Loading...

Please wait ...

Isabella's Creations logo
I

Isabella's Creations

Dyker Heights, New York

(82)
Isabella's Creations logo
I

Isabella's Creations

Dyker Heights, New York

(82)

Reviews (82)

Leave a review
G

Gloria Patricia Novoa

9 November 2019

Beautiful & Delicious And close to me

A

Aliz G.

11 October 2019

They are amazing, I can highly recommend them!!!Responding quickly, and very helpful. I had them make my mom's 50th birthday cake and some cake pops! Both were great success.The cake was beautiful and delicious.I'm about to order another one for next month More...

M

Megan A. Kleinman

7 October 2019

Another amazing cake! Everyone at my daughters birthday was amazed at how good it was! They are my go to birthday cake shop! Highly recommend to everyone!

J

Jiles Playz

22 September 2019

Absolutely loved the cake! it looked beautiful and tasted delicious. also, very professional which I admire and respect. thank you!

A

awilda bonilla

30 June 2019

Isabella's creations is the best. the cakes are not only beautifully made but moist and delicious I will be ordering All my cakes with Issabell's creations, thanks so much !

J

Julia Collazo

28 April 2019

My Babyshower cake was not only Beautiful, It was so delicious . our Family & Friends loved it. thanks again

J

Jeannette Stangarone

29 March 2019

Everything I purchased was delivered beyond my expectations. Not only did the display look wonderful everything was delicious. Will definitely be using her again for all my upcoming events. Thank you Maria. More...

M

Maria Tulone

17 March 2019

Her cakes are delicious and cupcakes all her things

D

Debra Welch

27 February 2019

Beautiful looking! Great tasting! Excellent service! Would recommend everyone looking for a cake! Just look at that cake ❤️

D

Dana Khater

27 January 2019

I ordered my sons 1st bday cake and we were so amazed. Did such a beautiful amazing job. Everyone at the party kept saying how beautiful the cake looked and how delicious it tasted. Thank you so much. Can’t wait to order more cakes from you. More...

M

MEDJINE DAZULME

27 January 2019

I love Isabella creations cakes, not only beautiful but so tasty and delicious.That’s where I get my birthday cake every year.

S

Shira Gelman

16 December 2018

Beautiful work! The cakes are beautiful and absolutely delicious.

A

Almir Hot

23 November 2018

We have used Isabella’s Creations for 3 orders of specialty cakes thus far and they just get better and better. The cakes are beautiful and done exactly the way you envision. Where some cakes look lovely and taste awful Isabella’s are just the opposite, delicious!!! Thank you for your excellent service! More...

D

Diana Gomez

10 November 2018

beautiful cakes and great bread

E

Elaine Duke

29 October 2018

They did my engagement party cake for me with my theme colors of emerald and gold. I couldn't believe how beautiful the cake turned out, and how well they did the design. Creative and delicious! They were very professional, honest and were full of great ideas. Loved them! Would definitely use them again! More...

W

Wioletta Falkowska

29 September 2018

Absolutely gorgeous cake, just like the photos I provided during consultation, amazingly yummy, just a show stopper! Thank you so much!

E

Estelle Ishay

25 September 2018

Best designs expert Labor beautiful cakes, delicious!!!!

W

Wiola F.

16 September 2018

Absolutely gorgeous cake, just like the photos I provided during consultation, amazingly yummy, just a show stopper! Thank you so much!

S

Sophia Doll Pryce

16 September 2018

beautiful work & delicious !

S

Simone P.

25 August 2018

The best cakes anywhere in NYC. Not only are the cakes beautiful but delicious. I've ordered a cake for every family event from Isabella's since 2012. I am never disappointed.

M

Mellissa A.

19 July 2018

The XXX Cake for my brother was on point in every way !!! He was so excited he video taped it before anyone can eat a piece ! This establishment was helpful in ideas design and flavors !!! I can't wait till we have our next occasion to order which will be soon !! Very very helpful staff and prompt delivery. There isn't enough I can say about these cakes except SUPERIOR!!! Thank you for making a memorable 30 th Birthday for my brother !!! More...

A

Adriana O.

