Contact us for all your baking needs! Huge menu with plenty of variety!
I'm always 100%+ satisfied with my orders from these girls. They make astounding deserts and treats that not only taste great but look great, too. They can make just about anything and are always coming up with something more to make. More...
we requested brownies as my daughter is not huge on cake for hr bday and they were amazing everyone loved how special they looked, and for the price it is amazing!!
They are an awesome duo and their baking skills are out of this world!
I got some Keto cinnamon rolls to help with the sweet cravings. OMG, they are amazing! Highly recommend!
I ordered a variety of specialty cupcakes for my sons graduation party. They were all absolutely delicious and packed professionally. Because it was such a busy day they even delivered straight to my home. Great customer service and a great variety of yummy treats! Also the prices cannot be beat!! More...
their cakes are so moist and delicious and very friendly will definitely order more in the future
Jamie Rau Moskowitz
They made us soccer ball cookies for are last soccer game of the season and the kids thought they were the coolest thing ever ! ! And boy were they yummy thanks for the awesome cookies !!! More...
They are truly an Amazing company, customer service at it's best! Their products are delicious and fresh. My family loves everything I have ever gotten from them. They went the extra mile when I had ordered an item, and something beyond their control happened that they were unable to fill that order. They contacted me and offered to remake the item in the coming days at no charge or I could pick something different. I picked a different item we had wanted to try and Erica would not let me pay for it! You guys are amazing and thoughtful! PS. I purchased an additional item to add to my order as she also delivered the items to my door, and I didn't want her to come without paying her something. I have already placed my Holiday order! One extremely happy customer! More...
got a banana roll and it is absolutely delicious. very friendly ladies! professional. will definitely be ordering again!
Purchased gluten free pumpkin cookies and a banana roll....they were amazing....very friendly and understanding...come here for all your baked goods
Come to them for my.kids birthday cakes and definitely for pies. They are all soooooo amazing. Their strawberry cupcakes my kids absolutely LOVE ♥️
Amazing donuts and awesome customer service! Love that you have a delivery option!!
The snicker doodles by the way, that weren't picked up, were amazing. Not to mention the homemade donuts are delicious. I highly recommend trying them if you haven't.
Zuchinni bread was awesome!! Very good customer service too!!
Everything they have ever made for me has been delicious. Kind girls to work with and they always deliver what they say! I HIGHLY recommend them!
Great deals and service! Lots of variety...all delicious...and she delivers on some specials. Gluten free options is a real plus! Very satisfied customer! Higly recommended for all occasions! More...
delicious food very good service very responsive to emails and comments All Around they provide a wonderful service price is very reasonable I would do all my business with them
Had a cake made for my Sons Birthday and it was delicious!! Did a great job decorating it also!
They did an excellent job with my son’s graduation party cupcakes and cookies!!
The cookies I ordered from Erica and Beth were delicious! They stayed fresh and they were so cute! Highly recommend
Awesome gluten free peanut butter & strawberry cupcakes. Tasted great & beautifully done. Would order again and recommend! Great customer service!
Great communication and customer service. The baked goods are excellent.
There very easy to work with and do a wonderful job at decorating. We had a double birthday party for both my granddaughters and had two different cakes for each and they went way beyond what I could have imagined. They both lived there cakes and cupcakes. If you want excellent service go with these lady's. More...
The girls knocked it out of the park with the cookies they made for our open house at Endless Creations. Our customers were extremely happy. Will use them for many events to come. Thank you for all the yumminess! More...
Absolutely love our LOCAL businesses. Phenomenal food as well as their service.
Partners In Crime Bakery are amazing bakers. My work always enjoys when i bring their items in to sell or for taste testings. Hands down i recommend this bakery to anyone looking for fresh baked delicious treats. More...
My son and I a great time at one of partner in crime catering tasting. Every was good we could not just pick one thing. My son loves their cut sugar cookies. They listen to you and nothing is to far out for them to try. They make you feel family. More...
Delicious! You ladies make such wonderful things! Lov ya!
