Loading...

Please wait ...

C

Calista West - Private Jeweler + Fine Jewelry Designers

Nantucket, Massachusetts

(28)
This professional is currently unavailable.
You can request reply and they will reach out as soon as they can.

Reviews (28)

Leave a review
5/5

28 customer reviews

Loading...
1 April 2023

Calista was a delight to work with. She was able to recreate a very special piece we’d been looking for for years. She really listens and she works within your budget. Can’t recommend her highly enough!

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 April 2023

As someone who is a complete novice at all things jewelry, Calista's guidance and help was invaluable. She was easy to work with, responsive and thoughtful about her recommendations. I would, and have already, recommended her to anyone I know who's looking for a jeweler! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 March 2023

Best Jeweler on Island!!!!

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 September 2022

Calista is wonderful to work with and I cannot recommend her enough! Her knowledge and personality instantly made me comfortable that she was the right jeweler to work with for an engagement ring even with doing it all via phone/email. My fiancé follows her on instagram which also helped simplify the process. Everyone always tells me I did a great job selecting a ring and I have Calista to thank for that! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 August 2022

My husband found Calista on instagram and I'm so happy he did! As it was his first major diamond purchase, he had a lot of questions which she patiently went through. Also, thanks to Covid, selecting a stone was a bit more involved, but Calista was super flexible and available over facetime. Because he had such a good experience (and because my ring is gorgeous!), we went with her for our wedding bands as well. I immediately understood why my husband went with her; she's warm, knowledgeable about her craft, and so easy to work with. Love my rings; thank you Calista! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 August 2022

Calista was recommended when shopping for my wedding band and I was so happy with the process working with her to buy my wedding bands. Her knowledge and expertise stood out to me so when I needed to reset my engagement ring, I immediately reached out to Calista for help. We also had an heirloom ring so I sent both rings to her to see if we could incorporate the heirloom diamonds somehow. We talked about ideas and my likes/dislikes and I felt like she understood exactly what I wanted. She designed a beautiful Toi Et Moi ring that blew me away and perfectly incorporated both rings - it was better than I could have imagined! My ring is stunning and I am so thankful to have worked with Calista on my ring reset. She is always so wonderful to work with - she is responsive, honest, and creates incredible custom jewelry. Whether you need something new or redone, you are local or across the country (like I am), you will ALWAYS be in great hands with Calista. I am a happy customer and will always go to Calista in the future! Thank you, Calista! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 July 2022

I could not be happier that I found and chose to work with Calista when designing my fiancée’s engagement ring. Within ten minutes of our first meeting I felt totally comfortable and had complete trust that Calista would guide me through the process with expertise and integrity. The end result is perfect - my fiancée is over the moon and constantly gets compliments on her ring. Calista, thank you for your patience and thoughtful guidance as I made this huge decision. We can’t wait to work with you again for our wedding bands! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Looking forward to another visit. I saw some absolutely beautiful unique jewelry. Owner super pleasant to work with. Definitely make an appointment with Calista.

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista has helped me with an engagement ring and wedding bands so far. She is absolutely amazing! Here are some reasons why: - She is easy to work (patient and always accommodating) - She is very helpful (she knows what she is talking about and provides great advice) - Her work is amazing and of the highest quality. Highly recommend her services!

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista is the best jeweler I’ve ever worked with. My wife and I love our rings! In addition, she has also taken great care of two of my friends. Thank you Calista!

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista is unbelievable! She worked closely with me to pick the perfect stone and guided me until it was perfectly finished. We initially had stones shipped to me but then decided to view them in person to really get it right. I'm thrilled with the finished product. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista assisted me with designing an engagement ring and was an absolute pleasure to work with... she made the process of choosing the right diamond along with designing a ring my fiancé would absolutely love a breeze! She offered a variety of options for both stones and ring styles and was extremely helpful in providing guidance based on her years of expertise. I highly recommend Calista to any man who wants to get it right when making this big decision! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

