Tristan Village, Florida
129 customer reviews
Steve Pfeiffer
Decades ago I caught wind of Sherry’s and have always relied on her ability to make incredible cakes, Never disappointed. Not sure how many family members are at the shop but her son Ryan also has my respect, here is there last project for me!
Reviewed on Facebook
Charlotte Strecker Pilling
Sherry's cakes are flavorful and moist. The buttercream icing is pure perfection! Since discovering Sherry's Cake Shop all other shops pale in comparison.
Reviewed on Facebook
Ann Beagles
Always friendly and Very helpful with my cake decorating needs. Sherry is the best!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Marissa Llagas
Everything in her shop are excellent.
Reviewed on Facebook
Ashley Eagerton
I get all my cakes from sherrys they are all delish! I just recently got my wedding cake from them, although it was beautiful and yummy if you plan to get a cake from them with fake flowers on it I suggest you bring your own flowers the sunflowers on my cake were small more like daisys, not what I asked for or anything like the picture I gave them but the cake was yummy!
Reviewed on Google Maps
kathy milstid
Got a cake for my best friend's birthday. They did an awesome job.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Gary Yarber
Absolutely incredible cake. Four layers, lemon, key lime, vanilla, and chocolate. It was delicious. It was beautiful. Sherry did a wonderful job filling our order but also assisted us with her expertise in what to order. Thank you to her and her family and her shop for their five star service!!! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ya'keitha Williams
I went into Sherry’s for my cake tasting and was greeted immediately. The atmosphere was loving and family oriented. I enjoyed the precise answers to my questions. Ms. Sherry also took the time to give vendor information about other areas of my wedding planning. It’s hard to find vendors who are not out for just themselves and I appreciate her to the fullest for being who she is. She’s a jewel... Now, trying to keep her handsome little grand baby from sneaking him a few pieces of the shop made candy is another story... LOL More...
Reviewed on WeddingWire
Crystal Manning Marcum
Great experience with Sherry’s cake shop! Very friendly staff and very tasty cakes! Will use again!
Reviewed on Facebook
Isabel Foust
I got a sugar free vanilla cake for my grandmas birthday and it was yummy and beautiful! Everyone complimented it and loved how it tasted!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Savanna Stevison
Awesome Shop and friendly and willing to work with you.
Reviewed on Facebook
Izzy Foust
Got a sugar free vanilla cake for my gmas bday and it tasted amazing and was beautiful! Everyone loved It and the sparkles really made a great impression!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jahkell
That have nice cakes and cookies keep up the good work.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mary
Thank you so much, Sherry and team, for contributing to our beautiful wedding day! Thank you for being so kind and helpful to my parents in the ordering process, and for providing just an amazing product! Our guests are still talking about how delicious both the wedding and grooms cake was! We highly recommend you to anyone wishing for a perfect wedding cake! More...
Reviewed on WeddingWire
Robert N Heather Smith
Sherry's Cake Shop is the best in town. She can custom make anything you want done at a reasonable price
Reviewed on Facebook
Jane E. Mitchell
My Birthday Hummingbird cake was wonderful!! Everyone raved about it!! One lady was cousin of Sherry's,she said u were amazing! !! Thank you so much,I craved this all year cause it is never in the one slice thingys u have!! Can't order whole cake,cause I'd be fatter than I am!!! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Brittney Cruise
Very tasty cakes! Friendly staff. It’s also your go to place for cake supplies and decor if you prefer to make your own cake (or if you have kids that love creating in the kitchen!)
Reviewed on Facebook
Tara McVay
The cake that was made for my dad's 80th birthday was moist and flavorful! The almond flavor was subtle and not overpowering. The decor of the cake was clean and sharp and my dad enjoyed it immensely! Thank you!!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Pam Carney Nolan
she is a wonderful lady. been going to her shop for 30 years.
Reviewed on Facebook
PROPHET CHOO.
On a very hot FL heat index day I was introduced to a really delicious cake and cookies snack from her cake shop. The cookies had a nut taste and weight, which made it a unforgettable bite. And the cakes I ate three times, because it flavor and sweetness madeMe want to savor it over and over again.And that how the cookies crumbled it is definitely a sinful indulgence. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Victoria Dial
Fast, friendly, hot service. Great eats the petite four, key lime cake, strawberry cake, royale cookies, harvest cookies, devil dogs, cookie sandwiches, different flavored cupcakes, etc. They do cakes for all occassions, in different shapes, flavors, and sizes. They have all types of decorations for weddings, baby showers, kids birthdays, Mother's Day, Valentine's Day, etc. It's a wonderful place to just drop in and grab a sweet snack. Ms. Sherry and her family are very kind people. It's a wonderful shopping experience. I get our birthday cakes, Mother's Day cakes, and Valentine's Day cakes from there every year. I definitely recommend this place. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Jessica Parker
Thank for the wonderful cake, for my husband. It was delicious.
