Loading...

Please wait ...

PizzaLove logo
P

PizzaLove

Wyckoff, New Jersey

(105)
PizzaLove logo
P

PizzaLove

Wyckoff, New Jersey

(105)

Reviews (105)

Leave a review
P

Pots P.

10 November 2019

This has to be one of the best pizzas in the area!  The food is great, full of flavor, and nice sized portions.  Staff is friendly and helpful. The place is clean and nicely decorated. Highly recommended. More...

C

Cap'n F.

10 October 2019

Pizza Love can't be touched for either their food or their service. They are, hands down, head and shoulders above Pizza Parlor, Pizzaiolo ( Midland Park) and Pizzaria Mandara (and any others in Wyckoff, in particular - No offense but I love me some Brooklyn Pizza, but they're in Ridgewood). Very friendly and hard working staff, none of whom have threatened to kill me, yet. Anyone who thinks they're going to have a pizza delivered hot has been vaping way too long. Let's not all rush there for dinner, however. It's busy enough as it is and I sometimes need a seat for crying out loud!! More...

C

Carmine B.

27 September 2019

Just walked in, had their soup, rice ball and pizza. Their food is so delicious, the establishment is super clean. Service was on point!!! I will DEF be coming back here!

T

Tara W.

24 September 2019

I think this place has some association with a tv star? I don't know or care but their pizza is fantastic. I'd love to branch from our usual drunken grandma pizza with chicken parm and broccoli rabe, but it's just too good!  We've ordered side and entree salads which are much more than an afterthought like at most pizza joints. Follow their Insta for some serious food porn. More...

D

Donna Mangani-Bucci

23 September 2019

My family loves Pizza Love! Delicious, fresh food with generous portions and reasonable prices. Always very clean and the service is excellent.

K

Karen Maher

17 September 2019

The service is absolutely outstanding!!

R

Robin Iosco

28 August 2019

The food was very good, the restaurant was very clean and our waiter Matt was excellent...very attentive and helpful with the menu!!!...I will definitely be back!!

M

Maureen Sarah Lembo

26 August 2019

Great food and staff!! Especially my nephew... :)

J

Jack H.

25 August 2019

Great pizza and other Italian food. Got catering from them on a few occasions and was very pleased. Highly recommend pizza love!

L

Leigh K.

15 August 2019

Been here a few times now & the food is consistently good. Family friendly dinner spot, for kids as well. The chicken parm with vodka sauce & penne is the best dish ive had so far! Portions are good, not too pricey. Wraps and sandwiches are delicious too. Id def recommend for a casual dinner or a family pizza night. More...

A

Angelica S.

1 August 2019

pizza was very good and the service was even better. we had our twins with us and the server was very sweet accommodating us!

B

Barbara Crohan Burggraf

23 July 2019

Pizza love just catering a party for our son and future daughter in law. The food was off the hook. I would highly recommend this place.. They rock

C

Charles B.

29 June 2019

A good friend of mine recommended this place for several reasons. My wife and our cousins went there this past Friday and it did not disappoint. Tucked away in a little strip mall  this place is much more then one would expect from a pizzeria/ restaurant. The food was outstanding ,  the setting and staff were fantastic. From start to finish our dining experience was a great one.  From the appetizers to the deserts it was flawless. A young man named Jayson made sure our first time there would be one that would bring us back time and time again. Jayson you succeeded. I will make Pizza Love a regular stop for dining. Everyone in our party all agreed this place is  a great find. My friend Fran hit this one out of the park with her recommendation. More...

M

Melanie F.

2 June 2019

Had such an amazing experience at pizza love. Everything is great about this place. The environment the people the staff the food . Everything !! I come here all the time because I just love it so much. I highly recommend it to anyone in the area or nearby. You will not regret it and definitely will be coming back! The grandma pizza has to be my absolute favorite.also it's a perfect spot for family parties or a night out with the friends, also good for date nights! Go eat at pizza love you will love it !! More...

B

Bob G.

15 May 2019

Great place, food is EXCELLENT, nice size portions, staff is very friendly and helpful!!!!

P

Pong C.

10 March 2019

Ok so this is the place to go to in Bergen County for great Italian food and pizza. We have catered in from Pizza love a few times and everyone loved the food. I am glad I found out the owner is or was one of the house wives. Otherwise we would not have tried pizza Love just because I do not agree with the representation of those nonsensical shows. But the food is amazing and I am happy to support a local business as well. More...

J

Jim H.

6 March 2019

I didn't have the pizza but the salads and sandwiches are so good . Probably one of the best Greek salads I ever had . A plus !

S

Sam L.

4 March 2019

What a nice surprise this place was! Got a menu in the mail so decided to give them a try. Ordered over the phone for delivery as the website wasn't working to order online. Food came on time and was all really good. The fresh pasta in the Fusilli Alla Mama was great and so was the Grilled Chicken Panini. Margarita pizza was also very good. Will definitely order again! More...