“My boyfriend proposed to me last night! Needless to say, I am filled with elation and joy… God is so good! The word beautiful is an understatement when it comes to my ring. Oh my goodness, it is simply perfect. Calista’s impeccable level of ethics, keen eye, and incredible taste, coupled with how warm and patient she is, has made our engagement jewelry selection memories all the more special. Exceeding expectations, the best of the very best, we are beyond thrilled to have developed a concierge jeweler relationship with Calista and look forward to many years ahead together. Without hesitation, we emphatically recommend Calista for a truly exceptional experience. ” - Marcella McSorley More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista helped me recreate something old that I didn’t love or wear into a few beautiful pieces that I’m now cherishing on a daily basis. I had never done something like this before and she was more than just an expert guiding me in the process. She was so personable, and my appointment with her felt more like chatting with one of my best girlfriends than a business transaction. Every step of the way she was communicative, honest, and helpful. I will absolutely work with Calista again in the future! (Thanks again! ☺️) More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

I am SO glad we chose Calista to make my engagement ring. She found me the exact diamond I was looking for (which was very specific) and helped me pick the perfect setting. My husband also loves the look and feel of his wedding band. She has also helped me reset and redesign several heirloom pieces, which have all turned out to be stunning. Calista is extremely knowledgeable, super sweet, and such a pleasure to do business with. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Working with Calista was a dream! She was professional, knowledgable, and made my vision come to life while designing my engagement ring reset. The whole process was quick, seamless, and fun! My ring came out more beautifully than I could have imagined. I can't wait to work with Calista on the rest of my jewelry wish list! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista is a dream to work with! After purchasing jewelry from her in the past, I approached her last year with the task of taking some family heirloom rings and re-making them into a new, fresh and more cohesive set. She far exceeded my expectations. She worked with me to determine the type of product I was looking for (I was unsure at first), educated me and gave her advice, and communicated each step of the process. The final product is absolutely gorgeous. I have recommended Calista to friends and would continue to recommend Calista over and over for her amazing work. The attention to detail that goes into each piece, the process and the final product - I can't say enough good things. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista is fantastic. She carefully considered all of our requests and answered all of our questions in the process of designing our rings. We were thrilled with her work and highly recommend her to anyone interested in a customized experience! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista was a joy to work with! My boyfriend (soon fiancé!) and I worked with Calista to design an engagement ring and the experience was wonderful from setting up the appointment to choosing the diamond and ring setting. Calista walked us through the custom design process and provided all the information needed for us to make an informed choice about the diamond. She had several ring styles to try on and a selection of diamonds with various cuts to choose from. I never felt rushed to make a decision and was able to take all the time needed to find the right style. She answered all our questions in great detail and made us feel at ease throughout the entire visit. Calista listened to our wishes and feedback, and was able to deliver samples in a timely fashion. We feel especially lucky to have found Calista! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista is not only an expert in her field but also a delight to work with as well. Your time with her is solely yours, you truly feel like she is a private jeweler working exclusively for you. She goes above and beyond to seek out the highest quality of stones and presents settings and styles that can be tried on so you know exactly what the finished, custom product will look like. My first pieces from her were stackable diamond bands, so it was only natural that she would be the one to design my engagement ring. The emerald cut ring my fiancé designed alongside Calista is custom down to the smallest detail, and having worked with me in the past with other pieces, she was able to create the ring of my dreams even though the engagement ring was a surprise. She is vested in her clients styles and wishes, and the process is never rushed. From there she hand selected diamonds for my eternity wedding band which perfectly compliments the engagement ring, and she helped us select my husbands band. Calista examines every component of each piece and has the highest standards for her designs, only perfection will do. From engagement rings to reimagined heirloom pieces, or for something new to add to your collection like tennis bracelets or earrings, look no further than the talents, passion and expertise Calista provides. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista was wonderful to work with and we couldn't be happier with the final product of the ring. In addition to design, we chose to work with Calista because of the personable approach she brought to the process. In addition, she went above and beyond to ensure the ring was deliverable on an expedited timeline, something that larger companies indicated wasn't feasible. It truly was a pleasure to work with Calista and we look forward to hopefully working with her again on our wedding bands. 10/10 would recommend again! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Working with Calista was the best decision I could have made. She took the time to teach me about diamonds and the engagement ring industry, showed me about ten different diamonds over two separate sessions, and provided objective and honest guidance as I made a decision. Trust is a huge component of purchasing an engagement ring, and you can certainly trust Calista. I would recommend her to anyone interested in buying a diamond. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista was an absolute pleasure to work with. She helped me through the process of designing and ordering my (now wife’s) engagement ring and wedding gift. She was patient and worked with me through each step in the process. Her customer service was second to none and the ring was better than I could have imagined. I will absolutely continue to use Calista in the future and will recommend her to all my friends and family. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