15 July 2018

I ordered a last minute bachelor cake for my fathers bachelor party. It was a boob cake with exposed nipples, I can't post a picture because my brother and the men at the party failed to take normal pictures of the cake. (If I get a normal pic, I will update the post). Updated: I received a normal picture (the colors look blotchy due to shadows. So please take that into consideration)The cake was vanilla, with coconut buttercream and it was a fondant cake. The colors were all correct, the cake looked very similar to the pictures presented for me to choose from, and I am pleased overall. My father, brother and his friends stated that the cake was very good. The prices are beyond fair, the service is good, communication is good and I would use their services again!! I would recommend them!!! Thank you so much !! More...

L

Lashon Stockton

4 July 2018

MY BIRTHDAY CAKE WAS AN ATTRACTION THAT CAUGHT EVERYONE'S EYES, IT WAS MOIST, TASTY, AND .......ALL GONE (SAD)!!

L

Laura Mencini

1 July 2018

The cake and mini cupcakes were beautiful and the cake was so moist and tasty. The frosting was divine. Thank you for making Isabellas day special! Everyone loved it!

E

Erica Diaz

27 May 2018

I ordered a trolls birthday cake for my daughter second birthday and I was beyond happy with it not to mention the price very reasonable and my daughter loved it I will be getting one for my son and my gender reveal

P

Phil Scandariato

27 May 2018

Isabellas Creations makes the best cakes! They're always what I ask for or pictured. Not only does it look amazing every time but it tastes delicious! I always get asked where I get my cakes from. Only the best!! More...

D

Daniella Urman

1 April 2018

I ordered some donuts so add to my daughter's unicorn theme dessert table and they were a great addition. The looked beautiful and tasted amazing!!! Everyone raved about the donuts.

M

Michelle Illiano

18 February 2018

Created an amazing ski mountain cake for my husbands 50th Birthday. The pictures do it no justice, it was stunning and tasted great too! Maria is so easy to work with and was very accommodating from creation to delivery. I highly recommend. More...

B

Bianca M.

29 January 2018

I got my engagement party cake from here and not only was it absolutely beautiful but real deal yummiest slice of cannoli cake I have ever had!  She is really good at what she does and well worth every penny! I've seen beautiful cakes at all types of events but taste is okay. That wasn't the case with Isabella creations. If you want not only beautiful but delicious cake, this is your cake lady! More...

S

Simone Pitts

13 January 2018

I have used Isabella’s for my baby shower, my mother’s 60th, my aunts 60th, and my aunts 50th. They are beyond professional. The cakes are always delicious. They communicate very well and are always on time. Besides that the cakes have been BEAUTIFUL every time. No place better. More...

T

Tatyana Ruzhinskaya

7 January 2018

Thank you for making such a beatiful birthday cake for our daughter! She had been asking for a Minnie Mouse cake for months, and it couldn't be more perfect!

M

Mayline Esposito

1 October 2017

Wonderful place for custom orders they did a beautiful job!

T

Tareyah Kennerly

28 September 2017

Best baker ever, I've been a customer over five years!!!

D

Daniela DiLeo Romano

21 June 2017

Don't think there was ever a cake theme you couldn't do. Everything is done down to the smallest detail. We have never been disappointed with any of the cakes, cookies, or cupcakes we have gotten.

M

Michelle L.

10 June 2017

I ordered a cake from Isabellas Creations. Came in for a cake taste testing. Picked out the flavors I liked. When the cake came it was beyond my expectations. I usually never look forward to cake at parties. It's usually never good, too much chocolate, or just for show. I had yellow regular sponge cake with a fruity/raspberry fill it was so amazing and so delicious that i dreamt about it and ate it for breakfast the next morning. All my guests were raving about the cake. I was so happy that it wasn't one of those cakes that just looks nice and gets tossed in the garbage cause it tastes bad. The cake itself was beautiful it exceeded my expectations!! Thank you guys More...

A

Agatha Teresa

27 May 2017

Today we had our sons confirmation party and everyone loved the cake you made - not only was it beautiful on the outside but delicious !! Can't thank you enough !

V

Victoria Weaver

27 May 2017

Isabella's Creations never disappoints! My family has used them for several cakes in the past and my husband and I just got our son's Christening cake from them. It was phenomenal!!! People couldn't stop talking about it! Their cakes taste great, look great, and they are so professional and easy to work with! More...

C

Chief ZEF monkey

27 May 2017

How can I start on how much I LOVE Isabella's Creations!! Her cakes are out of this world!!! I highly recommend ordering a cake, cupcakes, and any other sweets she makes for any occasion. She takes great pride in her work and when you see and take that first bit you know she's done that. PLEASE Take it from me anything you order with be the talk of your event! You can't go wrong. 5 STARS IS JUST NOT ENOUGH!!!! More...