S

Samantha S.

16 February 2019

Ordered in tonight. One large pie, penne vodka & my son had the fat bastard sandwich. The pizza was excellent nice and hot and the cheese was very good. The penne vodka was also excellent and I've had penne vodka from many places in the area this one was one of the best I had. My son LOVED his sandwich and it completely filled him up and he got the 7". Don't know why some people complain about the food I'm thinking they are not true Italians but just know Italian food. Delivery was very fast and we are def not that close but all showed up nice and hot- just perfect. Will order from again!! More...

N

Nicole T.

4 February 2019

Our go to pizza place in the area. Great for eat in, take out or delivery. We enjoy the pizza as well as other items - salads, pasta dishes and sandwiches. All reasonably priced and good quality. Especially the salads - fresh and have a lot of options to choose from! More...

T

Tyler Y.

22 January 2019

We ordered two pies for pickup - Meatball & Onion and Sausage. The pizza was hot when we got home and both pies tasted fresh and had lots of flavor. A bit pricy, but that comes with the region. We'll definitely be back! More...

J

Julie R.

12 January 2019

Awesome service, waitress was phenomenal. Never left dirty dishes out. Food portions were huge, prices were very reasonable, and food was delicious! Highly recommend going. They don't take reservations but told me to call 15 min ahead and they had a table waiting for us. Would definitely go back, order take out, or do a catering menu. More...

R

Renee G.

28 December 2018

This was my first time at Pizza Love but will not be my last. The restaurant is impeccable. The staff was friendly, courteous, and knowledgeable. Our server made suggestions and hit the mark on everything. We were a party of 13 so we started with salad, muscles, and a square pizza and ate it family style. All 3 were excellent. You can tell the ingredients were top of the line with the first bite. For the main course I chose the chicken parm. Amazing. Anytime u don't have to even look for ur knife to eat chicken parm is a home run!  Add the sauce and it was back to back homeruns!  To end the zeppolis, Tiramisu, and cappuccino. Boom!! There is so much to love at Pizza Love! More...

B

Bernie H.

8 November 2018

Where do I begin Every Thursday a bunch of guys who went to school together some 50 odd years ago and are from Paterson get together at different restaurants .  Today we went to Pizza Love , and we immediately put it on our return to list. I want to thank Kathy for taking good care of us. Now to the food....Great calamari cooked perfectly and very tender...the rice balls are like one we ever had...they were delicious !! Don't miss the fried ravioli , excellent with a wonderful marinara sauce for dipping . Everyone's lunch was delicious from the Veal Love , The Chicken Parm ,Sausage & Peppers and of course the Pizza. Do not leave Pizza Love without trying  their Tiramisu ( recommended by Kathy ) and the Cannolis . All in all , a great meal and a place to go back to !! Don't miss it !!! More...

D

Dawn R.

21 September 2018

Been coming for a couple of months and this place never disappoints. Food is always excellent and good friendly service. The shrimp appetizer is a must get and is plenty to share. They have a huge menu so there are lots of options. They will accommodate any request. Highly recommend! More...

M

Matthew K.

18 September 2018

Never had a bad experience there. Food is always fresh and their sandwiches are on point. I've ate there multiple times and was always satisfied with the food and service.

M

Mark A.

18 September 2018

If I was on my death bed this would be my choice for my last meal. Pizza love doesn't just offer amazing food but also an unbelievable staff. Will absolutely be returning. You won't leave hungry. More...

C

Colin M.

18 September 2018

Pizza Love rips it bad & trout Definitely my favorite Italian place in the area. Service is great & the food is even better

J

Jay U.

18 September 2018

THE BEST! We were recommended to Pizza Love by a friend a while back. We kept pushing it off since it was 30 min away from our house. Finally this past weekend we decided to try it out as we were thinking of a new spot to eat at. Couldn't have been happier that we came here. The Chicken Love was to die for! Even the appetizers were great - I highly recommend their Thai Chili Calamari. This is a spot you must try out. More...

G

Giancarlo R.

18 September 2018

Amazing service, the staff was very professional everyone made you feel like you were right at home. Jason helped my family & I have the best  dinner we could ask for. Just amazing all around I would give more stars if I could!! Thank you guys again, will definitely be back More...

E

Erik W.

18 September 2018

Excellent service, excellent food! Finally a place around town with great authentic Italian food. Went there last night with my girlfriend and will definitely be back soon!

P

PhilandEllen Mistrette

9 August 2018

Went here today! Great pizza got the drunken grandma pie! Also had the mussels so fresh!! We will be back.

J

Jacqueline Laurita

9 August 2018

I love everything about this place! Warm, friendly, excellent authentic food from authentic people! The atmosphere feels like you're in someone's home. I also love that they have gluten-free options AND that they deliver. I've known the Wakile's for a long time and cooking has always been a passion of theirs and the love definitely comes through in the food. My picky, food-loving, Italian husband said it's the best pizza he's ever had. It reminds him of his Grandmothers pizza. He said it's the real deal. We LOVE it!! Everyone involved did an excellent job with this place and the locals are very excited about it! Congratulations! We wish you all tons of success! XOXO! More...

