Cafe New Castle

Cute little neighborhood cafe, friendly service, great food.

Reviewed on Google Maps

nice staff great food and bar

Reviewed on Facebook

Food is great, service is good

Reviewed on Google Maps

Bike parking, nice brunch options, local flavor

Reviewed on Google Maps

I love breakfast here it's my go to on weekends! They also serve lunch and dinner and have a nice selection of wine and beer! The atmosphere is welcoming and laidback! Take your date and have a glass of wine! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Original colonial bldg, well prepared menu. Fun experience.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Don't order the roasted beet and fresh orange spinach salad-unless you ask first about the beets and oranges. What I received was canned beets and canned Mandarin oranges in my salad. Otherwise it was good. My husband had fried grouper sandwich and he said it was good. The place was trendy and clean. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

highly recommend for date night or special occasion. food was fantastic service was great and the atmosphere was phenomenal

Reviewed on Facebook

I was frolicking in New Castle and happened to have stumbled upon this cute little cafe. The food and service were excellent and I met some cool people there. I definitely recommend going!

Reviewed on Facebook

Great place, great food, great service

Reviewed on Google Maps

Delicious food and relaxing atmosphere, just a tad overpriced.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Came in during the 4th of July weekend and it was completely empty except us. I asked if they had ice cream - the wait staff said not enough for a scoop and then ended up bringing us a bowl of ice cream on the house. Lucky us!

Reviewed on Google Maps

A nice little getaway from the daily life.

Reviewed on Facebook

Always a pleasure dining here. The food are cooked to perfection and the prices are just OK. I’ve been to here several times and I highly recommend making a reservation!

Reviewed on Google Maps

First visit, no expectations. Our meals were fabulous. Chef Earl cooks lamb to perfection and the crab stuffed flounder was excellent. Attentive and personable staff. Highly recommend dinner. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Came highly recommended from a trustworthy source and didn't disappoint! We sat at a 4 top in the beautifully skylight lit breezeway. All of us thoroughly enjoyed our brunch meals. I had the 414 sandwich - absolutely wonderful. My mates had the fillet Benedict, blueberry French toast, and the Monte Cristo. We all had to share due to how good everything was! The ambiance was on par for a frenchie cafe. And the best part, our server, Leif. Had great stories on the history of the building, life, and the menu options! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Nice place.. good food. Great drinks. I'm looking forward to going back.

Reviewed on Google Maps

I love coming here with my Girlfriend. Its relaxing, the staff is extremely nice, and the food is amazing. If you're ever in the area, this is a must go.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Our party of four, fortunately likes to share, so we were all able to experience 4 different delicious menu items on our visit. Everything was fresh and tasty! Great ambiance in the dinning hall. The outside seating looked nice as well, but we sat in the breezeway, nice and bright from all the skylights. Our server, Leif, rounded out our experience; he is knowledgeable about the menu, where the products come from, and the history of the building - and a great deal of other interesting things! Leif, congratulations on getting your degree, but I don't wish you so much success that you won't stay on for at least one shift a week! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Waffles were excellent, light and airy. They ran out of any of their Benedicts (which are supposed to be amazing), but the Reuben is fantastic and I had a bloody Mary which was delicious.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Food is excellent and staff are friendly and attentive. Good quality coffee and ingredients, would recommend at any time of day.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Good poached pear salad and turkey chili. Nice airy atmosphere. Friendly and informative staff. Good breakfast, brunch, and lunch spot in historic New Castle.

Reviewed on Google Maps

This place is fantastic. A perfect fit for old newcastle. I am so very excited to have stumbled upon it. I feel at home and its the first time Ive been here.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Love this place for either a nice little sit down meal or a grab and go. We've stopped in several times and each time the food is delicious (highly recommend the veggie eggs Benedict) and the coffee on par hot or iced. Service is always friendly as well. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Food was delicious. Loved the ambience. Very nice staff. Will definitely visit again.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Cozy place, great back patio (weather permitting), food was delicious, and location was great, just a few blocks from the water. Service was very friendly, I'll definitely go back. Close to local college too! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Love this place! I get the omelets. Their sausage is maple flavoured and delicious. Very filling. Staff is very sweet.

Reviewed on Google Maps

Sorry I didn't take pics, but wow it was delicious. It's a small, trendy place in historic New Castle with an outside eating area (as well) in the back. At our table we had turkey chili, cheese ravioli in an Alfredo sauce (forgot the dish name), and crab cakes. Excellent! For dessert my daughter picked oatmeal cookies that they served warm with a dollop of homemade whipped cream. The service is friendly. I'll go again.
Edit-the pics posted are from my second visit, which includes the ravioli, which the chef happily prepared my request to include crab meat. Delicious. More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

We had friends coming from out of town, and decided to try out the new restaurant, but we didn't have high expectations. We were surprised and delighted by our experience at Cafe New Castle. The service was superior from beginning to end. The cocktails were both clever and delicious. Dinner itself was sophisticated simplicity, extraordinarily well conceived, prepared and presented. Well done, Cafe New Castle! We will be back soon! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps

Wow! Great coffee, great service, great food. We stopped by expecting to grab a cup of coffee and ended up ordering brunch (they serve breakfast, brunch, and lunch depending on time of day. Aesthetics are beautiful. Atmosphere ❤️. Highly recommend this spot for anyone heading to Old New Castle! More...

Reviewed on Google Maps