Loading...

Please wait ...

Pier Fifty-Three Open Air Bar and Brick Oven logo

Pier Fifty-Three Open Air Bar and Brick Oven

Sunset View, New York

(106)
Pier Fifty-Three Open Air Bar and Brick Oven logo

Pier Fifty-Three Open Air Bar and Brick Oven

Sunset View, New York

(106)

Reviews (106)

Leave a review
C

Chelsey Jayne Tryon

15 August 2019

Pier 53 is one of my favorite places to go now! I could go every week. The cauliflower pizza is absolutely to die for and the staff is so friendly. I love the atmosphere and the great food drinks and service! I 100% reccomend PIER 53!! More...

K

Karen Bush

11 August 2019

Wonderful place to just enjoy summer!!! Great live music and fabulous staff!

L

Lisa Emerson Olson

10 August 2019

Our first time & it was SO good! The food is excellent, great staff and service and super nice owner, Bryan. We played corn hole in the side yard and wish we could have stayed for the music! Highly recommend! We will definitely be back! More...

M

Mike Olson

10 August 2019

Great food atmosphere met the owner Brian. Nice place will be going back for sure.

S

Skip Murrell

30 July 2019

Extremely friendly. Make you feel like family from the first visit. Food and serves great. Out of the way, but worth the find by boat or car

E

Elwood Murrell

28 July 2019

Went twice while on vacation in the area, you were made to feel welcome right away and like family before leaving. The food was great-cook perfect and quick. For an out of the way place, the prices great. Would recommend this place to anyone and we will be back. Thank you for a great time. More...

C

Chris Mieney

27 July 2019

Was there last night, bugs came out, out of nowhere. Owner brought us 2 citronella candles and bug spray. If you want a place with excellent food, drinks and owners that truly care about their patrons, then this is your place.

T

Thomas Harkin

27 July 2019

Great atmosphere

A

andrew litzinger

27 July 2019

Had a great dinner. 5 of us had 5 different pizzas. The BBQ was my personal favorite. The owner is great. We were there when the bugs came out and when he noticed we were getting bit he gave us bug spray and citronella candles. We will definitely be back.

M

Michael Sinnott

25 July 2019

Great service , atmosphere and food!

D

Debora Otto

25 July 2019

Nice view of the bay, just stopped there waiting for our boat ride to one of the Islands and didn't have time to get something to eat.

S

steven sullivan

25 July 2019

Just a great place, with a great view and great atmosphere. We will be back!!!

J

Joanne Greco

18 July 2019

❤️❤️. Very very friendly employees and food was great. Can’t beat the atmosphere either

V

Veronica Weber Knope

16 July 2019

Great food, casual environment, and the staff was so friendly! We’ll definitely be back

S

Samatha Stephens

16 July 2019

The biggest pretzel I've ever seen, and yummy!

L

Lindy Burke

16 July 2019

Great service and great food! Very gluten free friendly! Offered to have chefs change gloves and pay attention for cross contamination. Highly recommend! Food, service and atmosphere were wonderful! Will come again and again. More...

J

Jody Brockmyre Barker

12 July 2019

Fun place to stop and grab some food if you are on the east side of the bay. Great views, good music, menu is versatile and the staff is friendly.

W

William H. Butterworth

9 July 2019

Great open air bar. Friendly staff Great pizzas

D

Denise Thompson

5 July 2019

Food was great. Staff friendly. Pieces were better than The Point. We will be back!!!!!

M

Michael Gouldrick

5 July 2019

Good food, good price, great staff.

B

Brandon Thanks

30 June 2019

Beautiful place.

K

KJ A

30 June 2019

A new twist on an old location. Nice atmosphere, great views, service was good.

D

David Hendrikx

30 June 2019

Very good service , great pizza and a beautiful view of Sodus Bay!

M

Mark Sharp

30 June 2019

Delicious lunch and fantastic open air environment. Worth the drive.