V

Vinny Zucchini

9 August 2018

My wife and I traveled from Delaware to visit our kids and their family in north Jersey over this Thanksgiving holiday. We also had planned to visit Pizza Love restaurant in Wyckoff N.J.
We were not disappointed, first by appearance of the restaurant, and then by how welcoming the staff was. While we were there, Kathy Wakile came in and we had the pleasure of meeting her. What a warm delightful person she is, she actually came over and shared in some conversation, i gotta tell ya, she's even prettier in person ;). Her husband Rich also came in and was extremely friendly as well, very nice guy. They made us feel like family, we had a great time, it was a wonderful experience.
We will definitely be going back, looking forward to seeing them both again.
Thank you Kathy and Rich, it was truly a pleasure to meet you both.
More...

P

Peter Daibes

9 August 2018

The best in the industry! Very impressed, definitely a restaurant to come back to for years to come

P

Phyllis-Gary Dedoussis

9 August 2018

As a fan of RHONJ, I had to check out Pizzalove & I was SO impressed. Started with garlic cheese bread and rock shrimp, both were delicious and the portion of rock shrimp was HUGE. I had the eggplant parm dinner and my daughter had the chicken parm dinner. Both dinners were amazing! Only thing I didn't like was the bright lighting, but thats a simple fix. � Will be back very soon!! More...

S

Sheridan Bowie

9 August 2018

Came all the way from Long Island, NY and my boyfriend and I were soooooo pleased! We got the drunk grandma which was amazing, and the chicken parm dinner to split. We will absolutely return ♥️

D

Donna Hill Luberger

9 August 2018

Delicious food, fabulous service, friendly and efficient help. Kathy , the owner is soooo nice. I will definitely be coming back!!

P

Peggy Creange

9 August 2018

Fantastic place in so many ways!... Ambience is warm and inviting... service was prompt and courteous... Pizza was delicious and we split a large salad with pears that was not only more than enough for 3 people, it was so tasty with fresh ingredients!... One of the best parts Wes's that Kathy was there.... and not only did she greet each customer with a smile, she stopped at each table and spoke to the customer like they've known each other since high school. A real old world charm that you don't see often these days. Wyckoff is truly lucky to have this adorable addition to town. I would wish Pizza Love luck, but I don't think they'll be needing it! More...

A

Ana Aarro

9 August 2018

Best Italian food I ever had. The portions were huge and the prices were great. Will definitely be my new place to eat.

K

Kim Smith

9 August 2018

Traveled from Baltimore, Md for my birthday this weekend to come here. I am so happy I did, it was delicious and the staff are all so nice and polite. I highly recommend Pizza Love to everyone More...

M

Michael Roberts

9 August 2018

There is nothing about this place that I don't love! Delicious, fresh food, big portions, reasonable prices, spotlessly clean, and a warm, cozy atmosphere with friendly staff! My only complaint is that I had trouble choosing what I wanted to order off of their massive menu! I had the pleasure of meeting the owner, Kathy, and her husband, Richie, and her son, Joseph. They are all very warm people who made me feel at home in their restaurant, which is something you don't encounter very often. It is fantastic that they maintain a presence in their establishment to ensure that their patrons enjoy their experience and the daily operations run smoothly. It is evident in every which way that PizzaLove isn't just another business; it is a labor of love and the food is prepared with passion. I ordered a Caesar salad and split the penne alla vodka with a friend. Outstanding! Delicious sauce and the pasta was cooked to al dente perfection! If you are ever in Bergen County, I would definitely recommend this place! It's only a 20-minute drive from the George Washington Bridge. I will definitely be returning many times in the future :-) More...

D

Denise Cimmino-Limone

9 August 2018

Another awesome dinner from Pizza Love! My husband absolutely loved the mussels & every salad I ever had there is the best. Pizza is fabulous & so are the paninis & pasta dishes. If you want a home cooked meal.... try pizza love! More...

K

Kim Marino Resetar

9 August 2018

This place is amazing. Some of the most authentic tasting Italian food. Everything is cooked to perfection. This place is becoming my new favorite!

E

Elise Rodenhiser

9 August 2018

Got in the car this morning and drove to chase housewives � we didn’t see any but we shopped till we dropped and the food here was ah-mazingggg.... we don’t even like pizza and holy cow... and the salads.... DID NOT DISAPPOINT More...

A

Ali Cash

9 August 2018

Absolutely the best pizza we have ever had-An impromptu trip to "chase the housewives" as we called it brought us here during our shopping excursion! Kathy what an amazing place-definitely worth a trip! More...