Reviewed on Facebook
Gina Bonelli
Love love love this place.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Clarence E. Slaughter Jr
We love going to Sherry's cake shop. They're very friendly and professional. This establishment is also very clean. We get my own, my wife's (Victoria Dial), and my 10 year old son's birthday cakes or cupcakes from here every year. We also like to stop in for a snack the petite fours, the devil's dog, strawberry and keylime cake, the royale cookie, the harvest cookies are all to die for. I no we highly recommend you try Sherry's Cake Shop. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Angee A Turner
Best Homemade Sweet Treat Bakery in town. My 1st Sweet Potato Cake #1☝
Reviewed on Google Maps
Hannah Bean
Love the bake good
Reviewed on Google Maps
Colleen Gallo
Hi I live in Ironwood ,Mi. About as far north from Pensacola as you can get. I am a pastry chef /baker by trade for the past 30 years. I needed a cake for my brother that was celebrating his 60th Birthday in Perdido Key and wanted to surprise him with it. I choose Sherrys of thr internet. Let me tell you all the high complements I recieved grom family on the cake I ordered. It wad the chocolate cake with raspberry preserve fill and cream chees icing. Also ecpertly decorated with a picture I emailed to them. My oldest brother who lives in Pensacola said he wish he knew about the cake shop years ago. So from one baker/cake decorator to another ....very well done. If I pr we ever need another cake in Pensacola we will definitely choose Sherrys Cake Shop ! Jeff Gallo Ironwood Mi . More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kylene Pepper
We love this cake shop so much that we make a special trip to go get it when we come to Florida! Everything you could want in a cake. Try the lemon.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Acquainetta Knight
3 layer Key lime cake was Great..
Reviewed on Facebook
Victoria Dial
Sherry does fantastic work. It's a family friendly place with a wide variety of decorations and styles for your cakes and other treats. They do birthdays, weddings, baby showers , etc. I get my son, my own, and my husband's birthday cakes from there every year. My husband also gets my mother's day cake from there. Stop in and try some of their already prepared desserts they're fantastic. I love the key lime pie cake, their strawberry cake, lemon cake, royale cookie, their four square cake, etc. They're all truly wonderful. Ms. Sherry does great work More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Trisha Franklin
Awesome shop and such great service! Cake is delicious
Reviewed on Google Maps
Shiana Middlefinger
the carmel cookies with pecans.. .omg...the best I ever had...they have a permanent customer!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
sillybilly gumdrop
Everything was fresh out the oven walking in just in time love Sherry's
Reviewed on Google Maps
Christina Messer
We had an awesome experience dealing with Ryan at Sherrys Cake shop. He was super friendly, listen to what I wanted and gave me EXACTLY what I asked for. Oh, and the cake tasted wonderful!!! I highly recommend this bakery!! Thanks guys!! My son was super surprised!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Felecia Hicks
Didn't buy anything to eat, however really did look scrumptious. Very friendly and helpful.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jasmine Williams
Loved it
Reviewed on Google Maps
Love Life
Best cakes and cupcakes.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Melissa St. Germain
My wedding cake was AMAZING!!! Looked beautiful and was so moist!! Best cake I’ve had in a very long time!! Highly recommend this bakery, you won’t be disappointed!!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Uther Gardner
Great bakery products and prices
Reviewed on Google Maps
Denice Stout
Awesome People!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Meredith Taylor
Wonderful
Reviewed on Google Maps
Crystal
We were in Pensacola for my daughter’s graduation and I called at the last minute just to see if they had any pre-made cakes available. They made us a cake that day and it was DELICIOUS!! Highly recommend! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kimberly Forret
German Chocolate cake was nostalgic and just as delicious as I remember from childhood.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nichole Grant
Great selection of cake supplies ( boxes, pastry bags, cake decorating kits etc). Yummy cupcakes and cakes.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kit Chan
Great for all your cake making needs!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Cynthia Hoogland
They made a ladybug cake for my 1 yr old lastyear. it was perfect.
Reviewed on Google Maps
UniqueAsh ResinArt
Absolutely the best!!! We love you guys!!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Veronica Wimley
She is friendly and professional. She always accommodate your needs and her decorating classes are awesome!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Sharon Owens
AWESOME
Reviewed on Google Maps
ATouch Williams
Buy all my cakes here if you won't your cake done right call Sherry's
Reviewed on Google Maps