I have had the opportunity to sample and purchase several of PIC'S awesome treats/pies/deserts. Made with care and love by a couple of great ladies ❤❤❤
Wonderful customer service! Wonderful tasting treats! Very reasonable pricing!
I've ordered several things, all were fabulously fantastic
My birthday cake was absolutely amazing!!! Just like in the picture!! ❤️❤️❤️ Thank you Beth and Erica!!! ❤️❤️❤️
Great cakes, cupcakes and out this world peanut butter pie! Always friendly and ready when it is time to pick up!
We ordered a birthday a cake for our daughters 15th bday and it was based off a picture that was given to the ladies and they did an amazing job and it tasted delicious. I also have had the opportunity to try their Whoopie Pies (choc cake w/pnut butter filling), it was also delicious. They have great prices also More...
Everything I’ve tried is AMAZING!!!
They have the best dessert in Williams county and fair prices. Love their products. Everyone needs to try them. Rich and Patty.i give them 5 stars.
Gabrielle Diane Baez
I ordered a fruit pizza because I saw a picture of one that you made from a friend. And let me say it did not disappoint! Also my son loved it
Jess Waldron Sharps
The Gluten Free Blueberry Muffins were Amazing!!! So happy to find someone that is willing to make items both GF and not, so my whole family can enjoy!
These ladies made our daughters cake for her 15th birthday and it was delicious and looked just like the picture I sent them. Price was reasonable also! Will definitely order again. The 1st pic is the actual cake The 2-3 pic are the sample pics I sent for reference More...
The whoopie pies are really good! My daughter and I really enjoyed them!!
Gluten free birthday cake was amazing and so was the customer service!
I love their whipped frosting and the customer service is excellent.
Jamie Hooser #Fam
Cookies ,cakes, yum, yum, yum
Easy to work with...ordering, order changes, pickup\delivery...yummy everything! Fruit salad, lemon lush, toffee crack, brownies, puppychow, specially decorated cookies and cupcakes, banana and blueberry coffeecakes!
Pam Reeb Andres
I just got some keto cinnamon rolls and they are AMAZING and made to my order with less cinnamon. also received gluten free blueberry muffins and gluten free cinnamon rolls, AMAZING!! You guys are the BEST!!!
snicker apple salad was a big hit... thank you
Everyone loved the Lemon Lush and German chocolate cupcakes...❤ and as always Isaac loved the Thumbprint cookies ...You guys are Awesome
Had a cheese cake made for my fiancé’s birthday and it was sooo yummy !!
such amazing cakes! only place I will order from! the cake is moist and delicious. their fillings are soooooo yummy and not over bearing. not to mention the creativity behind each piece! More...
Tammy Trame Kinkade
Yummiest cupcakes and cookies ever! Love everything of theirs I’ve tried!
These two ladies did my wedding cakes and cupcakes. The 4 different types of filled cupcakes were the biggest hit of the party! ! I highly recommend using them for all your baking desires ������� More...
Really enjoyed my double chocolate chip cookies and my cheesecake cookies! They have a huge variety in their menu and the prices are great. Will definitely be a repeat customer! More...
My grand daughter was so happy and loved the tye she cupcakes she got to take to school for her birthday! She has 14 in her class and took 24 and didn't have one left over at the end of the day! The kids loved them as much as my grand daughter did! Will definitely be ordering again in the future! More...
Lemon LUsh- the Strawberry Pretzel - and many other items-
Everything is delicious and made with love❤
We’ve had their cupcakes and they are delicious! The icing is perfect! Just writing this review wants me to order some more! ❤️
Everything I've had is delicious! Soft frosted sugar cookies, buckeye cupcakes, Andes Mint brownies -yum. Their service is awesome and prices are reasonable. If you haven't tried them, you should! More...
I have used these ladies multiple times and every experience has been wonderful, from special request birthday cakes to picking up extra goodies they have from orders. All of it is simply amazing my husband loved the pumpkin pie I had them make and my dad said the pecan is like having it made southern style! Quick response time and amazing kindness!!!! 10 out of 10 recommend! If you need any suggestions my favorite so far is the strawberry cupcakes with cheesecake filling!!!! More...