D

Doris Blackwell Amato

9 August 2018

Great service...the Love Salad with grilled chicken was delicious! Family had pasta vodka, gnocchi bolognese, eggplant rollitini...everything was amazing. Cappachino and zeppoles for dessert...so good. Will definitely go back. More...

M

Monika Fijor

9 August 2018

Kids loved the food ..service was friendly, very big portions..nice clean place
Very cute town ��

D

Denise Antonetti-Murrell

9 August 2018

First time and will not be our last... not only was the food amazingly good,we had wonderful service and everyone was so friendly...Kathy and Richie were so nice it was a pleasure meeting you both! More...

J

Joe Spaccavento

9 August 2018

Went last night. They were slammed with customers but the food was excellent! Chocolate chip zepoles were amazing. We’ll be back!

P

Paul C.

3 July 2018

Did not expect this place to be so good. Thought it would be just another pizzeria with acceptable Italian food. Many choices, reasonable prices, generous portions, exciting flavors and a friendly staff. We will definitely return.

S

Stef G.

3 July 2018

Stumbled upon this place near my job on my way home- came in around 8:45 after work and ordered pizza to go. Everything in the window looked so  fresh it was hard to decide. Service was super quick and polite, ordered 3 specialty slices, a plain slice, and it came to just shy of $15.  The portions were huge!! While I was inside I saw a plate of shrimp pasta and they are def family sized portions... super generous with the amount of food they give you for the price. Will absolutely be returning and was so excited to find out they deliver to me! More...

D

Dianna N.

22 June 2018

By far the BEST scampi sauce anywhere! I was down for the count for days with a migraine and my mom grabbed me some take out and I am thrilled she went here! The shrimp was so fresh and the sauce was to die for ! The pasta perfectly cooked and the bread it came with was amazing!  The portion was unreal I had half for dinner, some for lunch and still enough for the next day. They have a lot of healthy items as well which I'll be trying next time! More...

N

Nancy E.

14 May 2018

I really like the food here. The pizza and the pasta are exceptional. However on more than occasion the service leads a little to be desired. They are friendly but sometimes don't quite understand the menu or food. Most recently we ordered sandwiches for a mother's day picnic, ordered a eggplant cutlet sandwich and specified NOT grilled... repeated NOT grilled 3 times.  We got to our picnic destination and guess what.  GRILLED eggplant!! For which we were charged extra $3 for!!!Very frustrating. I hope they can figure out how to correct this. I want this restaurant to last since the pizza is so good. More...

A

Amy A.

25 April 2018

The food is really good, and even better, the staff is so nice and thoughtful. I work close to Pizza Love so we've eaten in the restaurant and have had food delivered to the office and the staff is always great.

T

Tom H.

21 April 2018

Stopped in for a quick lunch while passing through town. It's in a strip mall but inside is very nice, feels more like a casual restaurant than a slice joint. Workers very friendly and accommodating, seemed a little more expensive than a normal pizza shop but food was great. Definitely stop in if you are in the area. More...

M

Mish C.

2 April 2018

Ordered a pepperoni pie and it was good. This place is definitely a lot better than the business that was here before it. They have a huge selection of items on their menu so if you go with a group, there's an option for everyone.

M

Melissa D.

26 March 2018

I was excited to try this restaurant and I was not disappointed. I stopped in for lunch and I got 2 slices of pizza. I ate the margarita slice in the restaurant. The staff seemed a bit discombobulated and very stressed. I brought a slice of the balsamic chicken with me and I wanted to sneak a peak before I got going. It looked delicious so I decided to take one bite, and next thing I knew I had eaten the whole slice. It was excellent! Slightly crunchy chicken with soft cheese and a balsamic drizzle - yum! I will definitely return. More...

M

Mick R.

28 February 2018

Ordered the pizza.16" LargeCrust:   Stretched out perfectly thin, foldable with nice soft chew in the innards.  Undercrust  baked well-done, some mottled dark spots and char enhancing flavor, and provides a light crispy veneer. Cracks a bit on the fold.  Sauce:  Excellent ratios and juice factor, produces a positively scalding hot slice.  Balanced spices, and a good tomato flavor, some richness, butter maybe.  Cheese:  Lots of mozzarella, great melt and perfume. Perfect saltiness. More...

R

Rami M.

27 February 2018

Best pizza & Italian food hands down. Pizza Love is the perfect family owned restaurant. My entire family became fans since opening day. The staff was warm and welcoming. The interior decoration is beautiful and clean. It's hard to find both excellent food, matched by excellent service. However, Pizza Love set a new standard for pizzeria's in the area. Recommend it to everyone. 5 Stars without a doubt More...

J

Jonathan M.

