John & Mary's
Arcade, New York
(167)
Arcade, New York
(167)
167 customer reviews
russell rast
Hidden gem in arcade great food and wonderfully courteous people
Reviewed on Google Maps
Carl Larson
Great food friendly service
Reviewed on Google Maps
trish diebs
Stopped just to grab a ham sub to share for lunch with my sister. I haven't had a sub that good in years. It took me back to the good old days. We had to laugh though because my sister went in to order and she asked for the roll to be toasted. The girl at the counter said the toaster was on the fritz. Having years of restaurant experience my sister asked, can you not toast it in the pizza oven? The girl said she could but not if they were busy. So next time... Well I certainly hope the toaster is fixed by the next time we go. We got quite a chuckle from that. Let's everyone please start thinking outside their small circle of options. Again the sub was really really good. I'm new fan and I will stop again. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Task
Ordered a ham sub. Lady explained couldnt toast it because toaster wasnt working.I asked her to put on tray and toast in pizza oven. ...it was a very good sub. Nice and fresh. Gotta learn the old ways of toasting subs. Silly to rely on a roll toaster!! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
William Bird
Food great
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jamey Craft
I had a burger and curly fries and hubby has a half royal sub. All was good
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mike Andera
Nice place for a quick meal
Reviewed on Google Maps
Evans Bank
Eh
Reviewed on Google Maps
Susan Lembke
Great Greek chicken salads!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Matthew Ressler
Good pizza
Reviewed on Google Maps
Carlton Greene
Food & service was good as well as the speed in making as we were on a time schedule.
Reviewed on Google Maps
David webb
Awesome Family Restaurant in a desert of good restaurants in Arcade., Theo's is also awesome. No other good places to eat in this one horse town.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Stealthydemon 23
BEST CHICKEN FAJITAS
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jennifer Biddle
Always loved John & Mary's! Great food, the staff is always nice, and I love the fire pit!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Marc Petrillo
Great service and comfortable atmosphere! Very clean!
Reviewed on Google Maps
aayesha Singh
Great
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kellie Marie
We order from here quite a bit and it's usually pretty good. We always order the Sue Ann salad but tonight I wish I could give our order 6 stars! . The Sue Ann salad was beautiful! The romaine was so crisp, fesh and GREEN! The toppings weren't sparse, absolutely perfect..loved the shredded white cheese! Cheeseburger sub...AMAZING!!!! And we ordered super hot fingers and they absolutely were! So impressed! Please keep producing great food like tonight!!! Thank you! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Chris
Awesome Philly. Best I had in Western New York. Service was great, prices are very reasonable. I would recommend them. My family likes the pizza as well.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mary Wilkie
Food is always great tasting! Workers are always pleasant and very professional! I enjoy dining in and seeing other customers smiling and seeing the employees working together and keeping this restaurant very clean!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Genoviva Shelnut
Excellent service!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Christopher Wilson
Awesome food
Reviewed on Google Maps
P. Bryan
Great food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tim Weldon
Yummy
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kyle Norsen
Great food. Pricey
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mardelle Gohlke
Really good food. Nice dinning area
Reviewed on Google Maps
Joe Wolfer
They're good at listening to the customer, off menu items seem like a easy thing to ask for. Pizza is kinda saucey depending on the day
Reviewed on Google Maps
stan gunsolus
Great variety with super friendly staff and great salads.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Elaine Morsman
Love this location. The selection is extensive and the food is always good!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tammy Barrett
Awesome food very friendly.
Reviewed on Google Maps
R Yubert
Because it was fast survice there waiter's are nice
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dalton Busse
Always a joy to be here and food is great
Reviewed on Google Maps
JacLynn Klahn
Always consistent! Foods great!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Ayisha Wells
Consistently good food. Highly recommend the open souvlaki.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Necular
Never have had a hard time with this place
Reviewed on Google Maps
Elsie Bigelow
Food delicious waitress good
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jennifer Nagel
Pretty good food. Fried mushrooms were delicious!! The pizza was good, not great, but still enjoyable. Service was excellent!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Daniel Kruszynski
Always good subs
Reviewed on Google Maps
nicholas tiede
My other half and I love stopping in here when passing thru to camping. It has turned into a tradition, often both on the way to camp and home. Impeccably clean, staff is always above and beyond friendly and welcoming. The food is so good, he and I both love the Pinter sub. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Corey VanErp
Best Greek food I've had in a while, super nice staff, fast service.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Mad Max
My family and I were visiting letchworth state park. On our way back to the turnpike we came across this place. The food was good and the girls were nice. Very busy place.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Samantha Wiggins
Pizza is always very good and we get our food delivered a lot and is here within a good time being on a wknd day when it’s busier and living in a rural area. We enjoy Ordering from John and Mary’s and the service we receive. Best pizza in the area! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Geoff Kessler
Great lunch! Made my dinner plans for later. So good!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nina Metzger
Good food. Fast friendly service!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Colleen Richardson
Great food, great staff and very clean.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Steven Burch
Always great food
Reviewed on Google Maps
Linda Hawco
Always love going even if it takes me almost an hour to get there. Worth the drive
Reviewed on Google Maps
william janik
Great food, great service. Nice view.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Nicholas Tillinghast
The best every time. Never dissapoints
Reviewed on Google Maps
Dawn Conti
They have a wide variety of foods to choose from. From Pizza to Greek and even frozen yogurt! Very nice staff and large open comfy dining area. Even a fire pit outside.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Jeshu & Kurtis P
Delicious battered mushrooms! Fast service!
Reviewed on Google Maps