I had the St Patty’s Cupcakes and they were soooo good! The white ones tasted like Twinkies ❤️❤️❤️
Super friendly and reasonable pricing! Flexible with pickups!! I HIGHLY recommend their goodies! Especially those sugar cookies, IM ADDICTED!!
Sierra Nicole Goad
such wonderful baked goods! and such quick response time :) and amazing with requests! ten out of ten recommend! I've ordered from them a couple of times and the goodies always have been a big hit at work and at home! plus I just love that you can tell the goodies are made with care and that they enjoy what they do! More...
I had the pleasure of tasting there strawberry cupcakes and chocolate covered strawberries...SIMPLY AMAZING
Friendly service! Great tasting treats at such a reasonable price. Unique options, flexible pickup times and wonderful local owners who focus on customer satisfaction.
Our sugar cookie cutouts were great! The taste was amazing and it was so fun being able to decorate with our kiddos!! Thanks Erica!!
Thanks for the fantastic food that you made for our CKT Thanksgiving dinner-delicious! We also love the samples!!
purchased a pumpkin roll from PIC. it was amazing! I am a working mom with 3 kids and a basketball coach husband, and PIC will be getting my business for all of my baking needs!
Bought some pies for my family for helping us move and loooooooord they were good. My brother in law had his gone in a day
AMAZING desserts! You will not be disappointed!
Their pumpkin cookies are amazing!
We ordered gluten free pumpkin cookies, they made sure all ingredients, utensils, and pans were free from contamination. Not to mention...the cookies were gone quick! Thank you! More...
Dee Harmon Cox
Erica made a terrific cherry pie for me !! Best of luck in your new business !
The peanut butter pie I got for my dad’s birthday today was amazing! Will definitely be a repeat customer.
Nick R Jones
I love the pricing, effort and attitude! Chocolate chip cookies are to die for!
Last minute birthday cookie ordered and it was GOOOOD!!! Thank you for coming through for us!
I would highly recomment PIC Catering, everything I have purchased has been wonderful, the peanut butter cupcakes are my favorite! ! I can't wait to try the pumpkin cookies. More...
If you want to order a dozen pumpkin cookies you better get two they are amazing!!! The cupcakes will not dissapoint either we have tried almost every kind and no one makes them better! I even got my daughters graduation cake from them it looked and tasted great. Give these ladies a try you will not be disappointed!! More...
The pumpkin cookies are so delicious! Very soft and fluffy. Great on their own or with frosting! Both girls are great at what they do and their passion shows. Would highly recommend.
The specialty cupcakes always look as good as they taste. The pumpkin cookies are my jam! And their pies are always delicious. Erica and Beth are so good at what they do and their passion shows in their work. They’re both as sweet as their treats. You won’t be disappointed. More...
Everything they have made is amazing!
They had some very delicious gluten free pumpkin cookies!! They had made sure that all their ingredients were gluten free, which was extremely thoughtful! Highly recommend!!
Kathy Loomis Kirkendall
I ordered cookies for a potluck at work and all the flavors were delicious!
pumpkin cookies! butterfinger lush! everything is soooooo delicious!
I highly recommend Partner in Crime Catering. If you're just ordering cookies for yourself or wanting all of your holiday baking done. You won't need to look any further than these quality & delicious creations for you and your loved ones! 5 stars for sure More...
I had a peanut butter pie and it was to die for. I could eat many many more. Highly recommended and prices are cheap!
I highly recommended the pumpkin cookies. They (and the super-yummy cream cheese frosting) were absolutely delicious. My only complaint is that they disappeared all too quickly ; -) PIC Catering was also able to accommodate special dietary needs with their gluten-free offerings. Needless to say, I have already placed my next order of pumpkin cookies for my next visit to Ohio. More...
Fantastic pumpkin cookies
The pumpkin pie was to die for ... mom and dad had the apple and peanut butter pie and said they won’t get their pies anywhere else they are so amazing. . the sugar cookies we so good and I am pretty sure I ate the whipped cream with just a spoon lol More...