24 February 2018

Had a delicious meal/experience last week @ Pizza Love.   There was a great crowd, the restaurant was full of laughter and people having a great time.  Started with the thai calamari which was PERFECTO, super good. I had the escarole and beans with I found very authentic, hearty, delicious. My wife had specialty salad, i forget which one but she loved it.  The kids had pizza which was banging (they said the best the ever had).  We will definitely go back and bring our friends next time.  BTW the table next to me had a seafood salad which looked legit so I will order that next time as well. More...

S

Stephanie M.

11 February 2018

Finally got to try Pizza Love and I was completely blown away by the quality of food! We ordered takeout for a family get together of 15 people so we ordered an array of pizzas, apps, and pasta. Every pie was amazing and the rice balls were out of this world!! The bolognese sauce is as authentic as if I were making it on a Sunday! Pizza Love is our new go to Pizza place to order and we could not be happier to have A+++ pizza so close!! More...

J

Julie D.

7 February 2018

I always loved Kathy Wakile on RHONJ, so I've been dying to try her restaurant! Everything was delicious, I was so impressed. Started out with garlic cheese bread and rock shrimp, both so yummy and the rock shrimp portion was HUGE. I had the chicken parm dinner and my mom had the eggplant parm dinner and both dishes had great flavor and were a big portion. Our server Stephanie was super nice and the service was on point. I cant wait to go back for dinner ASAP! More...

J

Jennifer m.

1 February 2018

They made it right. Thanks! Just ordered again. Best salads!!!Update - ordered tonight. They did not give me the right/requested salad dressing. My husband received no salad dressing. Salad dressing is one of the most important parts of the salad. It's a Thursday night not a Friday. DisappointedMy original review from last week is below. Their Roman salad is so good. We ordered from there last night. Amazing. Toppings galore and I ordered it with grilled chicken. The bread they give with the food is so delicious. Garlic but better. Husband got the penne bolognese which was excellent. More...

C

Cathy P.

27 January 2018

What a treat! Amazing selection of delicious pizzas!My daughter and I each had a slice and split a pear salad. So fresh and so delicious! Just wish this place were closer to home! Thanks Pizza Love for a great lunch! More...

P

Patricia E.

21 January 2018

Rumor has it this is one of the best places for pizza so we had to try. It was very good, cooked as requested (well done, light on the sauce).  Only negative is delivery took over an hour, so this is not a last minute decision place to order from.  We look forward to trying some of the dishes from their extensive menu. More...

D

Demi G.

20 January 2018

Excellent had the bbq pizza great taste not your typical pizza that's what makes it delicious. Had the vodka basil mozzarella Sicilian another hit. Clean beautiful decor. The cannoli was the best. More...

C

Cristina Z.

17 January 2018

The food was good! Buffalo mozzarella sticks are delicious. The restaurant was clean. Went there for lunch on MLK day with friends, it was pretty empty. We ordered the sandwich special - half sandwich and ceasar salad. The sandwich came out a full sandwich and was great! The staff was helpful and sweet, but a little ditzy. I would definitely go back to try out their dinner. More...

E

Em F.

6 January 2018

Delicious! Pizza is so good.  Ingredients are fresh and interesting toppings. We had the chicken scarp one night and I LOVED IT, lots of garlic how I like it.  Really, really loved the food here and will definitely be back!! More...

V

Vincent S.

14 December 2017

Pizza Love Hooked up our holiday party! Everything from a Giant hero down to the Salmon Picatta was phenomenal... Highly recommend for catering all events... Thanks for the Quality and friendly service More...

N

Nicole B.

13 December 2017

Best pizza I've had in a looong time! Delivery in half the ttime they said. Had pizza, salad and a wrap. All amazing!

N

Natalia C.

12 December 2017

I'll preface this review by stating that I am one of the most skeptical and critical people when it comes to trying Italian food outside of home. My expectations for pizzeria food were by far surpassed when I first tried Pizza Love. I'll describe my first experience from start to finish but if you want my quick opinion - clean, exceptionally flavorful dishes for pizzeria style restaurant, attentive staff, HIGHLY recommend. Have already been here about 3 times and don't plan to stop coming despite not living in the area.First, I was taken aback by how bright and clean the restaurant is kept. The atmosphere here would likely exceed anyone's expectation for a pizzeria.To start, we somehow selected a handful of appetizers from the extensive menu. By this point we had already decided we would come back to try some others. We ordered rock shrimp arrabiata, calamari, calamari in thai chili sauce, and mussels. Each were outstanding, fresh and the portion size is unbeatable for the reasonable prices. My absolute favorite is the rock shrimp arrabiata. I've had it three times since and it's consistently delicious.For dinner we ordered drunk grandma pie, cavatelli with broccoli rabe and sausage, and a few other pasta dishes but the cavatelli w/ broccoli rabe and sausage stole my heart. It's actually my favorite pasta dish that my Nonna makes (I can't tell her this is just as good lol).For dessert, we had cheesecake bites, brownie bites, and zeppoles (we went all out). I'm not even a dessert person and I was already stuffed but I couldn't help but indulge. The cheesecake bites were phenom.The staff is young and learning but certainly attentive and much friendlier than your average pizzeria wait staff. Overall, the food by far surpassed my expectations. I was expecting to come in, order a few pies for myself, my boyfriend and his parents and just have a casual dinner. I was blown away by the quality of the dishes and the array of options. My boyfriends parents are quite the critics and could not wait to come back.HIGHLY recommend! More...