I had a great experience working with Calista. She walked me through all of the intricacies of the ring and the process that goes with it. She was extremely accessible and answered any questions that popped up in the process. The actual ring came out amazing and my now Fiancé loves the result since she was completely surprised and wasn't aware of the cut we eventually went with. I would recommend Calista to anyone who is looking to purchase an engagement ring and I can say with confidence we will be going back to her for the wedding band. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

We truly cannot recommend Calista West enough! Her innate way of establishing immediate rapport and trust made our experience feel so comfortable and personalized. Calista’s patience, honesty, decisiveness, keen eye, and overall classic aesthetic was key in helping us find the most remarkable diamond while also being conscientious of our budget. She was incredibly attentive, responsive, and there was no pressure at all as we able to move forward at our own pace. To think that we were able to garner a relationship so quickly after only a few email exchanges and a couple of in-person appointments is a testament to her devoted approach. It is with certainty that Calista West will be our only private jeweler for years to come! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

Calista is one of a kind. I’ve never been more comfortable purchasing jewelry as I was with her. We were welcome to her shop to purchase our wedding rings where we got to try on multiple settings. She talked to us about fits and what’s in and what was best for our specific styles. After our session she messaged me privately to talk about inscriptions for my now husbands ring, which was such a special reveal on wedding day. Calista is our go to for jewelry from this point forward and I cannot wait to work with her again. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

1 June 2022

I never thought I was a jewelry person. I used to tell people that I would much rather buy something for the house than a piece of jewelry. .. Then, I stumbled across Calista on Instagram and the rest is history. Calista's work is so incredibly beautiful because she pays attention to the details, she listens carefully to your vision, she's skilled at selecting high quality, GIA-graded diamonds, and she answers the questions you don't even know to ask. 2020 was the year I was supposed to celebrate a milestone birthday and my 10th wedding anniversary with my husband -- instead, we experienced our first lockdown due to a global pandemic. In his effort to mark the significance of the year, my husband suggested it might be time to replace my engagement ring (the original broke). Even though I knew we'd be committing to a virtual process, Calista was the first person that came to mind and the only jeweler I wanted to work with. After our first phone call with her, we both knew we had made the right choice. I know it sounds ill-advised to commit to such an expensive process knowing we would not have the chance to see the stones or Calista in person, but we knew we could trust Calista, and we were right. Calista has an impeccable eye for quality diamonds, and she knows how to design a setting that will highlight the beauty of the stone. We came to Calista with an idea and she took that idea and helped us understand the nuance of the decisions ahead, walked us through the details, sent us samples and videos, gave us options, and guided us through a clear and simple process. In the end, she delivered a gorgeous one-of-a-kind ring that I can't help but sneak glimpses of throughout the day. It's such a beautiful work of art and I'm so grateful to Calista for helping us skillfully execute our idea. Needless to say, I've been converted. I'm officially a jewelry person, and now also own a custom necklace that I designed in collaboration with Calista. Needless to say, I highly recommend working with Calista. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

4 November 2018

Calista is an amazing private jeweler whether you're starting from a knowledge base of "I'm looking for a diamond" or you're well versed in the 4C's. I purchased an engagement ring from Calista and it turned out amazing! My fiance loves the ring and we went back to Calista to get our wedding bands as well. Thank you Calista! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps