Cheesy Eddie's Bakery

Best Cheese Cake and Carrot Cake in Rochester

Reviewed on Google Maps

Hands down the BEST cheesecake I've ever had!!! Blows Cheesecake Factory out of the water! So delicious! Will definitely be coming back again and again!!!

Reviewed on Facebook

Cheesy Eddie's is literally one of my 3 favorite bakeries in Rochester, and they make the best peanut butter blossoms and Russian Tea Cakes!!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Amazing, what a local gem!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best desserts

Reviewed on Google Maps

I called to have 12 cupcakes delivered to my daughter who is studying at Eastman. It was her 18th bday and her first away from home. They staff was so helpful texting her to make sure they arrived and getting them to her and I heard that they were 5 star yummy.. thank you so much when I come to town I am headed to your store b More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Best carrot cake

Reviewed on Google Maps

Stop going to other cheese cake places. Go here! Ask yourself...”do I like cheesecake?” Yes? Then drive! Don’t think about it, do it! Get a little single servicing slice. Try it.....the rest is your mouth doing the work. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best cheesecake ever!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best carrot cake on this planet!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Delicious! You get what you pay for, definitely worth it!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best cheese cake in Rochester

Reviewed on Google Maps

Cheesey Eddie's is wonderful. Everyone is so nice there. Colleen is lovely. Every year they give us a gift card for our hospice Isaiah house for our fundraiser. God bless you all I just picked up some lusious goodies. Yum! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

The best cheesecake and carrot cake I’ve ever had in my life must go

Reviewed on Google Maps

Friendly staff, yummy treats, great place! Their carrot cake is excellent!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Cheesy Eddie's not only has amazing cheesecake and other scrumptious desserts, but they can cater their desserts with a quick turn around time! I had to plan a reception in 48 hours for about 40 people and when I called cheesy eddies they said they would be able to help with all of the desserts! We were able to get a couple of their sampler cheese cakes and feed all the guests! It was absolutely amazing and they helped make the day a lot more stress free! Make sure you try their Jillian's cookies when you go! A cheesy eddies special that does not disappoint! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Cute and queen establishment the staff is extremely friendly and helpful. They have the most outstanding cheesecake you have ever tried. They're completely accommodating to any of your needs. I highly recommend cheesy Eddie's. It is a staple in the Rochester area for years. Hopefully many more years to come. More...

Reviewed on Yelp

The absolutely best cheesecake & carrot cake, we've ever had. I drive an hour and a have several times a year to stock up, it's that good.

Reviewed on Facebook

Delicious cake and cheesecake.. warm and friendly staffs❤️

Reviewed on Google Maps

I thought there wouldn’t be anywhere I could get 12 cupcakes the day of besides a grocery store and I wanted high quality cupcakes- I love cheesy eddies and the people who work there! So helpful and great cupcakes.

Reviewed on Facebook

Best carrot cake in America

Reviewed on Facebook

The best cheesecake anywhere! They have an amazing variety and the staff are always so pleasant.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Great food and great service.

Reviewed on Google Maps

OMG.....ENOUGH SAID!!!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Very good cheesecake and carrot cake. Almost as good as homemade. I would recommend this place to anyone. Parking can be challenging but overall worth it for the items I mentioned.

Reviewed on Google Maps

It's Good, plain and simply put!  The Key Lime Blossom was my favorite item. It was creamy and solid, yet light with an amazing lime flavor that was clearly present but not overpowering.  I was glad to see items other than just slices of cheesecake available for purchase. Also tried the carrot cake which was delicious.  The cheesecake was good as well! With so many flavored slices to choose from, it was hard to pick just 1, but i went with the Apple streusel and it was a great choice. The Apple streusel isn't a wild crazy "over-the-top" flavor as described but As I'm writing this I'm just realizing that their "over-the-top" cheesecakes ( as opposed to classic) just means that there are toppings 'over the top' of the cheesecake, LOL,  not wild outrageous flavors.  Wow, Lol   Definitely will go back if i need a Cheesecake fix our a freshly made dessert! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

As a displaced New Yawker I have to admit that Rochester's lil piece of cheesecake heaven Eddies is quite good and comparable to the legendary Junior's outta Brooklyn. If you need a cheesecake and can't get to Junior's there is no better alternative. More...

Reviewed on Facebook

Love them! First time at the new location. It is just dessert. Love the South Ave shop for tea and dessert.

Reviewed on Facebook

Everything was awesome! We’ll be back soon.

Reviewed on Facebook

Best Cheese cake in Rochester NY

Reviewed on Facebook

By far the best cake in Rochester!!

Reviewed on Facebook

The best

Reviewed on Google Maps

All that needs to be said...YUMMY!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best cheese cake and carrot cake in Rochester! Hands down

Reviewed on Google Maps

Best cheesecakes I've ever had.

Reviewed on Google Maps

The most amazing carrot cake and, not to mention every kind of cheesecake, in the world!

Reviewed on Facebook

Great cheesecake!

Reviewed on Google Maps

If you are looking for a decadent fare, Cheesy Eddie's won't disappoint you! Their cakes are exquisite. While the carrot cake from Cheesy Eddie's is the best carrot cake that I have ever eaten, my all time favorite is their chocolate log cake. It have a generous portion of chocolate but it is extremely light! More...

Reviewed on Yelp

Divine Cheesecake and Jillian's Delights!! Stop by either the original South Ave location or the New place at 900 Jefferson Rd in the Regional Market!!

Reviewed on Facebook

Amazing baked goods and friendly staff. What more could you ask?

Reviewed on Google Maps

The nutella hazelnut cheesecake was to die for! Just the right amount of creamy. Will definitely go back.

Reviewed on Google Maps

The most delicious carrot cake and oatmeal cookies!!!

Reviewed on Facebook

Best cake in the state!

Reviewed on Google Maps

Wonderful place to go. Very friendly and deserts are Great!!!! Always fresh.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Awesome cheesecake. Great customer service

Reviewed on Google Maps