T

Taline-Shadi N.

8 December 2017

What can I say amazing food, great staff so much to order from on the menu. Absolutely loved everything we ordered. All the dishes had a kick to it with the different spices and seasonings. Can't wait to go back

D

David M.

6 December 2017

I have been very impressed with Pizza Love since it has opened as we have been in need of a good Pizza place in Wyckoff with decent parking available.  We have made our way around the menu now having tried regular pizza, stuffed pizza, Stromboli, several appetizers and several main courses.  2 minor complaints.  The fried ravioli appetizer was very spicy for some reason.  I am hoping that it was just a mistake as if they are always that hot than we could not eat them again.  Also forgot blue cheese with a wing order and did not realize it. The pizza's have all been excellent and the care watching them make the pizzas and finish them is very encouraging. Eating in one day and ordering a veal dish and a gnocchi dish and both were excellent.  One issue that they will need to figure out as due to their success the pizza lead time can get very long for pickup or delivery.  The wait for regular food and appetizers is not near as long.  So there can be time when you meals or appetizer are sitting on the counter awaiting your pizza to be finished.  This can lead to either cooler food or food that steams in their trays for to long.  But I think this is growing pains and they will learn to adjust.  We are very happy to have them in town and hope they keep improving on the little things.  No real complaints about the food and nice to have the return of a good pizza place in Wyckoff. More...

D

Denice L.

4 December 2017

Got the awesome gigantic menu in our mailbox and ordered take out last night to give it a try.  It was fantastic The Rock Shrimp appetizer was incredible wish we had ordered two!!!!! Got a cold sub which was great and Cavatelli with Sausage and Broccoli  Rabe and added in a Breaded Cutlet it was delish!   Ordered a side order of Kale and Garlic which also was yummy!Can't wait to go eat there it was really a great meal!!!!!!!!!!   So glad to add another great place to the neighborhood More...

E

Ed D.

1 December 2017

Now this new place is really good news!We tried takeout from here tonight. We did not order pizza but tried some other traditional Iti foods..Chicken dinner was delicious! Cooked perfectly and tender.Pasta outstanding! Eggplant outstanding!Rock shrimp appy was delicious as well.Note to owners: keep the chefs happy... happy chef = happy life..Doesn't rhyme but you get the message..Can't wait to try your pizza.. More...

G

Gianine T.

26 November 2017

Excellent food and service! From appetizers to dessert we were not disappointed. Great atmosphere for having dinner with your family, friends, or for a date night. Nicely decorated. Owners walked up to our table multiple times to make sure we were enjoying our meal. Would come back here for dinner/take out in a heartbeat! Must haves:  calamari, grandmas pie, and cannolis More...

T

Tuna J.

26 November 2017

I ordered for the first time today. My expectations were low because of the place's association with one of the most reprehensible shows on TV (RHONJ). I must say, we were VERY happy with the food. Very solid Italian hero, great bread. The pizza was very solid, tasted great. Will order again, I really liked it, may be the best pizza in town now. The sausage pizza is special... they put chunks of sausage on like Lodi Pizza does it.... very very good. Highly recommend. Food was fresh and tasty. More...

M

Michael R.

20 November 2017

Very high quality, fresh food and big portions! I was very impressed. I ordered a Caesar salad and shared the penne alla vodka with my friend.. so delicious I couldn't stop eating! Very friendly, welcoming and homey environment and the interior is spotless. Kathy, the owner, is an absolute doll! It is clear that this restaurant is a labor of love for her. I also had the opportunity to meet her husband Richie, her son Joseph, and Daryl, one of the managers. Lovely people!! I will definitely be coming back in the future. Highly recommend!! More...

N

Nicole L.

20 November 2017

I traveled all the way from Long Island to try Kathy and Richie's restaurant, and I was so impressed! The food was so delicious, best vodka sauce and one of the freshest salads I've had. Kathy and Richie made us feel right at home. I will definitely be coming back! More...

J

Janet Bob H.

15 November 2017

Ate out last-minute with my hubby here.  I've been wanting to try it even though my young adults went for pizza and were disappointed.  My husband and I review Italian places by how good the lasagna is for him and how good the eggplant rollatini is for me.  They were both excellent.Lasagna was homemade and sauce was the right combo of meat and thick gravy/sauce.  The cheese was just enough.  And the #1 thing was the sauce/gravy is not over salted!!!  The flavor is delicious without tons of salt like other pizza places.My eggplant was delicious as well.  Now as far as the pizza for me who stopped in another time for just a slice to take out.  I found the Sicilian option was delicious for me.  Pizza for me is all about the crust.  Similar to my crust favored "Giovanni's" who was bought out of this place, they use a more hearty crust than the other pizza places in the area.  I also like again a sauce less salted and can appreciate the homemade quality.The service was excellent there and had no trouble getting a seat.  This was a Thursday night though. More...

