Turtle Creek, Pennsylvania
117 customer reviews
Jon Subak
great service, wonderful pizza and great drink called the yinzer.
Reviewed on Facebook
Dan DiFyno
One of my favorites. Great pizza and pasta.
Reviewed on Facebook
Rhonda Robertson
friendly service and good food.
Reviewed on Facebook
Star W.
The Family Loves Their Pizza, Huge Pizza . Shelly's Pie Has No Problem Putting Lot's Of Toppings On There Pizza.
Reviewed on Yelp
Jo Murock
Best pizza around! Friendly staff too!
Reviewed on Facebook
Greg P.
We had an unexpected but wonderful experience at Shelly Pie in Turtle Creek, PA the day before Thanksgiving. We had originally set out for a quick lunch at a place in North Versailles but the wind storm had knocked out power in the area and businesses were closed, so we headed down Greensburg Pike to see if we could find an open restaurant. When we stopped at the red light in TC, my daughter noticed Shelly Pie and said that her office had recently brought in a bunch of pizzas from there and they were really good. Loaded with toppings. That was all I needed to hear so we pulled in to the lot and headed inside. The restaurant is nicely decorated and we were greeted with a friendly smile. The three of us decided on a large pepperoni pizza in order to have some leftovers. The pie arrived quickly and looked delicious. The toppings were loaded on top and full of flavor in every bite. All three of us agreed that it was the best pizza we've had in quite a while. This isn't your regular local pizza joint, it's much better. The prices are good and the atmosphere engaging. If you like pizza, try Shelly Pie! I know I'll be going back. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Fran Pellegrino
Always great service!! Pizza is outstanding!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Mary Lou Saunders
Good food and great pizza. Great place for meeting friends and family.
Reviewed on Facebook
Heidi Renee Mohammed
Phenomenal pizza!!! ❤ Fantastic food; fast, friendly service. First time there from Florida, and Absolutely LOVED it!!! ❤❤❤ Will definitely be a regular! ❤
Reviewed on Facebook
Paul Letterine
Such a awesome place, food is delicious, and the staff are polite & personable. The new re-opening with bar makes this place number one
Reviewed on Facebook
Eric S.
The pizza is awesome. There is so much pepperoni on their pepperoni special you have to ensure you spread it out evenly into every bite!
Reviewed on Yelp
A.j. Boughner
Awesome pizza and pasta. Might be best around. Gives Vincent’s real competition.
Reviewed on Facebook
Nicole Mares
First time having food from Shelly Pie Pizza. Delicious pizza and hoagies! Easily the best I’ve ever had! Can’t wait to go back and try other items from the menu! HUGE portions!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Mitzi Remaley
great food great service and the price is great
Reviewed on Facebook
Robert Roth
This was our 2nd visit here. Started our dinner with an outstanding LARGE salad big enough to satisfy 7 adults and 2 youth. The pizza was in my opinion one of the top two in Pittsburgh, everybody loved it! With a very friendly staff and a very nice dining are this place is hard to beat. Keep up the excellent combination! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Patricia Ann Pollock
It was the 1st time there the staff was amazing....polite the food was perfect...and the prices were not that bad...
Reviewed on Facebook
Sharon Wieland
our waitress was awesome. this was her first night alone . very well trained.she did an excellent job. .our pizza was so delicious. we will diffently be back..
Reviewed on Facebook
Victor L Clay
Hands down some of the best pizza Ive had thus far
Reviewed on Facebook
Jim A.
I haven't been to Shelly Pie in a while. Best pizza I've had in a long time. I introduced Shelly Pie to a fellow pizza connoisseur which we ate there. He gave it 10 out of 10 and said it was just what he needed. Service was excellent too. Can't wait to go back. I need to try the sicilian! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Heather Lynn Seagrave
One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!!!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Brian R. Kozera
Very accommodating to seat 30 people for 2 hours. Everyone was pleasant from the host, to the wait staff to the bartender and yes management as well . The food was great. Also, thank you for the donation to the Western PA Gold Star Game. We appreciated everything. Great Job! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Lowell G Mays
Excellent Pizza, friendly staff
Reviewed on Facebook
Barbara Mervine Cox
great pizza. not stingy on toppings that's for durr
Reviewed on Facebook
Emily H.
My family and friends love Shelly Pie! We've even booked their party room on two separate occasions and have nothing but nice things to say about our experiences. Great food and excellent service!
Reviewed on Yelp
Steve Helmick
Happened to find this place by accident (literally, there was an accident on the freeway so we got off to kill some time) and had some of the best pizza I've ever eaten! If you are within an hour of this place, it's worth a regular trip to get pizza! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Tom C.
