Please wait ...

Reviews (37)

Leave a review

Angela Baldassarre

23 May 2019

Great food and great bands!! Definitely recommend it! Manager is very nice


Diane Goldman

14 April 2019

Love the Yu your day sttyr yyyyyttt


Lisa Coppola

13 April 2019

Wonderful food in a unique location, a train station. The guy who books the talent has ears. All in all, a winner.


Ron Cardazone

24 March 2019

A great place to see live music while having good food and drinks!


Lauren Del Priore

24 February 2019

First visit here but won’t be our last. Food was great and atmosphere was fun and very different. It is located in the Short Hills train station. Give it a try. You won’t be disappointed.. More...


Art Ritter

11 February 2019

Lots of fun. Food is really good. If you need a Taxi would call 973-539-2500.


Marlene Hatoff Warner

4 November 2018

Great food & entertainment NxStage!!!!!!


Jo-Anne Callahan

14 October 2018

really great all around! staff was very attentive and helpful without making us feel rushed. outdoor space was warm and cozy!


Steven Siegel

20 September 2018

Boxcar is always a fun time! Great live music too!


Jason Rothfeld

30 August 2018

Excellent food, waiters are always super nice and the drinks are awesome! Even on weekends they close at 10:45pm, which makes for an early night. Wish they’d stay open till 12, at least on a Saturday. More...


Ben Hand

11 August 2018

From drinks to food this place blows everyone out of the water, the bartender John took great care of us. Highly recommend this establishment


James A Elliot

11 August 2018

This place is Rockstar! Good eats, terrific hospitality. Great pricing and delicious fair. Definitely a good place to visit and have a beer or spirits. The garlic wings are killer man.. They are out of bounds! They make a great burger as well. Try everything here it's all so very good.

Kudos Boxcar Bar & Grill. You made a small group of Transit workers very welcomed.
Thank You..


Dezign Rocky

11 August 2018

Great staff that always shows respect to its customers. Service was excellent from beginning to end. No complaints here. Everyone was In my group was treated like they were part of a family. What a great place to have a meal with friends, family, or even that special someone. Thank you for the wonderful experience will come again! More...


Edward Carroll

1 July 2018



Scott Bandekow

18 June 2018

The burgers were great, service was fantastic, drinks were great, onion rings were terrific! Great place for supper. Come one, come all!


Jenna Despotovich

16 June 2018

The charm of the place, fantastic cocktails and the quirky appeal of the concept of anchoring the train station sum up a pleasing experience for any diner or bar fly. A distinct influence for this review, as i have written few to none, was our server, Kevin. He was personable, knowledgeable, accomodating and professional while being friendly and personable. More...


Tom Gordon

31 May 2018

Eric and his staff do a great job. Tuesday nights they have 1/2 price bottles of wine. The food is great across the board.


Lory Anello

21 February 2018

I discovered this gem yesterday. I had a great pizza and beer. Definitely going back!


Michael Volmar

4 October 2017

Great place to drink and more!


Amy Umansky Kahn

28 May 2017

The grilled porkchops were delicious. I would go back again.


Marcus Em

25 March 2017

Every time I've been to boxcar I've been impressed! The food is always delicious (box car burger is delish) and cooked to perfection . The drinks I've had have been delicious and the staff has always been attentive and welcoming . I've had private events and casual dinners at box car and it's always been amazing! More...


Samantha Vazquez

24 March 2017

My husband and I love going to Box Car! I have never had a meal there that I didn't enjoy. This place not only has the best range of food on the menu, but the staff is always so accommodating!! If I could give more than 5 stars I would. Hands down this is the best restaurant in the area. We had the best date night this week enjoying some signature cocktails, (ordered so many yummy starters), the box car burger and the short ribs are the best I've ever had. We can't wait to go back!!! More...


Stuart Gantman

23 March 2017

A really cool venue for a restaurant. If just going for a drink ( or 2) or dinner , you'll love the food and ambiance. Service was excellent. Great for kid's or grown up parties. Enjoy! More...


John Tibbetts

26 February 2017

The General Manager came to my table to ask my wife and I how everything was going... He gave us some history about the bar and other things to do while we were visiting this great town! Thank you for your hospitality Eric! More...


Steven Siegel

18 January 2017

Love the boxcar. Nice vibe, good food, and awesome live music. Bar taps change often so always good beers to try. And my fav meal are the fish tacos! Yum!


Rich Catalano

11 December 2016

First Time there.. Food was great and service was Spot On.. Holly the Bartender �


Chris Marchant

31 August 2016

A great place for something to eat, and hear "live" music. Make a good drink , too!


John Currier

26 July 2016

The management is great. So friendly and helpful. Go on down you'll love that atmosphere.


James A Elliot

30 November 2015

This place is Rockstar! Good eats, terrific hospitality. Great pricing and delicious fair. Definitely a good place to visit and have a beer or spirits. The garlic wings are killer man.. They are out of bounds! They make a great burger as well. Try everything here it's all so very good. More...


Peter Buro

29 October 2015

Great atmosphere! Great place to hang, city feel but in the burbs-


Rick Winowski

27 October 2015

Great place for food and drinks ...cool atmosphere....great service..!


Mark Zacharia

2 June 2015

The Boxcar Signature burger is a delightful combination of flavors; the fries are among the best you'll ever taste, and the service is top-notch. Chef Eric truly has a winner here.


Art Ritter

5 February 2015

Good Food. Nice Bar. Really Nice Place to Eat. Right at the Train Station.


Robert L Tennard Jr

20 December 2014

Great food. Great atmosphere. Waitstaff was super friendly. If you looking for someplace new hip and happening, The Boxcar is the place to go!


Rob Mcmanus

7 November 2014

This place rocks!


Karen Eastman Bigos

28 January 2014

This is a fun local bar to grab a drink with friends, and live music is often featured in the pub. No kids hang out here (after dinner), lots of moms and dads who grab lunch, dinner or food after work. The outdoor patio is great for family dining, watching the trains go by and you can even tie up your friendly dog on the other side of the gate. Many people come back to meet here when they have Millburn High School reunions. The place has a lot of historic charm, and you can't beat half-priced bottles of wine on Tuesday nights. Thanks to manager Eric Linehan for always taking good care of us when we are here. More...


Marco Anzalone

2 December 2013

Thanks to the Boxcar Bar & Grill for hosting The Red Light Ban last night. The food and drinks were great!

Photos (1)

See all