M

Melissa Wendell Burke

29 June 2019

Food was delicious. great view on water. Mark Herrmann sounded great!

J

Josh Dinehart

29 June 2019

amazing food, friendly staff and so much for kids to do !

A

Alexander Traina

28 June 2019

Friendly and attentive waitstaff with quality food and a phenomenal view.

C

Chuck Weader

26 June 2019

Good food, beer is cold, good service. Owner is very friendly.

A

Allison Ganze

20 June 2019

Visiting my grandparents and we stopped here! Loved it! Awesome staff, drinks and food! Thank you Bryan and Kolton! ❤️

K

Kelly DeVito

20 June 2019

We are year round residents and this has quickly become our favorite spot for drinks or dinner or both! Excellent service, personable staff, great live music and always at the perfect volume! Highly recommended I love the outdoor games and fun family atmosphere. The kids love going as much as we do! Great job, guys More...

L

Lynnette M Olson

20 June 2019

We enjoyed the view and cocktails and beer. We bought three different pizzas all with cauliflower crusts. We’re waiting to enjoy them for dinner. Thanks Bryan and Kolton for the hospitality We’ll be back More...

J

Joan Raus Loveless

19 June 2019

Great pizza and a view to kill!

D

Doug Barr

18 June 2019

great service. friendly staff. great food and drinks. very nice come support them.

C

Cathy Stewart

16 June 2019

Great music and service !

S

Steve Groot

10 June 2019

Very enjoyable great atmosphere

B

Barbara Mayo

9 June 2019

Fantastic wings & best service in the area. If you want a perfect sunset view w great atmosphere, this is the great place to be!

T

Timothy VanDuyne

9 June 2019

Place is absolutely amazing! Service and food are great! Love the gluten free options! Pizza and baked fried pickles were terrific! The owner checked on us twice. My wife dropped her cell phone under the deck. The manager and staff worked for 30 minutes to retrieve it! Amazing! You can tell the owner is passionate about his restaurant and customers! Keep up the good work! More...

M

Michael Cellini Jr

1 June 2019

Good pizza and beautiful view of Sodus Bay!

J

Jon Caves

27 May 2019

Great place, nice views ,open air bar, and great staff

S

Susan Moulton

27 May 2019

Hanging here is so relaxing, lots to do corn hole, jenga, very friendly staff, chicken smelled great, tables outside, big bar inside.

T

Todd Mitchell

26 May 2019

Great updated menu! awesome service. packed house and everything was hot and on time!

C

Christine Lyn

25 May 2019

Friendly staff /owner that went out of their way ! Great food and atmosphere, can’t wait to go back!!!!!

T

Tom Jon

24 May 2019

Great food and dining experience! Great family location, the owner is very hospitable and welcoming! Stop in and eat and play!

M

Michael Capes

20 May 2019

Barbecue chicken Pizza is the best. wings are cooked right. had a cornhole tournament while there. And Tara the bartender is the tops, killer personality.

L

Lizzie Mangieri Hubright

20 May 2019

Went for the first time last night and we loved it! Our server was very friendly and service was prompt. The pizza and drinks were delicious! Very clean establishment! Can’t wait to return this summer! More...

R

rick graffrath

13 May 2019

food is good, excellent service(Tara!)

N

NICHOLAS MILLER

6 May 2019

Awesome concept

L

Levi Stone

2 May 2019

I’ve been here a few times and had great food and service every time!

T

Troy Cusson

1 May 2019

Great Staff! Great Views! Really Good Food

D

Deb Hibbard

13 April 2019

"House Favorite" Pizza was outstanding. Enjoyed the sun and the view on one of the first nice Spring days. Will be back FOR SURE!!

K

Kelly Price-Koury

13 April 2019

Wonderful place for the whole family. We have been there several times and the food and service is always great along with a spectacular view.

R

Robert Keim

4 April 2019

Great open-air atmosphere, friendly staff, and great food!

D

Deb Stritzel

24 March 2019

great atmosphere, food and service. plates for the food please?