This is my favorite pizza around Pittsburgh. If you love pepperoni pizza, you won't find a better one anywhere. The crust and sauce are great and there is a mound of pepperoni on each pie. If you freak out about pepperoni grease-stay away. There are lots of other fine menu items too. I drive 45 minutes one way for this pizza! More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Anna Marye Carcia
This was our first time here. Our waiter, who was also a chef, was great. Lee was Very friendly and patient. There were 4 of us. We all enjoyed our delicious food. The menu has something for everyone and daily specials. Pizza w/ generous toppings - delicious Stuffed pepper w/ mashed potatoes - very tender and tasty Turkey Devonshire - loved the way the bacon was crispy and crumbled Seafood Newburg - tasty w/ generous amounts of crab & lobster The restaurant and the bathroom are very clean. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Tom F.
The go to place for not only Pizza but a full menu of Italian specialties, we go as often and are never disappointed.
Reviewed on Yelp
Jen Slattery
Was fantastic! Great service and very clean restrooms.
Reviewed on Facebook
Jennifer M.
This is one of my favorite places to eat. The pizza is excellent! Prices are decent. Very clean. Nice friendly staff.
Reviewed on Yelp
Joe C.
The pizza is a pittsburgh classic thick crust and tons of cheese and pepperoni.The waiters are nice and the food came out realy quick.
Reviewed on Yelp
Nancy G.
We've heard about Shelly Pie but this was our first visit. It greatly exceeded our expectations. Erin, our server, was very helpful making suggestions of foods to try. She was attentive without being intrusive. We shared a pizza. It was deliciously- and huge!! We will definitely be back. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Sandy Varlotta
Anything I have ever had is delicious. I also like the old photos of Turtle Creek.
Reviewed on Facebook
Nick M.
Fantastic pizza and great service . Glad to see a building resued and past remebered
Reviewed on Yelp
Kasie E.
BEST PIZZA IVE HAD IN PITTSBURGH. I moved here from upstate NY, I couldn't find a pizza shop that had the right pizza, some people over baked, some people underbaked, not enough sauce, pepperoni's , cheese. .. weird crust... NOT THIS PLACE. The crust is thick, tasteful and perfectly cooked. The whole pizza had layers of crunchy pepperoni and thick cheese, I usually don't even eat the crust but I did this time. I ordered through DoorDash, it did take a good hour but THANK YOU, the wait was worth it. More...
Reviewed on Yelp
Eva Wootchie-Rocknich
We had a bad experience here one time when we last ate here. Here was my review.... We drove an hour and a half for this pizza which we have many times in the past. Since it was late we called ahead to have it ready. When we got there they said that they did not take call ins and the pizza was wrapped to go. The manager named Carol came over and was extremely rude. The pizza was there and ready and you could not serve it !! Never again will we be back. I would like to say that I emailed the owner and he treated me very kind and checked into my experience and messaged me back. I was given an apology and mailed a gift card. I have missed the pizza and will be back now. Please don't judge a place on one bad experience. We had always enjoyed this place and drove there just for the amazing pizza and food. Thank you to the wonderful owners for respecting my review and trying to keep us as customers. I have deleted my bad review above and grateful for all they did to fix the situation. Thank you Shelly Pie!!! ❤️ More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Sharon Dornetto
Food is really good especially the pizza. Love their descriptions of the food on the menu so you understand what you’re getting - like sausage on the pizza will cause the crust to be dark (burnt) because they put real sausage on raw & it takes longer to bake. At least you know!
Reviewed on Facebook
Denise Lynn
Best pizza. Come hungry! !
Reviewed on Facebook
Shawn Carman
Amazing service and fantastic food!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Walter Thomas
Shelly is Sweetie pie... Takes love to make great food... She's got the formula. ;-)
Reviewed on Facebook
Kathleen Fitzmaurice Malley
Food was great, pizzas are awesome and amazing staff!! You will not regret it!!!! Now go!
Reviewed on Facebook
Susan Malley
Great pizza, friendly staff.
Reviewed on Facebook
Barb Finzel-Mastrogiacoma
pizza is awesome there. anything you order there is fabulous
Reviewed on Facebook
Wayne K Hill
Nice atmosphere, large portions, nice people
Reviewed on Facebook
James Pertinaci
great food and great service!
Reviewed on Facebook
Darren Duhnke
I don’t write a lot of posts if I am being honest. But the uber friendly ownership, the plethora of choices, and THE PIZZA make this place my go to. And it’s not just the pizza, everything that I have tried hits the spot. I love it. Keep it up #shellypiepizza! Your forever fan. More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Ben Abernathy
prices are reasonable and portions are Titanic
Reviewed on Facebook
Robyn Heilman Stojakovich
We ordered a large pizza, half with no cheese due to an allergy. They were thoughtful enough to add a roll of crust as a barrier for the cheese.
Reviewed on Facebook
Susan Meador
Awesome Pizza and service!
Reviewed on Facebook
Todd Henderson
Fantastic pizza! Reminds me of the pies we would get when I was little.
Reviewed on Facebook