C

Cort D.

13 November 2017

Visited Pizza Love recently for a friends birthday.  We had about 8 people.  When you walk in it looks like a regular pizza place but a little nicer and more upscale.  Yet..when the food came out I was super surprised.It was an incredible array of not just pizza, but outstanding pasta and appetizers.  The food was to die for, and of course, in the traditional Italian style, there was SO MUCH OF IT!  The pizza was stellar, rivaling it against any high-end pizza place in New York.  Lastly, Kathy and her husband Rich were gracious hosts.  The place had great energy, and I am super excited to come back and try new things on the menu.Oh, and BTW- the Nutella pizza was out of this world! Ciao! More...

B

Brianna W.

10 November 2017

Great pizza. Huge slices. Salads were great. Great prices for the size of the slices. Owner, Kathy walked around and talked to all the customers. Cute decor for the restaurant as well! More...

J

Jake K.

10 November 2017

By far one of the best pizza places I've ever been to. Employees were extremely hospital and attentive, despite the rush. I tried the BBQ chicken pizza and the Nutella-Strawberry pie. Both were phenomenal. Giancarlo was our waiter and couldn't have been nicer. Kathy Wakile, you've done an excellent job designing this place, best of luck! More...

R

R K.

4 November 2017

Best eggplant parmigiana I ever had and I am not a fan of egglplant!  I love this place. My mom who is extremely picky loves it too and she is impossible!  Definitely going back!

F

Frank M.

29 October 2017

Amazing pizza! Subs and salads are great too. Great to have to close to home! Perfect for lunch at work

J

john c.

28 October 2017

I really didn't want to like it because of the hype, but I have to say the food was great.  The menu looks like a normal mom and pop pizzeria but the food is much better.  The vodka sauce pizza, the balsamic chicken pizza, the pasta with broccoli rabe and the pernetti vodka were great.  The only thing I wasn't happy with was the zeppolis, the were a little tough and soft and crunchy.  I must add the while the staff were young they were very nice and attentive.  We've been there 4 times in the past 2 weeks and we'll be back. More...

V

Vito L.

28 October 2017

Awesome place! Place is immaculate. Owners are respectful and pleasant. Food is CRAZY generous. Prices are inexpensive. Only wish they had regular American covfefe.  Highly recommended!

N

Nada H.

28 October 2017

Delicious food! I rate Pizza Love a 5/5 on the quality of food, atmosphere and ambiance. Super cute & friendly! Great staff and owners! Had the most tasteful gnocchi with vodka sauce, a thin crust personal sized margarita pizza and the most delicious fried shrimp in a spicy jalapeno sauce. Oh and lets not forget the freshly made zeppoles!! HIGHLY recommend Pizza Love and will definitely be going back! More...

J

Jessica L.

27 October 2017

Wow!  We ordered the Drunk Grandma pizza and had it delivered.  Not only was it delivered in less time than we expected,  but it smelled amazing!  And the taste was even better! We will definitely be trying other items on the menu soon. More...

L

Lee S.

27 October 2017

I just moved to Wyckoff 3 weeks ago, and I am walking distance to pizza love. There is no need for me to cook again. I love pizza love! Everything has been great. The salads are amazing. I order the ceaser salad with grilled salmon. Sooooo good. The dressing is a 10 for ceasar dressing- it's perfect. The salmon is perfectly cooked and seasoned. The quality is top notch. My boyfriend is a pizza snob and said the Greek pizza slice was extraordinary. We've been taking out 2x a week and plan to continue. I'm looking forward to trying more items on the menu. Penne with vodka sauce was excellent. Did I mention I am walking distance. I'm in love With pizza love. Also- staff is very friendly and professional. More...

E

E B.

26 October 2017

I been wanted to try this place for a white now so my sister and I went here yesterday and we love it everything was amazing  the Mac and cheese bites with ranch   dressing was "money' we will def be back

M

Matt O.

23 October 2017

This new restaurant is definitely worth the try, the food is great, had he chicken vodka pasta sandwich and the penne which was A+. Would highly recommend, only spots for improvement would be good prep speed and a new menu with a better graphic design haha ALSO ADD AN ONLINE MENU More...

C

Caroline S.

22 October 2017

Everything about this place is absolutely incredible. The food and the service is beyond incredible. Everything I have tried has completely blown my expectations. If you have not had the opportunity to try the food here, you must. Bergen county is lucky to have a place like this! I will defiantly be back and will tell everyone I know to come try it. More...

C

Connor B.

