Loading...

Please wait ...

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe logo logo
P

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe

Admiral's Walk Mobile Home Estates, Florida

(173)
This professional is currently unavailable.
You can request reply and they will reach out as soon as they can.

Photos (4)

See all

Reviews (173)

Leave a review
5/5

173 customer reviews

Loading...
8 August 2019

So we drove over 30 minutes to get there to try their highly reviewed KeyLime pie only to arrive with them completely sold out and making a new group. We had a flight in less than 3 hrs and the team at Pie Heaven broke out a small 6" one baked it special for us than put it on an ice pack for us to take along. NOW THAT'S CUSTOMER SERVICE!! Please know it was well worth the wait. We also got a piece of the coconut custard where the crust reminded me of the flakiness of my amish family. Well worth the drive and price! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 July 2019

Margarita pie yum

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 July 2019

Best pies!!! Outstanding customer service and those pies....

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 July 2019

Little pie shop with great pies. I'm glad I know about this place now.

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 July 2019

Wonderful pie and staff

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 July 2019

Yum-meeee for my tum-meeee!

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 July 2019

The fruit pies were UNBELIEVABLY FRESH! The strawberries were still firm yet tender. Pies are flavorful and baked to showcase the fruits natural flavors and sweetness! Pies were not mushy or overly sugared. Picked up strawberry pie (pie of the day), chocolate pie (chocolatey but not sugar coma inducing), banana cream pie, coconut cream pie, cherry pie, berry pie, peach pie and apple pie! The crusts are EXACTLY how the previous reviews described. Tender, flakes, buttery and structured not crumbly. Homemade pies like grandma makes it style bakery is worth EVERY DOLLAR! Perfect way to celebrate my birthday. Any foodie who appreciates traditional baking techniques will fall in love with the personal touches on each pie and the freshness of every ingredient. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 June 2019

Amazing selection and the apple pie was incredible

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 June 2019

Best pies in town

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 June 2019

I came back here recently and tried out the fruit gluten free mini pies... they were delicious! I got a cherry pie and a 3 berry pie and loved them both. My brother Quinn posted here earlier about the gluten free chocolate pie we bought, and I was scared that I would find the fruit pies to also be too sweet. Glad I was wrong! Will definitely come back again. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 June 2019

Very salty and sweet pie. A bit too much. Pricing was a bit high for the gluten free pie.6/11/19 Edit:I have not had time to call but this prompt response was fantastic. My family ended up purchasing another pie without me and it was much better than the first. No need for a refund. Thank you! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 June 2019

Do yourself a favor and go there today! The pie is heavenly and so are the owner and employees. You'll feel like family by the time you leave there.

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 June 2019

Super friendly, great military discount, everything was tasty.

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 June 2019

Unplanned Purchase! I just so happened to be driving by and saw the sign, "Pie Heaven". Who could resist stopping? I purchased a whole Quiche Lorraine and a 6" Blueberry pie. I have no words. I am speechless. But...Let me see if I can do these items justice.. The Quiche was absolutely fantastic! The perfect crust had herbs in it! Who does that!? The ingredients were clearly the highest quality and the flavor was off the charts! Our family consumed the whole quiche immediately!! (no time for photos!!) Now onto the blueberry pie. Seems innocent enough right? To be honest; I am not really a fruit pie person. This gem was by far the best fruit pie I have ever had the privilege of tasting. The crust was flaky and tender and the berries were tiny little purple love berries. 6 thumbs up, 10 stars. Just as an added little bonus-- the proprietors were delightful! Helpful, funny, sincere and well..sweet! People- go here-- buy some pies, make your family happy. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 June 2019

