great place for the whole family ❤️

B

Becky Jensen Nicholson

29 September 2018

Amazing food and atmosphere! Best Italian food in Utah!

B

Becky Jensen Nicholson

29 September 2018

Amazing food and atmosphere! Best Italian food in Utah!

T

Tom D.

29 September 2018

Have only had takeout pizza from this place, but I liked the vibe and the pizza was excellent. The pasta dishes that were coming out of the kitchen while I waited looked great. Will definitely go back for a dine-in experience next time we're in town. An unlikely location for a good restaurant--next to a big grocery store and almost out of site from the street. I'll update my review later. More...

T

Tiffany K.

21 September 2018

Good food and ambiance is fun. The carbonara is exciting to watch and plate but man is it so heavy!! I

K

K N.

20 September 2018

On September 19th 2018 we had lunch at this restaurant. As before the waiters were friendly and helpful and the main dish was delicious. Prior to being served bread was brought to the table and it was dry and old and tasteless and it would have been better just not to serve it. It would be nice if every entree was served with a small salad. I believe it is far too expensive to pay $13 for a plate of noodles with the little chicken. We will return at least one more time and Hope that some of these problems are remedied! More...

A

Austin P.

15 September 2018

If I were rating this place on just the carbonara and the ambience, I would give it five stars. However, I have to factor the tagliata, espresso, and tiramisu into my rating as well. The meat for the tagliata was a bit tough, and the presentation left something to be desired. (I had to dig through the arugula in order to even find the meat.) The tiramisu was tasty, but not "knock my socks off" good. Same for the espresso. So long story short, if you can handle heaps of cream and cheese, get the carbonara. Otherwise, get a recommendation from one of the servers. More...

J

Joanne Bolnick

14 September 2018

Always a fun time and great food!

J

Joanne Bolnick

14 September 2018

Always a fun time and great food!

A

Amy L.

8 September 2018

I went here for my birthday and it was great! It's a bit pricey so I would save it for a special occasion. I got the special (carbonara finished in a giant cheese wheel). My partner got the shrimp gnocchi. Cheesy, pasta goodness! At the end, the servers sang 'Happy Birthday' in Italian and I got a creme puff. More...

A

Amanda G.

7 September 2018

This is the best carbonara I've ever had.... bonus it comes with the little show of rolling the pasta in the wheel of cheese at your table.  Now my favorite,  can't miss when i come here is the Bistecca al Rosemarino. Omg!! This is the best steak I've had at a restaurant in a long time.  The portions are big,  so if you are going with a date i recommend getting the carbonara and the steak and sharing. More...

P

Pam B.

1 September 2018

Our second visit here.  Started with Italian wine, bread came although it was cold. Had Caesar salad was done well.  Ordered bolognese lasagna which was fine.  Husband had a chicken dish that was over cooked.  Daughter had the famous cheese wheel pasta presentation at table.  Tasty, but rich.  Best part of meal was Francesco our server who was very pleasant. More...

J

Jeff Chandler

27 August 2018

The food was excellent, the service great, and it was very economical compared to similar restaurants in the valley. Went there for our anniversary and they even made us a special dessert. Had been there for lunch in the past and it was good, but their dinner service was far better. If you want great Italian, this is the place. More...

J

Jeff Chandler

27 August 2018

The food was excellent, the service great, and it was very economical compared to similar restaurants in the valley. Went there for our anniversary and they even made us a special dessert. Had been there for lunch in the past and it was good, but their dinner service was far better. If you want great Italian, this is the place. More...

C

Christy Lineback Rath

24 August 2018

Great food and outstanding service. I had the carbonara, it was decadent.

C

Christy Lineback Rath

24 August 2018

Great food and outstanding service. I had the carbonara, it was decadent.

S

Scott Bennett

14 August 2018

just now Pricing is a bit on the higher end, but the food is excellent and service is exceptional. Someone in your group should get the Carbonara for the tableside presentation and fantastic flavor, but be warned - I doubt they will share. Note: some of the best restaurants in New York City, Europe, and Italy especially - wonderful small family owned restaurants found on side streets in small facilities. The Highland Drive Sicilia Mia is in a strip mall - and it's easy to imagine your in Italy at a friendly small family restaurant - just enjoy the feeling while your here. Also, call ahead and make reservations instead of just showing up. Being a wonderful restaurant makes them popular, busy and definitely crowded at peak dinner time. More...

S

Scott Bennett

14 August 2018

just now Pricing is a bit on the higher end, but the food is excellent and service is exceptional. Someone in your group should get the Carbonara for the tableside presentation and fantastic flavor, but be warned - I doubt they will share. Note: some of the best restaurants in New York City, Europe, and Italy especially - wonderful small family owned restaurants found on side streets in small facilities. The Highland Drive Sicilia Mia is in a strip mall - and it's easy to imagine your in Italy at a friendly small family restaurant - just enjoy the feeling while your here. Also, call ahead and make reservations instead of just showing up. Being a wonderful restaurant makes them popular, busy and definitely crowded at peak dinner time. More...

S

Steve Nielsen Jr.