22 October 2017

Great little pizza place. Overall a great vibe of the place. The service and the food is outstanding. The prices can't be beat and I'll for sure be coming back in order to try more options off the menu. Great place to have close by. The brownie bites are so good a must try for dessert when coming here. More...

N

Nancy C.

21 October 2017

This is our favorite pizzeria!  The service was good every one was nice and friendly. Not your regular corner pizzeria super cute place.  We had fried calamari was fresh and cooked perfectly. The bean an escarole soup was absolutely delicious my favorite.  We also ordered the big meat pie the sauce variety of meat where to begin LOVE LOVE LOVE. No wonder it's called pizza love!!! More...

P

Paul Q.

15 October 2017

This place is Amazing! Just when I thought "Here's another pizza place" I was blown away by the whole experience of Pizza Love. First, the décor is beautiful. The place was packed when I went with my partner after work on a Friday evening, but the energy and the vibe in this place was on high. The servers and staff are all outgoing, friendly, and have their act together- you'll quickly notice how they all work as a Team to get the job done. They are the nicest people who take pride in their work and where they work.  Brace yourself for the Menu: its huge!! They, literally, have Everything and will make whatever you want the way you want it. You need time to digest the menu and decide what you want to have. This is definitely NOT a typical pizza joint- looking around at the other diners, they all had beautifully presented plates and portions that were huge. In fact, I think the theme of this place is "Go Big or Go Home"--these portions are gigantic so plan on taking most of it home. At a loss for what to try, I stuck with an old standby: Pizza Margarita. I haven't had pizza like this since Italy or Brooklyn! Soft, delicate, perfectly seasoned, with amazing undertones from the tomato sauce and basil. Fluffy crust not your thing? Fear not, there are many thin crust options too. My partner had an Italian hero that came beautifully prepared and served with homemade potato chips. We both took doggie bags home because there was no way to eat all that food in one sitting. The amount of people coming and going out with bags and boxes of take out, plus the group waiting to be seated, and the full dining room tells me I am not the only one who thinks this place is here to stay. This is, by far, amazing Italian food. All I can say is bring your favorite bottle of wine, grab your friends, and definitely bring your appetite because Pizza Love will not disappoint. I will definitely be back--often!! More...

D

Debbie B.

14 October 2017

Yummy Pizza...made with vodka sauce chicken basil....zzzzzbest!Everyone's so sweet just like family

D

Desiree V.

14 October 2017

We went to Pizza Love for dinner on a Saturday night and it was nothing short of amazing. I had the Chicken Bruschetta and my boyfriend had the vodka wrap. Amazing! We also had amazing desserts (cannolis, Nutella pie, and brownie bites) The atmosphere is beautiful. Darryl, the owner, was very hands on and accommodating. He provided great suggestions and a warm atmosphere. We will definitely return! More...

A

Anonymous P.

13 October 2017

Needed a casual BYOB like this in the area!Calamari was great, got the "drunk Grandma" pie which was also great. Would like to go back to try more entrees and stuff like that.Cannoli was the best I have ever had, and I'm not even a cannoli person. Will go back for sure! More...

S

Stefani D.

12 October 2017

Been wanting to try this place since it opened, and finally convinced my office we should order from there. My pizza reputation was on the line, but we were not disappointed! We ordered the pepperoni special, plain, and the white pizza with breaded eggplant, broccoli and garlic = ALL awesome! Lots of pizza places in the area, but Pizza Love is definitely worth a visit. Really cute interior as well , and was pretty crowded for lunchtime. Staff was friendly and helpful. I will definitely be back again to try their salad pizza! More...

J

Jon D.

9 October 2017

Stopped by on our way back to the city...delicious food, generous portions. Try the pasta and Thai styled calamari!

E

Elizabeth B.

5 October 2017

Visiting back in the ol 201 this past weekend to see my sister.We went here to eat lunch because we had heard it was pretty good.The Buffalo Chicken slice was life changingly GOOD! My sister had the eggplant parm which she said was not near as good as our Mom's who is also Italian but she did love her salad. It was very fresh.The staff was friendly, attentive and clean. the place is cute & clean and the prices are fair. Good size portions too. I'm not swayed by the owner's tv persona at all because I am not all that familiar with her. As far as being a restaurant owner though, she is doing a good job. More...

L

Lindsey R.

1 October 2017

I've had Pizza Love (takeout) twice since they opened and I've had a good experience both times. They have a large selection of pizza, pasta, salad, entrees and much more. So far I've had speciality and plain pizza, two pasta dishes (ziti and penne vodka) and wings all of which were good. The inside is cozy but modern, had great service and was BYO. More...

J

Joe P.

29 September 2017

Amazing food and service. The pizza is delicious as are all of the dinners I've tried. The fried calamari is fresh and fried to perfection! I've been here 3 times in the week since they have been open. Top it off with a delicious espresso. 5 stars without a doubt. The gnocchi siciliano is a must try!! More...

Photos (2)

See all