R

Rob Keim

24 March 2019

Great atmosphere and great food! Friendly staff - and we can’t wait to go back this summer.

A

Alena Premo

17 March 2019

Love this place. Beautiful views!! Great owners. And Bartenders ❤️

F

Fran Alini

6 March 2019

Great place to chill

J

Jon sutton

6 March 2019

Great pizza. Friendly staff.

K

Kimberley Ess

6 March 2019

New building, very nice,can't wait to go back in the summer.

S

S Gallo

6 March 2019

Pizza and wings were delicious

J

joan m. Loveless

5 March 2019

Everything was delish! Pizza, wedge salads, sausage sliders all very good!! Great service and the view was wonderful!!

A

Andrea Buckalew

5 March 2019

The owner was so gracious and accommodating to our party, which included kids. Very hospitable and kind. The food was great! Wings were delish!!

C

Cassi Hursh

2 March 2019

these pretzels are the best!

S

Susan Hughes Johnson

24 February 2019

Pizza was very good and the pretzel was huge. We’ll go back again.

C

Christi Biroscak

24 February 2019

Great atmosphere and delicious food! The cheeseburger pizza and fire roasted wings were amazing!

E

Eric Abbott

24 February 2019

Nice place !! Real wood fired pizza and wings !! Gonna be a awesome place in warmer weather, all the doors open and great views off Sodus Bay . But they do a great job even in the winter !!!! We only tried the pizza , very good ! The staff was great . We met the owner Bryan , he introduced himself And conversed for a bit . He said he has a lot of entertainment booked starting Memorial Day !! Love this place !! More...

M

Marc Craine

22 February 2019

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Friendly staff and the best food around

D

Danielle Drechsler

2 February 2019

Just tried Pier Fifty-Three for the first time. My husband and I enjoyed the pizza and wings! We met the owners, great people! We look forward to summer, this will definitely be a favorite place for us to go! More...

R

Ron Modzel

6 January 2019

Great place. Pizza is a must get item.

S

Sherry Handel

6 January 2019

Loved the wood fired pizza !

L

Lucy Ferruzza

30 December 2018

Waitress was very attentive and atmosphere casual. Will be fantastic this summer! Enjoyed the entertainment too!

S

Scott Moore

5 December 2018

You can not beat the view on the bay. Great food, if you are feeling adventurous go with the cheeseburger pizza. Plenty of games to keep the children entertained while you enjoy a beverage. Seems family friendly without being stuffy. There has always been live music when I'm there. Excited that they are very boat and sled friendly. Staff is funny / witty with just enough snark to keep folks in check. Owner helped me out of a flat tire jam, and went above and beyond. Very pleased with the asthetic of the new building. This is one of my favorite places on the bay. More...

J

Justin Kerr

1 December 2018

excellent pizza. awesome service. worth every bit of your time and money.

L

Lori Scibetta Leiby

25 November 2018

Great place!! Always a fun time!

R

Ray Stacy

25 November 2018

Awesome place. Great Pier 53 burger! Great drinks!

S

Stephen Ruster

25 November 2018

Always the Best with Tara best all around bartender in the area in Wayne and Monroe County!!!

A

Amanda Ashley

25 November 2018

Amazing staff, beautiful view, creative events and really fun atmosphere for all to enjoy. Can't wait to see this place truly come alive in the summertime!

D

David Crandall

23 November 2018

The chicken, bacon and mustard pizza was awesome!

D

Dave Amy McDowell

23 November 2018

Delicious food, good beer and great people. We look forward to many more visits.

L

Laurel Baker

23 November 2018

Great spot! Delicious food, friendly staff, deadly sunset views. Kid and dog friendly. Will be open all winter as well �

K

Kevin Herrick

23 November 2018

We stopped in each of the last three days for food and drinks and ice cream.
The food and drinks are good and the staff is nice and friendly.
Sunday I ordered a spicy Bloody Mary and it came with a full hot dog and bun, a big pickle wedge, a bag of chips and three olives pinned to the drink on a wooden spear. Quite a surprise! Stop by and try the meatballs while your pizza is heating up. We're very happy Pier 53 has opened as its very convenient for us and we plan to go back again and again. Congrats on a very successful first weekend.
More...