M

Maria Justo Silva

1 May 2017

How can I start on how much I LOVE Isabella's Creations!! Her cakes are out of this world!!! I highly recommend ordering a cake, cupcakes, and any other sweets she makes for any occasion. She takes great pride in her work and when you see and take that first bit you know she's done that. PLEASE Take it from me anything you order with be the talk of your event! You can't go wrong. 5 STARS IS JUST NOT ENOUGH!!!! More...

D

Danielle Russo

26 April 2017

The best!!!! Isabella's creations has been our go to for custom cake designs for years... always amazing creations!

S

Samantha Reda

25 April 2017

I been using Isabella Creations for years from when she was working out of her home and I loved every single cake and cupcake she is made for my parties. I recommended her to all my friends and gave her some loyal customers. She is excellent More...

A

Alex Z.

17 April 2017

I ordered 2 custom birthday cakes & I couldn't be happier with the process & the outcome. I was able to describe the specifics of my custom orders via email, making it convenient to do so while I was at work. Another convenience was having my orders delivered to me, arriving within moments of the specific time I requested. The cakes themselves were fresh & delicious, while the celebrity custom birthday cake was a stunning recreation of a photo image. Of course, custom orders are going to cost extra, but it's well worth it since we're talking about unique cakes. More...

L

Lauren Alfonzo

25 February 2017

My sons birthday cake looked great and tasted amazing another great cake!

N

Natasha C.

19 February 2017

All 40 people at the party were blown away by the beauty and attention to detail of this cake. Then, the were licking their fingers because this cake was yammy. And everyone was asking where I got it from. My surprise was successful.  Im already planning to order another themed care from them! More...

J

Janet Watson

4 December 2016

A Special Thanks to the Bake Queens at Isabella's Creations. The tastes and great hospitality were A List!!!. My #50AndFabulousCelebration was EVERYTHING!!! This cake almost stole the spotlight from me. A true centerpiece of the celebration. Fabulous job for a #50AndFabulousCelebration. Will definately be back for more. Can anybody say, "Sweet 16 x 2?" More...

D

Diana Guerra Pavon

25 November 2016

Exactly what we asked for ! Very delicious chocolate cake with strawberry !

E

Enrico T.

20 September 2016

I have a large family which means a lot  of parties! Maria at Isabella creations makes every party special with her delicious cakes and amazing cupcakes.We have ordered many desserts from her and each item is better than the last! Her professionalism and dedication to perfection is second to none! Everything is delivered fresh and on time! I would not recommend anyone but Isabella creations if you want the best cake for your friends to rave about! Keep up the great work! More...

S

S. P.

4 August 2016

I've been a loyal customer of Isabella's Creations since 2013 and will continue to be for a lifetime! They make the yummiest, most beautiful cakes! The bakery itself is very quaint and clean and the staff is always professional and kind. They are very thorough in making sure that the customer gets exactly what they want in a cake design, and they always follow up in a timely manner. I find the pricing to be reasonable and affordable. The owner Maria is ABSOLUTELY WONDERFUL! I walked into the bakery this evening to pick up my cake order and right away she greeted me with a smile and asked how my kids were. It's always nice when a customer is treated like more than just another sale. I would definitely HIGHLY recommend Isabella's Creations to anyone looking to purchase a cake that is tasty, pleasing to the eye, and easy on the pockets. More...

A

Anna Pajaro

3 July 2016

My brother loved his cake and it was delicious! Isabella's Creations is a fantastic place with very kind people, for a first timer I'm definitely coming back soon :)

F

Felicia Livingston

6 June 2016

I am so happy with my daughter's cake for her sweet 16!! Very friendly and attentive!! I highly recommend!! I will be back for more!

J

Jacqueline Rowe

18 February 2016

My birthday cake was awesome! From Chrissy Monroe.. Love it❣

D

Danielle

6 January 2016

They took my ideas and made them a reality. The cake was beautiful and tastes amazing. All my guests talked about was how delicious the cake tasted and looked. I even went back to them in the spring to have my sister in laws baby shower cake done by them that's how happy I was with them. More...

J

Jazmin T.

4 January 2016

I contacted isabellas creations for a spiderman cake for my son's 5th bday. Isabellas creations corresponded with me via email and responded to my questions in a timely fashion. The cake was delicious and exactly how we asked. The price was great too. Will be using her again for my next party! More...

M

Maria

24 June 2015

loved loved loved the sports cake you make for my sons 1st birthday it not only looked amazing but tasted amazing. Everyone loved the cake :) thank you so much!

K

Kristin S.

21 May 2015

I recently ordered my husband's law school graduation cake from Isabella's Creations and it was PERFECT. They followed my wishes to a T and created a cake that was absolutely beautiful and delicious as well! Everyone was so impressed with it, especially my graduate. More...

M

Megan Ashley

12 April 2015

They made a cake for my boyfriends 30th a gravity beer cake.. It was AMAZING!!! She is super talented !! Not only was it the coolest cake ever !! It was delicious and a hit at the party!! Needless to say he was very happy!! More...

T

Taynay Tay Nay

9 February 2015

Love love love this place. They get my order exactly how I want it. Every time.

A

Anne Marie Tedesco Sorice

17 January 2015

The cake they made for my daughter's graduation was amazing!!!! It was beautiful, exactly what I wanted and tasted delicious!!! Everyone raved about it! Thank you Isabella and staff. More...

K

Kerrin Murtagh

25 October 2014

Thank you so much for my daughters sweet 16 cake (10-24-14) for her theme under the stars it was absolutely beautiful and was delicious also!!!! Thanks again!!!

M

Maria Katsaros Manolakakis

17 September 2014

We loved the basketball cake you created for us for our sons 2nd birthday everyone raved about how good it looked and tasted the cupcakes were a hot item as well. Thank you for all you did to make my sons birthday extra special More...

Y

Yuridia P.

7 September 2014

This place is amazing! This incredible establishment beautifully replicated the design of the cake I wanted for my godson's baptism brunch. The cake was beautiful and delicious. Thank you Isabella's creation for making such a joyous occasion sweeter. More...

A

Abdus A.

21 August 2014

Found these guys on Yelp and I decided to give them a try. I needed a specialty cake a friend was going away for med school. I saw their sample online that they made a cake that looks like a lab-coat, so I went with that. I've never paid so much for a cake in my life, but then again I've never had a cake that looked that gorgeous.I was very pleased visually, the cake looked awesome. I was hoping for equal joy when having the first bite. The taste was disappointing. In fact it didn't taste good at all. This place can sure as hell bake a gorgeous cake, but wheres the flavor? Beats me. More...

S

Sarah DeStefano Iacono

16 August 2014

Thank you for making such a beautiful and delicious Luau cake for my daughters Sweet 16 8/8/14! The cake was so beautiful it looked fake like it was part of the decorations! Thank you again the flowers looked just like a lei the diamonds added bling n the colors matched her theme perfect n it was delish!! More...

L

Lisa Caiafa Masiello

21 July 2014

I ordered a cake for my boyfriends 30th birthday. We threw him a "pig roast." Isabella's creations did a fantastic job! I really could not have been happier! Her prices are awesome... Actually very cheap compared to other places. More...

M

Maria Justo Silva

8 June 2014

Isabella's Creations is with a doubt the best cake, cupcake business in the Tri-State area! Without a doubt you will satisfied with their baked goods. The ladies are all helpful, professional and friendly. Whatever occasion your having their cake or cupcakes will set your party apart from any other. Jaws drop when you see her cakes. More...

S

Sharon Howe

8 June 2014

I bought my daughter's sweet 16 cake here last year. It was amazing.

C

Cherisse C.

19 May 2014

After scouring the internet for hours and reading countless bakery reviews-- Whala! I came across Isabellas Creations! I had a specific theme in mind: Call of Duty Black Ops. I wanted something different and creative, and none of the places I reached out to offered me that. After emailing Isabellas Creations they got back to me promptly and with 2 photos of cakes they've done in the past. They looked spectacular, but I was weary -- would they look this good, better yet taste good? It was a gamble, but I decided to go with them.We picked up the cake and were blown away. 2 tiers with yellow cake and cookies and cream filling. DELICIOUS! Best cake I've ever eaten. It was a huge hit at the birthday patty -- kids couldn't stop raving and parents were blown away with the design. I have another birthday party approaching and will be using them again. What blew me away the most was the price. Totally affordable with amazing quality. You can truly see the love they put into their work. Highly recommend -- one happy customer:) More...

D

Dan M.