The coconut pie is just borderline heavenly

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 May 2019

My sister discovered this charming bakery café when looking for a last minute gift for a dinner party. She bought a pie for the dinner only to discover that her host had also bought one from the same store because it was her favourite pie shop. Pies are available by the slice or whole (large or small) and they can be made gluten free. The selection changes daily and seasonally as the store uses the freshest ingredients and does everything by hand from scratch. The service is friendly and the store supports charities that feed children. You will have a hard time selecting. My family had a reunion in April and ordered several different slices and pies. My sister's favourites are the caramel apple pie and the chocolate bourbon pecan. My brother-in-law loved the margarita key lime pie and I liked the chili and corn bread pie, the chocolate cloud, and the coconut cream. The wild Maine blueberry pie and the chicken pot pie were also big hits.Don't miss this treasure filled place if you're in Jacksonville. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 May 2019

Magical, simply magical. Flavor was out of this world!!!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

15 May 2019

Pie heaven had the best chicken pot pie, key lime pie and chocolate pie I've ever had. The crust was buttery and flavorful. I feel like it wasn't as crisp, mainly because the pies were pre made in lager batches. It was still very very good! I took another pot pie for take out. The key lime pie was phenomenal. The filling was perfect and it was a beautiful balance between sweet, tart and creamy. I loved the texture of the graham cracker crust too. The service was great, there is a 15% military discount and a portion of the earnings go to feeding starving children around the world. Would come back probably in the next 3 days. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

2 May 2019

This place has my heart. Their pies and the quiches too are absolutely amazing. The ladies who work there are so genuine and dedicated to their craft and customers.

Reviewed on Yelp

29 April 2019

After looking up the best pie places in my area, I had a chance to stop at Pie Heaven. I had the key lime pie and it was delicious. I look forward to trying their other pies another time. The ladies working there are very friendly. You won’t be disappointed. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

21 April 2019

What a super cute place with friendly service and heavenly pies. The ladies who own this bakery are adorable and so very funny. We learned about Pie Heaven from their amusing self made videos on Facebook and finally took the drive out to Mayport to buy some pies. We wanted every single one on the pie status list, they all look so tempting. But we just two of us, we had to make choices. We settled on one full savory, chicken pot pie, one full sweet, salted caramel apple, and slices of chocolate and margarita key lime. Sadly they had just sold out of the salted caramel apple, but we were happy to take a regular apple pie. OH MY... they were all so amazing. We started with our slices because we could just not wait. The chocolate on a pastry crust was so rich and creamy and the key lime with a graham cracker crust had just the right amount of tang and actually tasted like a good margarita. So yummy. We heated up the chicken pot pie for dinner and it was beautiful. We wouldn't have minded a little more gravy but at the same time appreciated it being packed full of good chicken and vegetables with fresh herbs. The apple pie tasted like fresh picked apples cooked up perfectly and not too sweet. The pastry crust is so perfect, light and delicate but sturdy enough to stand up to the hearty filling and flavor. These homemade pies cost more than your regular grocery store pies, but they are absolutely worth the price and the drive out to Mayport to get them. We will be back for more of the fruit, fluffy top, and savory pies. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

3 April 2019

A little piece of country heaven where you know the pies are made from scratch. Their chicken pot pie almost rivals my own. Love the friendly welcoming environment. I think they are a little pricey for the size of their servings but I believe it's because a portion of the money goes for donation to kids in need. Also they have a business to run. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

29 March 2019

Best pie around! Key lime and margarita key lime are fantastic!

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 March 2019

The best pies ever. I had a chicken pot pie. Best dish I have eaten in a while. It was very quiet. The service was great.

Reviewed on Google Maps

14 March 2019

Happy pie day!!  No doubt about it, these pies are delicious.  Come out on 3/14 and get the best deals on their pies at $3. 14 a slice (limit 4).  If you come any other day of the year, ya, you'll probably pay more but the tender loving baking care that goes into each pie delivers some yummy bites.  Don't let the run down little building prevent you from placing a pie order.  There's space for about 9 seats inside... and on pie day, they set up an outside tent to hold another 8 seats.Eat dessert first. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

6 March 2019

Awesome pastry, all organic fillings. Loved the beef burgundy; Julia Child would approve. Staff very friendly.