M

Marie Mattison Kenyon

23 November 2018

The food and service were very good. Love supporting local businesses! Thank you Tara!

B

Bryan Ritter

23 November 2018

..

R

Rob Grant

22 November 2018

Great pizza and wings with pitchers of draft beer.

D

Dale Skinner

6 November 2018

Great pizza, great views, fair list.

T

tracey frazer

6 November 2018

Very relaxing!

T

Tammy Montagne

6 November 2018

Great pizza!!

G

Gary Pfleegor Jr

27 October 2018

Best wings and pizza we ever had! Music by Amanda Ashley was awesome also. We will be regulars!!

B

Brant W Gill

10 October 2018

Awesome Lake Front Restaurant And Bar!!

J

Jere Minkau

6 October 2018

Will be better when they get a wider beer selection

B

Bryan Ritter

6 October 2018

We have a wonderful new building and picturesque views. All warm food is prepared in a wood fired oven with no assistance from gas or electric. The food is flamed kisses with the tastes of hickory, cherry, apple and oak hardwoods and deserts are prepared pizza style topped of with ice cream. Come see us! More...

L

Lara Newman

6 October 2018

Beautiful view of the bay and great price on drinks. This place is awesome.

D

dean baker

6 October 2018

Nice atmosphere, good prices!!

C

Chad Paige

6 October 2018

Great views and atmosphere

H

Heather Colleen

25 September 2018

Beautiful sunset...stopped in after our son's soccer ⚽ game tonight, had the bruschetta, garlic parmesan wings, & meat pizza, everything was delicious . Thanks Tara & Bryan

S

Sandy McDonald Pagano

17 September 2018

Love it. First of it’s kind around this beautiful location. Wish you all the success you deserve. Your place is wonderful and we look forward to enjoying your delicious food for a long time.

J

Joan Zimmer

15 September 2018

Lunch was very good. The view is amazing. The staff and owner are so friendly.

W

William Barlow

8 September 2018

Great food . Wow this place is so nice.

P

Pat Doohan

7 September 2018

Great atmosphere and good food! Domestic beers are 16 oz cans! Brian the owner came right up and introduced himself. I like it when an owner does that. My constructive criticism comment: an order of wings is 7 pieces. 1 order is not enough for a couple to share. Would be nice if a larger size order of say 10 pieces was also available. More...

D

Deenails1gmail.com Bates

6 September 2018

Great place to hang, have great food & several lawn games. Large area for seating & table plus boat docking. If I had to say negative it would be no Kendall Jackson Chardonnay which in Sodus Point is a staple!

M

Mariah Blake

4 September 2018

Amazing food, fast service and a great view!

S

Sherry Herrick

3 September 2018

We've been a few times already and really enjoy the atmosphere. Plenty of parking by car or boat, great food, friendly staff. We wish them great success and will be back often! More...

D

Deborah Carpenter Van Riper

3 September 2018

lovely casual atmosphere! pizza was great. approved by adult and child alike. loaded nachos were a hit. The twelve year old is already planning a return during apple picking season. Looking forward to coming back and watching the menu grow! More...

K

Kym Triplett

2 September 2018

if you went friday night, go back and give it a chance...they were extremely busy and weren't completely prepared...what service we did get, was fantastic...we will be back when you are fully up and running More...

C

Cindy Flynn

2 September 2018

Only 2 days new. Drink glasses are too small. Pizza was black on the bottom. Great view, nice vibe. It will all come together.

C

Chad Comstock

2 September 2018

Great pizza and service! Will be back!

J

John Bauman

31 August 2018

Stopped by to check it out. Facility is great, perfect view of the bay.

Photos (4)

See all