7 April 2014

I ordered a cake with a short turn around time and Maria was awesome. She made it happen, delivered it on time (in a very short delivery window), it was exactly what i wanted and it was delicious! 5 Stars across the board. I will be ordering again soon. More...

S

Sarah W.

2 April 2014

Decor gets 2.5 stars.  I was a bit disappointed at the fondant having a noticable hill on one side and a valley on the other, and I would have liked them not to add sugar flowers without consulting me (design was supposed to be lace-and-pearl), but the fondant was smooth and I appreciated the slight pearl-y shimmer they gave it.Taste gets 4.5 stars...it wasn't gourmet but everyone was asking me for the bakery's name it was so good.  I'm still thinking about that taste days later actually...And the AMAZING value of a special occasion cake for 4times less  $$$ than the other bakeries quoted me?  SOLID 4 stars; will definitely use again!...but for birthdays, not ultra-important one-time occasions like wedding/bridal shower. More...

D

Danielle Bocchino

27 March 2014

Awesome frozen cake and design once again by Isabella's creations!! My guests were all impressed and asking for your number. Thank you again

A

Amici Miei

11 March 2014

Ever since I met Maria I haven't ordered from anyone else. Her cakes are beautifully detailed to perfection and the taste is amazing. Thank you=)

J

James Charles Wilson

25 November 2013

To celebrate by big 3-0 they did amazing birthday cake that was so good thank you!

D

Danielle

23 October 2013

Maria and her staff not only make the most beautiful cakes, they are delicious too! I have now used Isabella's Creations for many events and will continue to do so! Just fabulous!

J

Jessica Klett Douyon

8 September 2013

Thank you so much for the most amazing cake! Not only was it the most delicious cake ever... But you created exactly what I asked for!! Thank you and I recommended you to every guest at the party!!! Lol More...

K

Katherine Jeff Rucker

7 September 2013

They Made my Baby Shower Cake and it was not only FABULOUS but YUMMIE and the Best thing about it is that I was able to send alllll my information via email and never had to leave my home.

K

Katie M.

5 June 2013

I ordered my son's first birthday cake from Isabellas, and it was GREAT!  I was impressed with all aspects of my experience.... ordering was easy (I said I wanted them to do an American flag guitar and sent them a pic of his guitar). They made an amazingly awesome design!!!!  paying was easy.  They delivered to downtown Manhattan on time.  And most of all, the cake was a big hit, and it tasted really good too!  I've already recommended them to friends, and would definitely use them again! More...

J

Jennifer

26 March 2013

Isabella creations created a tiffany themed bridal shower cake for me. It was gorgeous and people are still talking about it to this day. Maria (the owner) is amazing and can create anything your heart desires. She is the nicest person to work with. I wish I could include a picture of my cake because it would take your breath away. I recommend Isabella Creations to everyone.... you will not be disappointed!!! They are also making my rehearsal dinner cake... I am so excited to see it! Not only are the cakes beautiful, but DELICIOUS TOO! More...

B

Bobby H.

17 February 2013

I was so impressed with Isabella's Creations. I ordered two dozen cupcakes with a custom design for a bridal shower and they turned out great. They helped me choose the perfect design, and were super clear and communicative about coordinating payment and delivery. The cupcakes showed up on time and looked (AND TASTED) even better than I expected. They were a huge hit! I would heartily recommend using them again! More...

M

Michelle

20 November 2012

The cake not only looked amazing but tasted great too!
Thank you!

N

Nancy L.

16 August 2012

Customer service was exceptional and the cake was delicious! Also very affordable prices.  I highly recommend Isabellas Creations for any events

A

Andrea W.

14 May 2012

Great cupcakes! Isabella's Creations made delicious fun decorated cupcakes and delivered them in a short turn around! Their customer service was excellent AND so was the product.

L

Lauren S.

9 November 2011

What is best about Isabellas Creations is the cakes are actually delicious!!! Sometimes when you order these fancy cakes, all they do is look fancy and don't taste good!! Isabellas Creations' cakes are not only beautiful, they taste delicious!!!!!Besides the cakes being amazing, one of the other best parts of Isabellas Creations is dealing with the staff.  They are family-owned, friendly, helpful, and reasonably priced!! The cake creator was one of the nicest people I ever met!  It was a pleasure dealing with her!I highly recommend Isabellas Creations for your cake needs!! you won't be disappointed!! More...

Photos (10)

See all