Reviewed on Yelp

28 February 2019

Delicious pie, warm, friendly service. So many kinds of pie.

Reviewed on Google Maps

28 February 2019

Best chicken pot pie I have ever had! I can’t wait to try my slice of coconut custard! Wonderful

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 January 2019

You are what you eatEat LOVE I’m in Heaven Last sin of 2018

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 January 2019

Awesome!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 December 2018

Great Ladies,pies are top shelf,wish I lived next door!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 December 2018

Great pies but expensive. Definitely a great idea for Christmas eating. They are on the main road in Mayport. A little house. You can order in advance, pick up what’s currently made or just buy a piece and eat there. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 November 2018

Very nice ladies, yummy pie, excellent crust!

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 November 2018

This place is amazing! The lady that owns it donates it's proceeds to charity and the pies are the best you've ever had!

Reviewed on Google Maps

26 October 2018

A must visit cafe.  We came for dessert after seafood at Mayport.  Three of us enjoyed chocolate, cherry and lemon chess pie.  The fourth ordered salted, caramel apple pie. We stayed for pressed coffee.  The proprietors are a joy and make you feel like family. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

10 October 2018

This whole place is a treat. Adorable blue building, the most wonderful smells when you enter, warm and friendly staff not to mention a wonderful selection of old fashioned home made pies! The gentleman behind us in line said he was from Tennessee and made sure he came back again after trying their pies last time in town. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

29 September 2018

We love their homemade pies! The owners are great and they have many different pies. Sweet and savory. One of my favorites is the coconut cream.

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 September 2018

Love ALL the ladies! They're ALL amazing people and Ohhh the pies are ALL fabulous too!

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 September 2018

Picked up a fresh GF pie to enjoy w/ family. Great homemade pie, a bit high $$. Best GF pie someone has ever enjoyed.

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 September 2018

We took out two individual chicken pot pies and slices of blueberry pie, apple pie & chocolate pie. Everything was completely delicious! Linda was sweet and helpful and I loved that our take out cake with reheating directions. The chicken pot pie is something we will definitely come back for and I'm dreaming of that chocolate pie! Both were the best we've had. This is local gem and we wish we tried it sooner! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

29 August 2018

Yum Yum! Lemon marange, Chicken pot pie and quiche lorraine. Dinner, desert, and breakfast tomorrow. The wife is happy, no cooking, delicious food what more could you ask for. The name here is perfect, the crust is perfect, you need to visit this perfect little place. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 August 2018

Just ate her country chocolate pie for lunch

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 August 2018

Can you imagine a bunch of lovely grandmas busily making pies, filling their pie shop with toasted, buttered crusts and sweet fruit aromas? These ladies are spectacular bakers with eccentric personalities to go along. Their pies are fantastic experiences baked down into a crust. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 August 2018

I first heard of Pie Heaven on First Coast News I was there recently for the first time and the owners are delightfulThe pies and the quiche were deliciousIt's a little pricey but worth it I don't bake so I will leave the baking to them

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 August 2018

Bought a Triple Berry Pie hot 'n ready! Great with big scoop of Blue Bell!

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 August 2018

Honestly the best pie I've had in the world! I can not recommend my favorite because all are so good. Small and friendly atmosphere with a big and bold flavor! The margarita key lime pie is amazing. The strawberry rhubarb is smashing. The bourbon pecan is fantastic. I'm telling super good stuff here. They also serve pot pies. Haven't had a full one, but the bite I did have was on point. Go get some pie! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 August 2018

Fantastic pies! Great variety, all made by scratch. Fantastic staff as well.

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 August 2018

Can't what to go back very good place

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 August 2018

Fantastic pie & fantastic people!

Reviewed on Google Maps

29 August 2018

This place is offering lil slices of heaven. The icebox chocolate pie is my favorite. Honestly can’t go wrong with any choice.

Reviewed on Google Maps