Cretia Cakes Bake Shop
Northwest Manor, Indiana
(28)
Northwest Manor, Indiana
(28)
28 customer reviews
Just Kesha
Ordered the Caramel Obsession Cake for Christmas Day....AMAZING!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Debra Woods
I ordered sweet potato pies, chess pies and 2 pound cakes for my Pre Thanksgiving dinner. They were all VERY GOOD and a big hit for everyone. The customer service is very good as well. Thank you Cretia Cakes I highly recommend this Bake Shop! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
T. Nicole L
The Best Bakery Since Roselyn’s!! From Carmel Cakes, Chocolate Chip Cookies To Live For, Moist Cupcakes, With Yummy Icing To Wedding Cakes And More! ! They Greet You With A Smile, Very Professional, Prompt And Friendly !! Give Them A Try!! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Robbie Brooks
Bought the Mexican wedding cake cookies, I strongly recommend them. I will be back to try those caramel cakes.
Reviewed on Google Maps
carol adams
We arrived just as the owner was closing but she kindly informed us she didn’t have any cakes available. After a few minutes she offered to make us a cake to our specific requests for our dad’s 99th birthday! It was delicious. Wonderful experience More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Cheryl Ray-Williams
I love Creitia's caramel obsession cake. It so just amazing!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Isla Terrell
The food was tasty. Looking forward to returning with my friends. The bill was decent. I see why this place has a lot of positive reviews.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Aryelle Player
LaCretia did an incredible job on my cake. Not only did it look EXACTLY as I wanted but it also tasted amazing. I will definitely be going to LaCretia again for any future cake needs!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Daniel Weaver
I purchased a 2 tier cake for my wife’s birthday after a recommendation from a friend. They walked me through all the options and we landed on a bottom layer lemon and top layer strawberry with buttercream frosting. The cake was beautiful and absolutely delicious. The cake was the perfect density, moist, and couldn’t have been better. In addition the price was very fair. Don’t hesitate to call Cretia Cakes for any of your baking needs. It’s our new go to! More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Kathryn Lea
We ran into this place by accident, seeing a bunch of ppl standing in queue. We ordered chocolate and berry souer bread and pizza. Very unique flavor.
Reviewed on Google Maps
Crandal shumpert
Real down to earth people that make you feel very welcomed as soon you as walk through the door. They have been making our kids cakes for the last 2 years. Love the chocolate chip cookies and carmel cakes. Thanks for everything y'all do. More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
Cleovs Cloe Sears
The best, softest cake I have ever tasted that was made by a bakery!! They designed the cake onto a boom box for my Soon to be Great-Nephew’s baby shower and it looked so real! ! Would recommend them to everyone for all occasions! Deserves a 10 star!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Angela Collins Cooper
LOVE! 5+ Stars for Awesome Desserts, Business Professionalism, Creativity, Great People!!
Reviewed on Facebook
Nancy Bringman Daniels
Thanks Cretia Cakes!! The German Chocolate was AMAZing!!! Highly recommend!
Reviewed on Facebook
Jennifer Gann Burns
Our wedding cake was perfect! Thanks so much! Plus, I'll keep coming back for the Caramel cake!
Reviewed on Facebook
LaToyia Webster Austin
I was so happy with the cake they made for my husband's 40th birthday! The design was exactly how I imagined and the cake was absolutely DELICIOUS!
Reviewed on Facebook
Ayisha Abdur-Rahman
Tried a couple of small cakes from the bakery today! I was very impressed with the quality and taste. A new favorite!
Reviewed on Facebook
Kimberly Qualls
Amazing Carmel cake!!! If you want to eat some delicious baked goods this is the place for you! Please stop by and support this family business, you won't be disappointed.
Reviewed on Facebook
Tyonna Smith
I've been celebrating my daughter's birthdays with Cretias cakes since she was 4. She'll be 11 next week and this year will be no different. She is always the centerpiece of the party table and it's taste is às appealing as it looks!!! We love her work!!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Candice Harthorne
Hands down best sweet potato pies and vanilla cake.
Reviewed on Facebook
Teri Ann-Snow Cox
I wanted one cupcake, to cure my sweet tooth. I walked in and yes, I could buy one, more if needed. I loved the atmosphere and the owner, shared her story how she got started.
I felt like we had known each other years.
#Great!
More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Shannon Hege
I follow Cretia Cakes on Instagram. When my daughter's Sweet 16 came I knew I wanted to give them a try. I cannot describe how absolutely delicious the cake was. The frosting was fresh and the cake moist...we dined at a local restaurant and several people wanted to know where we purchased the cake because it was just beautiful! My daughter was very happy and needless to say we will be using Cretia Cakes from here on out! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Anthony Robinson Jr.
Did a excellent job on my wife’s 55th Birthday cake!! It was a slot machine theme...just showed them a picture and they made! !! NOT only looked GREAT but TASTED FANTASTIC!!! More...
Reviewed on Facebook
Victoria Steen Williams
Just popped in today on a whim and had to try a couple treats... These mexican wedding cookies are melt in your mouth amazing!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Tina Guyse
Friendly family staff..But that Caramel Cake tho!!! BEST CAKE EVER!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Rebecca Schwartz
Their cakes are always good very moist and beautiful I have had the pleasure of ordering with them twice in the last three months! Very Satisfied!!
Reviewed on Google Maps
A A
Shop is small and unassuming but he came was moist, delicious and I was very impressed. I definitely plan on going back!
Reviewed on Google Maps
Shanae Tellis
I just recently tried the cupcakes & bought a small caramel cake at the ladies event at Sky Zone. I was very satisfied & yet disappointed that I've never had any! Maybe because I'm from Anderson & no one has tried them yet. I'm not sure. Either way, I'm going to be a satisfied customer from here on out More...
Reviewed on Google Maps
