Please wait ...

Reviews (11)

Leave a review

Megan Callaghan

25 April 2019

Bartleby & Sage has done the catering for my nonprofit client's gala two years in a row. The food is delicious and receives so much positive praise from the guests. The staff is professional and extremely perceptive to feedback -- they were even better this year than last. Rachael worked with me and the rental company to be sure we had everything on hand to make the night flawless. With so many details flying around, I was grateful that she and her team were so on top of everything. I highly recommend Bartleby & Sage! More...


nell postman

25 April 2019

Molly from Bartleby & Sage was amazing to work with. She made my daughter's bat mitzvah planning and event run so smoothly, from our introductory conversation to the high-pressure day of, where she pulled everything together seamlessly. She was creative about helping us save money on a total price - encouraging us to buy bamboo disposable dishes, for instance, renting some benches rather than all chairs, proposing that I buy the wine and liquor license myself. She also helped me figure out a very tricky seating situation when we had many more RSVP's than we had foreseen. The food itself was excellent, and the service during the party flowed very well and naturally. I was so relieved to see her take charge there so I could focus on enjoying the beautiful day. I recommend her and B&S very highly. More...


Dale Levine

25 January 2019

We hired Bartleby & Sage to cater our 200+ person, brunch wedding at 26 Bridge in Dumbo, Brooklyn. Rachael was our point person and she was amazing to work with. She really understood our vision and put together a menu proposal that was exactly what we wanted. She then stayed on top of every single detail every step of the way. Their team is creative and talented. The food was delicious and looked amazing. They helped us create a cutom bloody mary bar with unique toppings that our guests can't stop raving about. We can't say enough good things about them and are hoping to attend future events catered by them! More...


Monica Wolyniec

26 November 2018

Stellar, magical, beyond efficient from Moment 1! Leslie and the Bartleby & Sage (Dream) Team were not only accommodating but knew how to talk - and LISTEN -to us and all of our suppliers. Moving beyond that, the art/taste/design/planning behind each and every culinary creation speaks for itself - you feel the heart and soul that go into every recipe, every idea. Their experience also helped iron out and polish every last question or detail we needed to feel ready and comfortable for our big day. My husband (!!) and I worked with Leslie, Ramon, Hans and Rachael. Each really took the time to listen to what we were looking for in order to come up with the best solution/dish/recommendation/schedule. They proceeded to get things done behind the scenes without a hitch. TRUE professionals! Our favorites were (savory) Fish Tacos and the lamb chops were the overall crowd favorite + (sweet) the mini lemon meringue pots along with our wedding cake (fresh summer berries in a whipped mascarpone cream on a light sponge cake) MMM to the MAX! More...


Rachel Urban

26 November 2018

Barletby & Sage is a truly exceptional catering company. As a planner in the industry, I have accompanied a few clients to tastings with them and their food is always unique and fully customized to each event.I hosted an event recently at The Brooklyn Grange and Leslie pulled through last minute for us and curated a fully custom seasonal menu and the guests raved all evening about the food. Can't say enough how grateful and happy we were!! More...


Benjamin Teo

28 August 2018

My company has been working with Bartleby & Sage for about a year now. I did a few tastings here and there with different catering companies and none could come close to compete in terms of taste or value. I would love to recommend them to anyone who wants to do an event, wedding or any excuse to hire them really. We don't use anyone else but Bartleby & Sage now. More...


Renee Shaker

29 July 2018

My firm has worked with Leslie and the Bartleby & Sage team on a number of events over the past 10 years or so and they still hold a top spot in our small list of favorites! (And we've worked with them all.) A season pro who knows her business, Leslie continues to impress with fresh creativity and tasteful innovation that keeps keeps her at the top of her game. My firm (Sine AV Design, Inc.) provides event production to a demanding and sophisticated clientele in art, fashion, fundraising and high-end retail, and I never hesitate to recommend Leslie and B&S whenever I have the opportunity. More...


Joel Troge

29 July 2018

We are happy that we worked with Bartleby & Sage to help plan our wedding! Our guests said the food was fantastic and they really worked with us to create a menu that was unique and special to our occasion. It was a great choice!


Jose Perez

29 July 2018

Was looking for an inexpensive menu for my wedding, Bartleby & Sage has a great drop-off menu that fit our pricing. Leslie and Molly were so quick with their replies to my questions and very helpful. I will be recommending them to friend's and family for their catering needs. More...


Carla Nicdao

29 June 2018

Worked with Bartleby & Sage for a recent event with about 350 attendees. There's so many wonderful things to say about this company from their service, quality of food, and professionalism. Everything went seamlessly and Leslie exceeded all of my expectations. The staff was professional, courteous, and on time. They made sure to stay till the very end to make sure everything was packed up to my client and the venue's liking. Would definitely use them again for future events! More...


Jillian Pagano

10 July 2017

Bartleby and Sage catered our wedding June 17, 2017 and they were a true pleasure to work with from start to finish. Leslie was attentive, detail-oriented and impressively organized. What stood out to us the most was her enthusiasm to create a menu based on where we were from, our family heritage and our favorite foods. And the execution of the menu was true to form. It was exactly as we had tasted at our tasting and we are still receiving complements about the menu.

Without having a true wedding planner, Leslie took the lead making sure everything went smoothly the day of the wedding. Greta, her assistant was also a great help and pleasure. We would highly recommend Leslie and her catering company for any couple looking for a reliable, easy to work with caterer.

Photos (10)

See all